In Syria, the US can help rebuild while supplanting Russian influence
The fall of Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad creates a once-in-a-generation opportunity to reshape the balance of power in the Middle East. The weaponry that American policymakers can wield for that rebalance are not bombs, but commerce.
Washington needs a plan to create conditions for future U.S. investment to stabilize Syria — and to make sure Russia doesn’t regain a foothold. If policymakers can smartly and strategically work with American businesses and other partners, the U.S. can blunt Russian influence in Syria and Vladimir Putin’s plans to project power in the Middle East, Europe and Africa.
It essential for the U.S. to act now. While Russia’s position in Syria has weakened, it is now likely to double-down on cementing its place in the country. As a permanent member of the U.N. Security Council and a signatory to the U.N. resolution that outlines a post-Assad transition, Russia has diplomatic influence in negotiations. Nor has Russia entirely vacated its military bases in Syria. Ahmed al-Sharaa, Syria’s current de facto leader, noted “deep strategic” interests between Russia and Syria.
Russia will likely to try leveraging its business ties. After Russia’s military intervention in Syria in late 2015 to rescue Assad, Russian companies (along with the paramilitary group Wagner, now rebranded as AfricaCorp) gained access to Syria’s resources, including energy, phosphates and telecommunications. Russia stands to lose billions in investments in Syria, along with loans to the Assad regime.
Any American plan to counter Russia must start with sanctions. Washington enclosed the Assad regime within a tight network of various sanctions; revoking them all will take years, but discussion is now underway for issuing waivers and licenses to encourage economic development and foreign investment in Syria. On Jan. 6, the Treasury Department issued additional sanctions relief. If early waivers are issued for humanitarian reasons, U.S. officials must ensure Russia cannot take advantage of any loopholes in the sanctions regime, including through use of shell companies and other third parties that can be hard to trace.
The U.S. must also be proactive and go beyond sanctions. Washington can do this by empowering Ukrainians and other partners to help rebuild Syria. Indeed, President Volodymyr Zelensky has already expressed an eagerness to do so. The U.S. can respect the existing sanctions regime while helping to identify what assistance Ukrainians and other partners need to work in Syria in a way that empowers them and shuts Russia out.
Until recently, Russia was the largest provider of wheat to Syria — grain that Russia largely stole from Ukraine. With Assad’s fall, Russia’s supplies have been suspended. The U.S., in partnership with American firms, should make sure that Ukrainian wheat reaches Syria. Later on, it should expand that option to other commercial interests, like telecommunications, shutting out Russia.
Lastly, the U.S. could build a better public messaging campaign, also potentially with help from the private sector, to highlight what America and its partners are doing to help Syria. In previous years, America often did not label humanitarian aid for fear of Assad’s retribution. The U.S. didn’t care about getting credit; it prioritized helping the Syrian people. Now is the time to also start getting credit.
No one should have any illusions. Helping Syria will be very difficult. But the U.S. has been the top provider of humanitarian aid to Syria over the years, with over $17 billion in humanitarian relief since 2011. If the U.S. has succeeded in getting aid to Syria with Assad in control, surely it can go beyond aid now that Assad is gone and Russia (and Iran) are losing sway. Top Russian officials often travel to foreign countries with business delegations. Moscow understands the importance of commercial ties in politics. The U.S. can beat Putin at his own game.
American credibility is on the line. Beyond that, failing to support Syria will cost the U.S. more in Ukraine. American policymakers have long said Russia must not be allowed to profit from Assad’s war crimes. Over the years, Russian officials cried crocodile tears about humanitarian suffering in Syria while Putin helped Assad bomb his own civilians. Moscow has been able to repeat its crimes in Ukraine on an even larger scale. That will continue unless the price to Russia becomes high enough.
The Russians are currently betting that Washington will simply give up on the Middle East — and the U.S. would lose face around the world if Moscow is proven right. If Russia entrenches a commercial presence in Syria, it will use economic gains to fund its war effort in Ukraine, likely raising the costs for the West, as it would need to give Ukraine more aid in response. Moscow will also use its presence in Syria to build influence across the region.
Putin doesn’t want peace for the world — he wants chaos. Russia has already succeeded in undermining world trade, destabilizing economies and regimes for its own power. Putin started the largest armed conflict in Europe soil since World War II when he invaded Ukraine. There is no pretending now that the Ukraine war is an isolated conflict.
