How will universities handle diversity goals now that affirmative action is illegal?
As universities across the country settle into the fall semester, and high school seniors begin applications for fall 2025, declining enrollment and the elimination of diversity considerations in admissions are contributing to structural shifts in higher education, influencing student choices and experiences.
U.S. News & World Report recently released its Best National University Rankings for the U.S., with a category for diversity of student enrollment. The top-ranked school, Princeton University, claims a current minority enrollment of 50 percent, but of this number only 19 percent are underrepresented minorities — that is, students who are disproportionately underrepresented in higher education relative to the proportion of that group in the population.
New York University, ranked #30, has a minority enrollment of 49 percent, with 24 percent underrepresented.
Admissions practices on campuses across the country changed in response to the June 2023 U.S. Supreme Court elimination of affirmative action in its Students for Fair Admissions decision. And these changes may have long-lasting effects. The decision prohibits university admissions officials from considering race or ethnicity when evaluating applicants.
Individual experiences, including “an applicant’s discussion of how race affected his or her life,” can be considered in the admissions process, but decisions cannot be rendered “on the basis of race.”
While applicants may address diversity in their essays, evaluation forms no longer list “diversity” as a positive factor.
At many colleges, the percentage of Black students in the first-year class dropped in the fall of 2024, while at others it did not, or it did not drop more than the percentage of white students. However, some institutions recalculated their race and ethnicity data from 2023, ostensibly to present a more positive view of the numbers in 2024.
It is clear that affirmative action did contribute directly to an increase in access for qualified underrepresented minority students to higher education. While it is too early to assess the impact of the 2023 SCOTUS decision, information from states that had banned affirmative action prior to 2023 indicates that the percentage of underrepresented minority students on college campuses likely will decrease in other states in the coming years.
“Diversity” refers to many kinds of difference, and not necessarily just to one underrepresented identity. Not only are fewer students identifying with a single racial or ethnic category, more students are electing not to check the race-ethnicity box at all. This shifting data impedes the ability to get a clear picture of the immediate impact of the end of race-based admissions.
The shifts in the student population come at the same time as a period of intense cultural change. Restrictions on free speech, and the elimination of programs and centers promoting diversity, are part of ongoing right-wing efforts to reshape a supposedly overly liberal college landscape across the U.S. Some faculty and administrators express a fear that a perceived need to appease conservative critics and donors may reduce universities’ ability to contribute to an informed citizenry.
As a faculty member for 23 years and director of an honors program at the University of Illinois, I have observed some chilling downstream effects of the disappearance of affirmative action, but also some hopeful collective action. Eliminating data on race and ethnicity from applications does not merely mean that admissions officers know less about the applicants. Instead, as with other policy changes, ripple effects on experiences in classrooms, social groups and the world outside the university occur. These effects are difficult to calculate, but nonetheless real.
When diversity no longer can be considered a plus, students in a variety of campus organizations — from the newspaper to club athletics — ask if they can consider an applicant’s race when making decisions about who will join their boards or their membership. Such decisions affect resumes and therefore may impact students’ experiences long after graduation. K-12 schools across the country also are navigating more uncertain terrain with respect to race and admissions.
The increase in overall racial and socioeconomic diversity offers a multiplicity of perspectives and backgrounds and opportunities for instructors to learn, as well as students. Far from focusing primarily on racial or ethnic identity, campuses provide a multitude of spaces where robust argumentation and ideas drive our work, including the critical questioning of identities.
There is hope for the future, as some universities have taken actions to preserve access and diversity. This includes a tool the College Board developed called Landscape, which provides nuanced metrics about applicants’ high schools and neighborhoods, although it does not compensate for the loss of race and ethnicity data. Other admissions officers are putting more proactive work into recruiting underrepresented students prior to application season, as well as assertive recruitment after admission.
Diversity is good for business, and it is undoubtedly good for the universities that help produce a knowledgeable and thoughtful public. If diversity diminishes, so will the progress higher education administrators have made in offering access and opportunity to a much wider swath of the population. When fewer identities are represented, ideas become impoverished.
Laurie Johnson is professor of German and director of the Campus Honors Program at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and is a Public Voices Fellow through The OpEd Project.
Date: |
-
Business - Inc.
How to Handle Conflicts of Interest in Business
Protect your reputation before conflicts emerge.2 days ago -
Tech - VentureBeat
Microsoft just dropped Drasi, and it could change how we handle big data
Microsoft unveils Drasi, a groundbreaking open-source data processing system that simplifies event-driven architectures and revolutionizes cloud-native development for improved efficiency and ...3 days ago - Microsoft -
Top stories - CBS News
How much will a $60,000 home equity loan cost per month now that rates are cut?
Homeowners looking for $60,000 worth of extra money should consider their home equity. Here's what it costs now.2 days ago -
World - Yahoo News
Milei Vetoes University Pay Raise After Protest in Argentina
3 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Texas sues TikTok over handling of minors' data
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) sued the social platform TikTok for allegedly operating in a way that "puts the online safety and privacy of Texas children at risk" and violates a bill that ...2 days ago - Tiktok -
World - The Guardian
Manchester United’s stuttering start: where it has gone wrong, goal by goal
Twelve goals, multiple mistakes – we assess the goals let in by Ten Hag’s team this term and the lessons unlearned. Thursday’s 3-3 draw at Porto means Manchester United have conceded 12 goals in ...Yesterday -
World - Yahoo News
Post misleads with old video of Nigerian police raid on illegal pill mill
3 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Dems hammer Israel over West Bank settlements: ‘Illegal’ and ‘indefensible’
House Democrats are bashing Israeli leaders over the vast expansion of settlements in the occupied West Bank, arguing the developments are not only illegal but will also make it impossible to ...2 days ago - Israel -
World - The New York Times
E.U. Court Says Some Rules for Soccer’s Transfer Market Are Illegal
A decision could force soccer’s governing body to rewrite the regulations that govern the sport’s multibillion-dollar transfer market.Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Speaker Johnson calls federal response to Helene 'a massive failure'
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) called the federal response to Hurricane Helene a “massive failure” and pointed to the hundreds of people still missing. “At the federal level, this has been a massive ...4 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Dana Bash presses Lara Trump on Trump attack on FEMA response
CNN anchor Dana Bash on Sunday pressed Republican National Committee Co-Chair Lara Trump on former President Trump’s misleading claims about the FEMA relief aid available to residents. In an ...7 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Data point to the real reason married people cheat, and you may be surprised
Infidelity is on the rise, with women driving the increase, and cheating is often driven by a lack of desire and connection in long-term relationships, rather than just sex or emotional interest.21 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Walz: There are 'consequences’ for what Iran does
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D) stood firm in his support for Israel's right to defend itself ahead of the first anniversary of the Oct. 7 Hamas attack that killed 1,200 Israelis and triggered an ...26 minutes ago - Iran -
Politics - The Hill
Mark Kelly on Harris: ‘I’m confident she’s going to win Arizona’
Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.) said on Sunday he’s confident Vice President Harris is going to win his state of Arizona and the race overall. In an interview on CNN's "State of the Union," anchor Dana ...43 minutes ago