House GOP budget resolution on thin ice as conservatives dig in on opposition
The House GOP’s budget resolution is on thin ice as conservative budget hawks dig in on their opposition, threatening to derail Speaker Mike Johnson's (R-La.) plans to bring the legislation up for a vote on Tuesday.
At least four Republicans — Reps. Thomas Massie (Ky.), Victoria Spartz (Ind.), Warren Davidson (Ohio) and Tim Burchett (Tenn.) — said they plan to vote against the measure when it hits the floor Tuesday evening, airing gripes related to spending. Burchett said there are at least five opponents, signaling that the resistance is larger behind the scenes.
The hardened opposition has already prompted leadership to change its projections for a vote. After announcing Monday night that the House would vote on the budget resolution on Tuesday night, Johnson opened the door to delaying that timeline.
“There may be a vote tonight, may not be,” he said at a press conference Tuesday morning. “Stay tuned.”
“That’s why you get paid and hang around here, you have lots to report on,” he added.
The budget resolution would set the stage for House Republicans to pass a sprawling bill full of Trump’s domestic policy priorities, including border funding, energy policy and tax cuts.
Johnson, however, has little room for error. Republicans can only afford to lose one GOP vote and still adopt the resolution, assuming full attendance and complete Democratic opposition. Attendance on both sides of the aisle was unclear early on Tuesday.
In a positive development for Johnson, leadership appeared to make some progress with moderate Republicans who have expressed hesitation about the resolution, primarily over expected cuts to Medicaid. A handful of centrists huddled with Johnson in his office late Monday night.
“I’m in a better place [than] where I was yesterday,” said Rep. Juan Ciscomani (R-Ariz.), who last week signed on to a letter with Congressional Hispanic Conference members expressing concerns about potential changes to Medicaid and other programs.
Medicaid cuts have been a significant flashpoint throughout the budget resolution deliberations, with moderates concerned that the conference may gut the social safety net program to reach the $880 billion minimum of spending cuts the Energy and Commerce Committee has been directed to find — a reality that some lawmakers have publicly acknowledged.
Leadership, however, is downplaying any potential changes to Medicaid ahead of the vote on the framework. House Majority Leader Steve Scalise (R-La.) held up a paper copy of the resolution in a press conference and said: “There is no Medicaid in this bill. There are no Medicaid cuts in this bill.”
Pressed on whether he can guarantee there won’t be cuts to Medicaid, Johnson said that the program is “hugely problematic because it has a lot of fraud, waste, abuse.”
“That's what we're about, and that's what you're going to see happen,” the Speaker added, saying Republicans want to ensure migrants in the country illegally do not get Medicaid benefits.
Still at least two budget hawks are digging in on their opposition — and signaling that they will not waver from that position — which is enough resistance to tank the bill.
“I was a lean no before this meeting, now I’m a no,” Massie told reporters after leaving the House GOP conference’s gathering Tuesday morning, pointing to a fact sheet from leadership and arguing that the measure will add to the deficit.
“If the Republican plan passes under the rosiest assumptions, which aren’t even true, we’re gonna add $328 billion to the deficit this year, we’re gonna add $295 billion to the deficit the year after that, and $242 billion to the deficit after that, under the rosiest assumptions,” Massie added. “Why would I vote for that?”
Rep. Victoria Spartz (R-Ind.), who announced her opposition to the resolution over the weekend, re-upped that position Tuesday morning, arguing that the budget resolution does not do enough to rein in deficit spending.
“We have a baseline that includes $3.5 trillion, and we’re only committing to really $150 billion,” she said. “It’s just really sad.”
The Indiana Republican — who is known to flip-flop stances on high-stakes votes — dismissed any notion that she would change her position, suggesting that she was dug in on the opposition.
“I don't change my vote if things don't change,” Spartz said. “I don't think you guys get right memo. I never change my vote without changes in the rules or changes in procedures.”
