How the US can counter China's economic coercion
In recent years, China’s threat of economic coercion has loomed large, and Washington’s allies and partners have seen entire sectors threatened by Beijing as punishment for certain political stances.The most meaningful Chinese threat often targets exports to China, exemplified famously by tariffs against Australian wine producers and embargoes against Lithuanian meat and dairy producers.
For a Western company, the immediate loss of the Chinese market directly corresponds to a loss in profitability that is difficult to replace. To many in Washington, this type of coercion appears to give the Chinese an unusual degree of power in foreign affairs. And because it is so effective, larger-scale instances of China wielding its economic weapon appear to be a matter of when, not if.
At present, Chinese coercion is met largely with a playbook of defensive measures. The Chinese are able to choose the time and location of their action, and the recipient country busies itself scrambling to contain the fallout. China therefore has the initiative, while the targeted country — often in conjunction with the U.S. — mostly tries to mitigate the impact.
As a result, it’s tempting to assume that China holds more cards than it actually does. And it’s equally easy for the U.S. to forget the extent of its own leverage over China in the exact same manner.
A significant source of deterrence lies in America’s recognition of just how much the Chinese economy relies on supplying U.S. companies. China’s confidence in using the economic coercion card far outstrips the nature of its true position, and two can play at that game. After all, China’s single largest trading balance by far is with the United States, which nearly equals the entirety of the EU and ASEAN balances. China’s suppliers receive roughly $3 from the U.S. for every $1 that its end markets spend on U.S. products.
As a result, American policymakers can gain a significant advantage by making clear that they have far more room to maneuver in relative terms — and that they know it.
Some experts have called for limiting exports headed to China in order to punish its coercion. While such action could be effective, the willingness to limit China’s own exports could be even more potent, because doing so would leverage the unique imbalance in China’s export relationship with the U.S.
For the American private sector, changing commercial suppliers to alternative partners in places like Mexico or Vietnam is often costly in the near term. But by and large, particularly for the types of goods that comprise the bulk of China's exports to the U.S., the shift is much less detrimental for the buyer than it is for the original supplier. Aiding this phenomenon is the fact that average labor costs in Mexico and Vietnam are by some measures competitive with or even lower than those observed in many parts of China.
Chinese companies, by contrast, don’t have this advantage. For the corresponding Chinese supplier, the loss of business is often difficult to replace, and its orders (and therefore future sales) can be expected to suffer. What's more, a supplier's use of debt — its capital structure — is frequently predicated on an assumption of steady future sales. Large declines in orders can call its solvency into question. Even if a Chinese company could move production abroad, the loss in mainland Chinese jobs would be unavoidable.
That, in turn, would put Beijing in a difficult position. If confronted with such a scenario, the best option for China’s government would involve stepping in to heavily subsidize newly unprofitable companies. This subsidization would come at a most inconvenient time, when Chinese tax revenues are even lower due to the very impacts that the subsidies were meant to remedy. In the worst possible scenario, entire swaths of China’s coastal provinces would suffer steep job losses and business closures.
This type of shift has taken place before, prompted by the Section 301 tariffs first levied during the Trump administration. The impact has been undeniable. In recent years, thousands of factories have shuttered, hit hard by declining orders from abroad. The lesson is clear: Decisive American action that prompts companies to drop China as a supplier can have effects even heavy subsidies cannot soften.
This general asymmetry is something that the U.S. can harness to its advantage in negotiating with China. Preventing coercion — not just against U.S. companies, but also against those of allies and partners — will depend on American willingness to use the same technique in the other direction. Such action, moreover, need not take place to have the intended effect. It’s enough for Beijing to believe that Washington is both able and willing to do so.
Andrew Liang is a fellow at the American Foreign Policy Council in Washington. He has been a private equity investor and investment banker focusing on the global industrial sector.
Date: | |
Tag: | China |
-
Business - CNBC
How to counter a low-ball salary offer
A low-ball salary offer doesn’t have to mean a lost cause. Here’s how to counter a less-than-ideal offer and negotiate for a higher wage.4 days ago -
World - The Guardian
Taiwan and trade: how China sees its future with the US after the election
Beijing does not see there being much difference between a Democratic- or Republican-controlled White House. Deciphering the obscure machinations of elite politics is a pursuit that western ...2 days ago - China -
Business - Financial Times
China’s economic ills are serious but not incurable
Unfortunately, policymakers have made things worse by resorting to temporary palliatives3 days ago - China -
World - ABC News
How a broke Argentine province is countering Milei's deep austerity cuts
After entering office last year, far-right President Milei swiftly imposed his fiscal shock therapy, slashing federal budget transfers to provincesYesterday -
Business - Financial Times
China’s economy grows 4.6% in third quarter
Lowest figure in year and a half comes as Beijing steps up stimulus efforts10 hours ago - China -
World - ABC News
China to boost financing for approved housing projects to $560 billion to counter property slump
China has announced it will expand the amount of financing available for housing projects on a “white list” to 4 trillion yuan ($562 billion), seeking to reverse a slump in the property industryYesterday - China -
Business - CNBC
ASML just gave us a first glimpse into how U.S. chip export curbs will dent its China sales
ASML on Tuesday offered the first glimpse into how U.S. restrictions on exports of its advanced chip manufacturing tools to China will impact its sales in the Asian country.Yesterday - China -
Business - Financial Times
Four economic truths that explain the US’s bizarre election
A trip to America’s number 3 shopping mall offers answers to what’s really going onYesterday -
World - The Guardian
Trio of professors win Nobel economics prize for work on post-colonial wealth
British-born Simon Johnson and James A Robinson and Turkish-American Daron Acemoğlu share £810,000 prize . Three US-based professors, including two UK-born academics, have been awarded this year’s ...4 days ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Haberman says Trump's rhetoric becoming 'much more apocalyptic'
Former President Trump's language has shifted to become “much more apocalyptic” than at the start of the election, journalist Maggie Haberman said. “For whatever reason his language, and I think we ...33 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Trump tells child there will be no cows under Harris
Former President Trump joined "Fox & Friends" on Friday for an in-person interview where he told a 6-year-old child the U.S. “won’t have any cows” if Vice President Harris is elected. In a recorded ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
UK Labour Party's efforts to help Harris draw scorn from Trump World
The Labor Party in the UK is sending over 100 current and former staff members to battleground states in the US to volunteer for Vice President Harris, sparking controversy among Republicans who ...1 hour ago - United Kingdom -
Politics - The Hill
The fight for AI labels
The Hill's weekly technology news digest. {beacon} Friday, October 18, 2024 LEADING THE DAY Lawmakers struggle for ways to distinguish real content from AI fakes Image © Getty Images ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
How Matt Drudge turned on Trump
“American Psycho,” screamed the banner headline on the Drudge Report this week underneath a photo of former President Trump swaying back and forth listening to music at a town hall in Pennsylvania, ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump