In Ukraine, Trump and Kellogg must avoid the road to Yalta

It is increasingly clear that retired Army Lt. Gen. Keith Kellogg does not yet have an overall plan to end the war in Ukraine — at least not one that President Trump is willing to support.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio told Megyn Kelly last Friday that the Trump administration believes the war has been fought to a “stalemate,” and that “it is not going to end with the maximalist goals of either" Russia or Ukraine.

Russian President Vladimir Putin disagrees. He remains dead-set on the total destruction of Ukraine and continues to insist on its absolute submission. His advisor Nikolai Patrushev went further: “It can’t be ruled out that Ukraine will cease to exist at all in the coming year.”

The Kremlin believes time is now on its side, especially now that Trump has tasked Kellogg with finding a negotiated solution in 100 days or less.

A quick negotiated solution means ending the war on Putin’s terms. Moscow is still demanding Ukraine's complete capitulation — territorial concessions, Ukrainian neutrality and unilateral disarmament.

Putin is also insisting that Ukraine would have to “give up its pursuit of NATO membership” and accept “extensive limitations on the size of its armed forces and on the kinds of weapons systems it is allowed to possess.”

Each of these is a non-starter for Ukraine.

Essentially, Putin is demanding Kellogg embark on an ill-advised road to a modern-day Yalta Conference. Near the end of World War II, President Franklin Roosevelt and British Prime Minister Winston Churchill effectively conceded Eastern Europe at Yalta to Soviet leader Josef Stalin in exchange for Stalin agreeing to fight Japan. The result? Forty-three years of the Iron Curtain in Europe.

Kellogg needs to channel his inner Gen. George Patton and tell Trump that he is on a road to nowhere with Putin.

The Kremlin is betting on Trump being strategically distracted in the Indo-Pacific — as Roosevelt was at the end of World War II — and getting everything he wants in Eastern Europe and in the Caucasian nations of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia. Putin has made no secret about it.

Russia has repeatedly rejected the Kellogg proposal to freeze the war. Moscow will not accept the presence of European peace-keeping forces in Ukraine. And despite the Ukrainian constitution saying otherwise, Putin considers Zelensky an illegitimate leader, since his presidential term expired last year. As a consequence, he will not negotiate directly with him.

It is therefore ill-advised for Kellogg to urge Ukraine to hold elections after any ceasefire. Moscow is performing poorly on the battlefield but excels at election interference. Recent elections in Moldova, Georgia and Romania are highly dispositive, a foreshadowing of what would come.

Meanwhile, Putin is continuing his assault on Ukraine.

Over the weekend, Russia launched ballistic missiles on Odesa’s historic city center, a UNESCO designated World Heritage site. Multiple historic buildings were damaged and seven people were injured. Norwegian diplomats visiting the city narrowly escaped the strikes. In March 2024, Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis also avoided a missile strike in Odesa within 500 meters of his convoy.

Kellogg, for now, is struggling to set conditions for any meaningful negotiations. Putin is clearly waiting for a face-to-face meeting with Trump in what he hopes becomes a second Yalta-like conference.

Wittingly or not, Kellogg is trapped in a Monty Hall-like "Let’s Make a Deal" modus operandi of his own making — as opposed to a more forceful "this is what you are going to do" approach to Putin and his cronies in the Kremlin. This peace deal is more in the short-term interests of the U.S. and not the victim — Ukraine.

Presently, Kellogg has no negotiating leverage. There are signs that may change. On Monday, Trump announced that he wants Ukraine to repay the U.S. with rare earth minerals valued at “close to $300 billion.” Kellogg would be wise to remind Trump that parts of the illegally Russian-occupied Donbas are rich in natural resources.

Indeed, according to The Washington Post, the Donbas “harbors some of the world’s largest reserves of titanium and iron ore, fields of untapped lithium and massive deposits of coal. Collectively, they are worth tens of trillions of dollars.”

So Ukraine is more than capable of paying its way forward. It is time Kellogg reminded Putin of that reality.

But Putin will get that message only to the extent that his nose is bloodied on the battlefield. He survived Biden’s "just enough" war in Ukraine, and now he believes he can outlast Trump.

Kellogg can disabuse Putin of that notion by empowering the armed forces of Ukraine to take the fight to the Russians, and to do so now.

Russia has been severely militarily weakened. After nearly three years of war, Putin has suffered an estimated 841,660 casualties — 48,240 in January alone — and combined tens of thousands of tanks, armored fighting vehicles, artillery systems, multiple rocket launch systems, aircraft, helicopters, warships and vehicles.

The only way for Kellogg to create decisive negotiating leverage and stop the killing in Ukraine is to defeat Russia and drive it out of the country. That involves the use of all the instruments on national power: diplomatic, information, military and economy, or DIME.

New sanctions, coordinating with OPEC to drive down the cost of oil, and targeting shadow fleets alone will not bring Putin to the negotiating table. The hammer — the punch to the face — must come from the military instrument of national power. While Ukraine is effectively targeting oil refineries, they must take pressure off their front-line units in the close fight, and that requires interdiction.

This entails targeting Russian, North Korean and Chechen forces, their equipment, weapons, ammunition, fuel, supplies in Russia before they enter Ukraine. It means targeting them in their assembly areas, at the seaports, airports, and railheads, ammunition storage areas and fuel depots. Only when Putin feels threatened with the loss of his army will he come to the negotiating table — sanctions will not do that.

Putin will negotiate with Kellogg, but only when he is made to realize he has truly lost on the battlefields of Ukraine.

Anything less, and it is likely Yalta 2.0 whenever Putin and Trump meet. And a new Iron Curtain will fall.

Col. (Ret.) Jonathan Sweet served 30 years as a military intelligence officer. Mark Toth writes on national security and foreign policy.

Topics

Trump pardons founder of Silk Road drugs website

US president says Ross Ulbricht was victim of ‘weaponisation of government’
Financial Times - Jan. 22
Trump pardons Silk Road creator Ross Ulbricht

President Trump grants full pardon to Silk Road founder Ross Ulbricht, early bitcoin advocate.
CNBC - Jan. 22
Trump pardons Silk Road founder Ross Ulbricht

Libertarian activists, who generally oppose criminal drug policies, argued the government overreached in building its case against Ross Ulbricht and the dark web marketplace Silk Road.
CBS News - Jan. 22
Trump pardons Silk Road founder Ross Ulbricht

President Trump said Tuesday he had signed a full pardon for Ross Ulbricht, the founder of the scandalous online marketplace Silk Road, fulfilling a campaign promise Trump had made to Libertarian ...
The Hill - Jan. 22
Canada avoids Trump's tariffs - for now

President Donald Trump stopped short of imposing tariffs on Canada on day one but said they may come as soon as 1 February.
BBC News - Jan. 21
Ukraine Braces for Trump’s Return

Soldiers and civilians alike say that after so much loss, the new U.S. president must push for a just settlement, not peace at any cost.
The New York Times - Jan. 19
3 Teams Jonathan Toews Must Avoid In NHL Return

Former Chicago Blackhawks captain Jonathan Toews should avoid these NHL teams if he comes back.
Yahoo Sports - Jan. 17
FA Cup upset watch: Arsenal aim to avoid surprise by Man United; Everton must watch out for Peterborough

The FA Cup always delivers upset, but which teams need to be on alert this week?
CBS Sports - Jan. 9
In their final meeting, Zelenskyy, Austin say military aid to Ukraine must continue

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and U_S_ Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin used their final meeting in Germany to press the incoming Trump administration to not give up on Kyiv’s fight, ...
ABC News - Jan. 9