Members of the House Freedom Caucus, who are normally part of a cadre of hardliners opposing legislation over fiscal matters, meanwhile, are supportive of the resolution after they secured key changes ahead of a committee vote earlier this month. But with the thin GOP margin, other fiscal hawks can easily threaten the vote.
House GOP leadership is racing to adopt its budget resolution as it seeks to keep pace with its ambitious timeline to pass Trump’s domestic policy agenda. Republicans are looking to use the budget reconciliation process to achieve that goal which would allow the party to circumvent Democratic opposition in the Senate.
Republicans, however, must first adopt a budget resolution to set that process in motion. Johnson has said he wants to move the budget resolution out of the chamber by the end of this month.
The resolution lays out a $1.5 trillion floor for spending cuts across committees with a target of $2 trillion, puts a $4.5 trillion ceiling on the deficit impact of any GOP plan to extend Trump’s 2017 tax cuts, and includes $300 billion in additional spending for the border and defense and a $4 trillion debt limit increase.
Tucked inside the resolution is a directive for the Energy and Commerce Committee to find at least $880 billion in deficit reductions, which some say will necessitate changes to Medicaid — a notion that sparked widespread concerns among moderates.
While the measure does not directly call for cuts to Medicaid a number of lawmakers have argued that the $880 billion number cannot be reached without significant slashes to Medicaid. Republicans have been publicly talking for weeks about offsetting the cost of tax cuts and other priorities with adjustments to Medicaid.
Members leaving the House GOP Conference meeting, however, Tuesday morning echoed a key talking point from leadership: That the resolution is simply the framework for the Trump agenda bill, and does not include the final details.
“It’s just a starting point,” said Rep. Nick LaLota (R-N.Y.).
While Massie and Spartz signaled firm opposition to the budget resolution, Burchett and Davidson suggested that they could be convinced to get on board.
When asked if there was any path for leadership to gain his support, Davidson said “they could communicate a binding plan for discretionary spending ahead of March 14,” pointing to the looming government funding deadline. He said he wants the budget resolution and government funding plan to reduce spending, and would like to see the slashes outlined by the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) locked in by Congress.
“I want a plan that, when you put the whole spending together it actually spends less money. We’re seeing part of the plan with the budget resolution, we’re not seeing the whole plan,” Davidson said. “If Congress doesn't lock in in funding some measure of all these things that DOGE is outlining, the administration’s gonna keep losing in court.”
Burchett, meanwhile, said he just needs some “verbal” assurances that GOP leaders are committed to reining in deficits in real numbers.
“I’d just like to have some confirmation that we’re going to make some changes,” he said. “We don’t honor what we write down anyway. Come on. This is Washington. They don’t honor anything.”
Like the other conservative holdouts, the Tennessee Republican said his chief concern is that the GOP budget will spike the nation’s deficit spending in the name of cutting it. He’s accusing Republican leaders of fudging the numbers to claim savings where there is none.
“We promised the people we’re gonna have cuts, and then we’re just gonna turn right around and spend the money at the Pentagon. The war pimps will get theirs no matter what anyway,” Burchett said. “And President Trump is talking about permanent tax cuts — I don’t think they’re in there. And they talk about all [these] DOGE cuts — which are great, and America loves — but what they don’t realize is they’re just going to tack ‘em right back on to the money we saved, that we’re borrowing.”
Burchett blasted the GOP’s proposed cuts as insufficient to rein in deficits, and he dismissed the Republicans’ growth projections stemming from tax cuts as unrealistic “Washington talk.”
-
House GOP advances budget resolution as conservative opponents hold firm
House Republicans advanced their budget resolution to enact President Trump’s legislative agenda on Tuesday, teeing the measure up for a final vote even as GOP opponents of the measure appeared to ...The Hill - 2h -
House budget resolution vote expected
The House of Representatives is expected to vote on a budget plan that would extend cuts to several parts of government spending. CBS News' Taurean Small reports.CBS News - 6h -
What's in the House GOP budget plan?
