JD Vance’s shameless lies have terrorized Springfield
The claim by Donald Trump and JD Vance that Haitian immigrants are stealing and eating pets in Springfield, Ohio, invites comparison with another fear-provoking mega-hoax: the infamous 1938 radio performance of “War of the Worlds” by Orson Welles, which used the format of a news report.
“Those strange beings who landed in the Jersey farmlands tonight,” a CBS radio announcer breathlessly told listeners on Halloween Eve, “are the vanguard of an invading army from the planet Mars.” The performance frightened listeners across the country, who hysterically called police departments, radio stations and newspaper offices, and even got out their shotguns. But it had no lasting impact beyond the single national fright night.
The pet-eating hoax, on the other hand, could conceivably affect the presidential election (half of Trump voters believe it). Vance first made the claim, and Trump amplified it at the presidential debate, using a “War of the Worlds”-style frantic, present-tense description of Haitians invading Springfield. “They’re eating the dogs. The people that came in, they’re eating the cats. They’re eating...they’re eating the pets of the people that live there.” And then more falsehoods: “They’re taking the geese.”
Ohio Republican Gov. Mike DeWine called the pet-eating claims “garbage.” When asked for evidence, Vance’s staff provided a police report filed by a Springfield resident named Anna Kilgore in which she accused her Haitian neighbors of taking her cat, Miss Sassy. But Kilgore later told a Wall Street Journal reporter that, after filing the report, she had found Miss Sassy, uneaten and in good health, in her basement. Kilgore apologized to the Haitian community.
Here’s the difference between Trump and Vance. Trump never concedes that he makes anything up, even when he’s caught red-handed lying about objective matters such as his crowd sizes or winning Michigan’s “Man of the Year Award,” when no evidence of such an award exists (or that he won the 2020 election).
Vance, on the other hand, is willing to acknowledge lying if he can spin it as a patriotic act. “If I have to create stories so that the American media actually pays attention to the suffering of the American people,” Vance said regarding the pet-eating lies, “then that’s what I’m going to do.”
The stories “created” by Trump and Vance have turned the city of Springfield, the alleged victim in their fictional narrative, upside down. The Haitians have boosted Springfield’s economy by filling vacant jobs in businesses and factories, but they have also strained the city’s services. Tensions rose in the city when a child died in a school bus accident involving a Haitian driver, who was later sentenced to prison. But only after Trump and Vance spread their pet-eating falsehoods did Springfield become a terrorized city.
Dozens of bomb threats forced the shutdown of Springfield’s government buildings, lockdowns at two hospitals and the evacuation of elementary schools. State highway policemen had to be posted in each of Springfield’s public schools and security tower cameras were put up. The city cancelled its annual two-day CultureFest “for the safety of our residents.”
Haitians in Springfield have stayed off the streets. “I am really scared for my kids right now,” Bianca Daniels, a beauty supply owner from Haiti, told a reporter.
Let’s be honest about what’s going on here. To JD Vance, if Springfield has to be terrorized by pet-eating lies for the good of his and Trump’s electoral prospects, so be it.
Gregory J. Wallance was a federal prosecutor in the Carter and Reagan administrations and a member of the ABSCAM prosecution team, which convicted a U.S. senator and six representatives of bribery. He is the author of “Into Siberia: George Kennan’s Epic Journey Through the Brutal, Frozen Heart of Russia.”
Date: |
Topics
-
The Guardian - World
John Oliver on JD Vance’s Springfield claims: ‘He’s pretty good at parroting racist lies’
Last Week Tonight host discusses Vance’s lies about Haitian immigrants and social security disability benefits issues. John Oliver opened Sunday’s Last Week Tonight with an excoriation of Donald ...Yesterday -
The New York Times - Top stories
What Pete Buttigieg Learned Playing JD Vance
The politician discusses how Democrats can rebuild trust.7 hours ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
JD Vance to Appear With Tucker Carlson, Who Amplified False Holocaust Claims
The Republican vice-presidential nominee will share a stage with Mr. Carlson, who was criticized for interviewing a writer who falsely claimed the Holocaust was not an intentional act of genocide.2 days ago -
NBC News - Politics
Vance says allegations against Mark Robinson 'aren't necessarily reality'
Sen. JD Vance reacted to the bombshell report about Mark Robinson, the Republican candidate for governor in North Carolina, saying that the allegations against Robinson "aren't necessarily reality."2 days ago -
NBC News - Politics
JD Vance says allegations against Mark Robinson 'aren't necessarily reality'
Sen. JD Vance reacted for the first time to the bombshell report about Mark Robinson, the Republican candidate for governor in North Carolina, saying that the allegations against Robinson "aren't ...2 days ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
Mike DeWine: I Don’t Recognize the Springfield That Trump and Vance Describe
I have lived my entire life near this city. Our people and our history deserve better than to be falsely portrayed.3 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Trump and Vance’s Springfield smear is a microcosm of their entire campaign | Sidney Blumenthal
The Republicans desperately need to distract voters away from abortion. They’ve now found the perfect new scapegoat. After Donald Trump ’s disastrous debate with Kamala Harris on 10 September he ...4 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Ohio’s Republican governor condemns Trump and Vance for Springfield claims
Mike DeWine criticizes pair in New York Times op-ed for repeating racist claims about Haitian immigrants. Ohio’s Republican governor, Mike DeWine, on Friday criticized former US president Donald ...3 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Ohio GOP governor in NYT: 'I don't recognize the Springfield that Trump and Vance describe'
Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine (R) is attempting to paint a different picture of Springfield and its "rich history" than the one portrayed by false claims from former President Trump and his running mate, ...4 days ago - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
ESG pseudo-science gets brutally debunked
State laws requiring public funds to be invested with financial institutions focused on financial performance have debunked the myth that such laws increase costs, as other states without such laws ...23 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: House Democratic Party leadership hold hearing on Project 2025
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) and other top Democrats are convening a hearing Tuesday to voice shared concerns about the conservative policy agenda known as Project 2025. Democrats ...23 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Zelensky, world leaders address UN General Assembly
(3pm)23 minutes ago - United Nations -
The Hill - Politics
Top Dem says Speaker Johnson can’t be trusted to certify election results
The head of the House Democratic Caucus warned Tuesday that voters should have no faith in Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) to certify this year’s presidential election results because of his role in ...26 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Nebraska governor: No plans for special session on winner-take-all electoral system
Nebraska Gov. Jim Pillen (R) said Tuesday that he would not be calling a special session for lawmakers to consider changing the state’s electoral system to winner-take-all after one key GOP ...37 minutes ago