Yes, it is the Syrian people who must build their own future. Yet the stability of that future would be far more secure with the help of the world’s dominant economic superpower. The U.S. has a remarkable opportunity to regain its influence throughout the Middle East by resisting Moscow’s attempts to install itself at the center of a new world order. Allowing Russian dominance in Syria will only assure further chaos and war.
Anna Borshchevskaya is the Harold Grinspoon Senior Fellow at the Washington Institute and the author of “Putin’s War in Syria: Russian Foreign Policy and the Price of America’s Absence.”
-
Economists Are in the Wilderness. Can They Find a Way Back to Influence?
Economists have long helped to shape policy on issues like taxes and health care. But flawed forecasts and arcane language have cost them credibility.The New York Times - 2d -
Arab States Race Turkey for Influence in New Syria
Saudi Arabia and others are overlooking the new leadership’s jihadist past, hoping to gain an advantage on rivals in the strategically positioned country.The Wall Street Journal - 2d -
Former Blackhawks Who Would've Helped Team Avoid a Rebuild
There is a lot of talented former Blackhawks around the league that didn't all need to leave.Yahoo Sports - 23h -
US and UK toughens sanctions on Russian oil industry
The actions are aimed at cutting off revenue Moscow is using to fund its war in Ukraine.BBC News - 1d -
The UN wants to influence a pluralist Syria – but will the country listen?
Syrians are suspicious after allegations of complicity with the brutal Assad regime during 14 years of civil war . The UN special envoy for Syria will urge the security council to back a transition ...The Guardian - 4d -
How the US can help to save Georgia from the brink
The West could do more to stand by the Georgians who are protesting the GD’s authoritarian rule and its refusal to expand ties with the European Union.The Hill - Jan. 4 -
US leadership is being tested in Syria
The consequences of Turkey’s and its Islamist allies’ potential takeover of northeastern Syria are profound, with significant implications for U.S. national security interests.The Hill - Jan. 3 -
Rebels Easily Toppled Syria’s Army. Their Challenge Now: Rebuilding.
The rebels’ path to victory is littered with evidence of Syria’s defeated military. It also reflects the sizable task of trying to put the country back together.The New York Times - Jan. 1
More from The Hill
-
Death toll rises as Los Angeles wildfires continue to spread
More than a dozen people have died as a result of the still-spreading wildfires burning in Los Angeles.The Hill - 25m -
IRS delays after ID thefts 'unconscionable,' watchdog says. Here are 3 ways to protect yourself
A new tax season is nearly here, and with it an opportunity for identity thieves to take advantage of taxpayers. So what can taxpayers do to protect themselves in 2025?The Hill - 50m -
Will the ‘real’ Speaker Johnson please stand up?
Given the GOP’s razor-thin House majority, no one can be certain what the Speaker can and will do in 2025.The Hill - 50m -
Suspended South Korean President Yoon to skip first day of impeachment trial over safety concerns
South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol will not attend the first day of his impeachment trial this week, according to his lawyer, who cited concerns for the suspended president’s safety. "As attempts ...The Hill - 1h -
America must act to secure its ‘legacy chips’ from China and other competitors
As demand for connected devices and digital technologies continues to increase, so does the need for trusted and secure chips. Legacy chips are one important piece of that puzzle.The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Death toll rises as Los Angeles wildfires continue to spread
More than a dozen people have died as a result of the still-spreading wildfires burning in Los Angeles.The Hill - 25m -
Gov. Newsom says he’s organizing a Marshall Plan to reimagine ‘L.A. 2.0’ after wildfires
In an exclusive interview with Meet the Press, California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) discusses his Marshall Plan to rebuild Los Angeles after wildfires as the city prepares to host the World Cup, Super ...NBC News - 26m -
Gov. Newsom says he has ‘faith in our leaders’ as L.A. Mayor Karen Bass faces scrutiny
California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) says he has "absolute faith" in his state's leaders when asked about Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass. Bass has been criticized for being out of town on a trip to Ghana ...NBC News - 32m -
Trump has not responded to invitation to survey L.A. wildfire damage, Gov. Newsom says
During an exclusive interview with NBC News Correspondent Jacob Soboroff, California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) says he wants President-elect Donald Trump to "take a look for himself" at the damage ...NBC News - 33m -
Gov. Newsom says his investigation into L.A. County water supply is ‘not about finger pointing’
Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) tells NBC News Correspondent Jacob Soboroff that his investigation into the loss of water pressure to local fire hydrants is about answering the questions of California ...NBC News - 37m