The House is expected to vote on a budget plan this week. It will be a key test to see if Republicans can unify around President Trump's agenda. CBS News congressional correspondent Nikole Killion ...CBS News - 22h -
GOP scrambles to win over moderates on budget resolution
Senate passage of a budget resolution designed to execute large parts of President Trump’s policy agenda throws the ball back to the House, where GOP leaders are hoping to move swiftly on ...The Hill - 1d -
Johnson searches for consensus on budget resolution as opposition grows ahead of key vote
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) and his leadership team are feverishly searching for consensus on the House GOP conference's plan to advance President Trump's legislative agenda, which has thus far ...The Hill - 16h -
Trump stuns Senate GOP with House budget endorsement
“Did not see that one coming,” Senate Majority Leader John Thune said.Politico - 6d -
Graham defends Senate budget resolution amid Trump opposition: 'Complete game changer'
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) defended the Senate's budget resolution, which rolled in during the wee hours of Friday morning and involves a two-track process instead of the one large spending bill ...The Hill - 4d -
Conservatives threaten to tank House budget vote needed to advance Trump agenda
Speaker Mike Johnson said Tuesday he is plowing forward this week with a vote on House Republicans' multi-trillion-dollar budget blueprint, a crucial test for President Donald Trump's legislative ...NBC News - 5h -
House Rules Committee advances budget resolution as path forward remains uncertain
The House Rules Committee voted Monday to advance the GOP conference’s plan to pass President Trump’s legislative agenda, sending the budget resolution to the full chamber even as its fate on the ...The Hill - 18h
More from The Hill
-
Utah on the verge of being the first state to ban fluoride in public water
Utah is on the verge of becoming the first state to prohibit cities and towns from adding fluoride to their public water supply. The Utah Senate on Friday voted 18-8 to give final approval to ...The Hill - 20m -
Trump directs investigation preceding potential copper tariffs
President Trump on Tuesday directed his Commerce secretary to investigate the need for possible tariffs on copper, the latest industry to potentially be targeted by Trump’s sweeping trade agenda. ...The Hill - 27m -
Senate Democrats press Trump's FTC commissioner nominee over agency independence
Multiple Senate Democrats on the Commerce, Science and Transportation on Tuesday pressed President Trump's Federal Trade Commissioner nominee, Mark Meador, over the independence of the agency amid ...The Hill - 40m -
White House names interim DOGE administrator
The White House on Tuesday disclosed that the interim administrator of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) is Amy Gleason after repeated questioning from reporters. A White House ...The Hill - 45m -
Whitmer on Republican lawmaker's same-sex marriage resolution: 'Hell no'
Michigan Democrats, including Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, are pushing back against a Republican-led resolution asking the Supreme Court to reverse its decision that legalized same-sex marriage ...The Hill - 45m
More in Politics
-
Rep. Spartz says she will vote no on GOP budget resolution if ‘language doesn’t change’
Rep. Victoria Spartz (R-Ind.) explains why she plans to vote no on Speaker Mike Johnson’s budget resolution. Rep. Spartz also weighed in on whether Congress will be able to fund the government as ...NBC News - 14m -
Utah on the verge of being the first state to ban fluoride in public water
Utah is on the verge of becoming the first state to prohibit cities and towns from adding fluoride to their public water supply. The Utah Senate on Friday voted 18-8 to give final approval to ...The Hill - 20m -
Trump directs investigation preceding potential copper tariffs
President Trump on Tuesday directed his Commerce secretary to investigate the need for possible tariffs on copper, the latest industry to potentially be targeted by Trump’s sweeping trade agenda. ...The Hill - 27m -
Senate Democrats press Trump's FTC commissioner nominee over agency independence
Multiple Senate Democrats on the Commerce, Science and Transportation on Tuesday pressed President Trump's Federal Trade Commissioner nominee, Mark Meador, over the independence of the agency amid ...The Hill - 40m -
White House names interim DOGE administrator
The White House on Tuesday disclosed that the interim administrator of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) is Amy Gleason after repeated questioning from reporters. A White House ...The Hill - 45m