How our candidates’ trade policies could kill our Santa Claus economy
Year in and year out, we Americans consume more than we produce, and in recent years, the numbers have been growing. No, it’s not Santa Claus delivering the extra goods. It’s net imports: what we buy from other countries, minus what we sell to them.
Neither White House candidate has talked about this issue, but both have made promises that, if implemented, would end the import sleigh ride and make us poorer.
In 2023, the deficit was $65.4 billion, about equal to what Amazon sells in three months. In 2022, it was even more, at $78.7 billion. If we go back to 1992, it was just $3.2 billion.
How can we consume so much more than we produce each year? It’s partly explained by two trends that aren’t necessarily healthy: It is our nation’s growing government deficit habit, combined with a low rate of private savings. We as a country — government and citizens together — spend more than we earn each year.
But our ability to consume more than we make is how we manage the disparities. And despite Washington’s excesses, this ability is nonetheless an indicator of continued and enviable American prosperity.
Loading Santa’s sled are people in other parts of the world who are producing more than they consume. They trade with us, taking our IOUs and printed greenbacks and shipping us things we want and need: automobiles, chips, steel, aluminum, chemicals, tractors, toys, medicine and a vast array of other consumer goods.
Then, when our trading partners end up with more of our dollars than they may wish to use to buy U.S. goods, they use them to invest in America. Consider the Chinese-owned Volvo plant in South Carolina that employs some 1,500 workers, or Fuyao Glass America with 1,700 workers in Moraine, Ohio.
A glance at countries of origin on goods found at Target, Walmart, Amazon or anywhere else identifies those that happily trade with us. Chinese shipments have been falling since the U.S.-China trade war began around the time Trump took office. Much of what was shipped from China is now shipped from other Asian countries, especially Vietnam.
Indeed, each time we put the squeeze on China, shipments to the U.S. rise from somewhere else. Short of some drastic change in our own habits, it has to be that way. So long as we consume more than we produce, the goods will have to come from somewhere.
It is folly to assume that those substitute goods can suddenly and automatically come from American producers. In fact, typically there is just a small increase in U.S. production when tariffs are imposed on manufactured goods. We have tight labor markets and an economy that has adjusted to produce what we already do best.
America is expanding as a service, high-tech and construction economy. People elsewhere have become more effective at manufacturing goods than we are. To force a reversal would make us poorer.
Presidential candidate Donald Trump states, in no uncertain terms, that he wants to raise the gangplank and close America’s harbors to foreign goods. This applies not only to goods from China but from other countries as well, with the mention of a blanket 20 percent tariff.
Vice President Kamala Harris is less strident, but she has been a part of an administration that imposed and raised tariffs on Chinese and other goods.
Though they would not put it this way, both candidates want to stop Americans from consuming more than we produce. That might make sense on some level if they were also calling for federal action that will decrease the annual deficit. But both are doing very much the opposite, and higher deficits mean the pressure to import goods and services will increase, not decrease.
Potentially making it even harder to reduce imports are Trump’s repeated promises to begin deporting millions of undocumented immigrants. According to a Peterson Institute analysis, doing so would reduce U.S. employment and GDP growth. When all is said and done, we as a nation will be able to consume less, not more.
Goodbye, Santa Claus! Welcome to harder times, USA.
Bruce Yandle is a distinguished adjunct fellow with the Mercatus Center at George Mason University and dean emeritus of the Clemson University’s College of Business and Behavioral Sciences.
Date: |
-
Top stories - The New York Times
How Trump’s Radical Tariff Plan Could Wreck Our Economy
There’s no upside to the former president’s pet economic plan.18 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
The internet’s worst ‘zero day’ could drain all of our bank accounts
Without protective legislation, strong rules, cybercops, better security and tech-literate users, it seems inevitable that we wake one day to zero balances.3 days ago -
World - The Guardian
Quit if you don’t like our office-working policy, Amazon executive suggests
Matt Garman, head of AWS unit, says ‘there are other companies around’, according to transcript. A senior Amazon executive has suggested that staff who do not like the company’s new ...6 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
I’m one of the few doctors providing abortions in Arizona. This could be the issue that turns our state blue | Gabrielle Goodrick
Our state was a Republican stronghold, but the party’s assault on reproductive rights is making many voters think twice. We speak to voters in the states that will decide the US election about the ...Yesterday -
World - The Guardian
All British cinema is propaganda: how our film-makers are unwittingly reshaping the world
Propaganda films didn’t end after the war. Instead they became a tool for packaging our cultural heritage, promoting tourism and transforming British culture. During the second world war, British ...3 days ago -
World - The Guardian
In the Netherlands, we’re closing our emptying prisons. What can other countries learn from how we did it? | Renate van der Zee
The Dutch prison population has fallen by more than 40% – and awareness of the harms of harsh sentencing could explain why. Yesterday, I went to the cinema in the Dome prison in Haarlem. This ...4 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
‘Land politics’ are at the root of our costliest natural disasters
Patterns of home-building in climate frontiers and the resources provided to communities following natural disasters are deeply rooted in the political power of land.3 days ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Tuchel 'excited to make our dream come true'
New England head coach Thomas Tuchel says he wants to "make our dream come true" at the 2026 World Cup following his appointment.2 days ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
In Lebanon, We Took Pride in Our Resilience. Not Anymore.
The Lebanese have held strong through many tragedies. But they are now at the end of their rope.Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
DeSantis suspends election deadlines to ensure flexibility after hurricanes
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) has suspended some election deadlines and rules in Florida to ensure flexibility for voters and election workers in areas affected by hurricanes Helene and Milton. In ...38 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
FAA opening Boeing safety review
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) announced Friday it is opening a review into Boeing's safety processes to ensure they meet the administration's requirements. "The review will focus on key ...47 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
How the US can counter China's economic coercion
The Chinese threat of economic coercion has been effective, but the U.S. has leverage over China due to its reliance on supplying U.S. companies, and can leverage the imbalance in China's export ...52 minutes ago - China -
Politics - The Hill
More than 1 million votes cast in Georgia during early voting period
More than 1 million votes have been cast in the critical battleground state of Georgia just days after early voting opened in the state. Georgia shattered records with more than 300,000 ballots ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Usher, Lizzo to campaign with Harris this weekend
Kamala Harris's campaign is saying "Yeah!" to a double dose of star power, with Usher and Lizzo appearing in back-to-back swing state events in support of the vice president's White House bid. ...1 hour ago