GOP scrambles to win over moderates on budget resolution
Senate passage of a budget resolution designed to execute large parts of President Trump’s policy agenda throws the ball back to the House, where GOP leaders are hoping to move swiftly on legislation encompassing an even broader swath of Trump’s first-year wishlist.
Behind Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.), House Republicans were already advancing Trump’s “one big beautiful bill” strategy even before Senate GOP leaders chose to charge ahead with their competing — and more narrow — budget blueprint, which passed through the upper chamber in the early hours of Friday morning.
But Trump’s surprise endorsement of the House package — which came amid the Senate process and blindsided GOP leaders — has heightened the stakes for Johnson and other top Republicans, who are now under even greater pressure to unite their divided conference behind the massive spending plan in order to secure an early win for the president, who’s facing mounting criticism for rising inflation and efforts to gut the federal bureaucracy.
The GOP budget bill is poised to hit the House floor this week, but passage is no slam dunk.
House Republicans are clinging to a historically tiny majority, which leaves virtually no room for GOP defections as long as Democrats are united in opposition, as expected. And already, a handful of moderate Republicans are airing concerns about steep cuts to safety net programs like food stamps and Medicaid that could tank the bill.
Those cuts are a crucial piece of the GOP’s budget plan, designed to help offset the multitrillion-dollar cost of extending Trump’s 2017 tax cuts. But the centrist GOP holdouts have reservations that the cuts would hurt their most vulnerable constituents — particularly those on Medicaid, which provides coverage to more than 70 million people, most of them poor and roughly half of them children.
Under the House budget resolution, the Energy and Commerce Committee would be tasked with locating $880 billion in cuts to programs under the panel’s jurisdiction, the great bulk of which are expected to fall on Medicaid. The Agriculture Committee, which oversees food stamps, must find another $230 billion.
At least three moderate Republicans — Reps. David Valadao (Calif.), Nicole Malliotakis (N.Y.) and Don Bacon (Neb.) — told The Hill on Wednesday that they’re ready to vote against the budget bill this week unless GOP leaders can provide convincing evidence beforehand that the proposed Medicaid cuts won’t diminish direct benefits to people in their districts.
“There’s a group of us who want to see how $880B can be cut and how it will affect Medicaid,” one of the concerned moderates said Friday.
A failure of the budget plan on the House floor would strike a hard blow to the GOP’s efforts to enact Trump’s ambitious legislative agenda in the first year of his second term, just months after voters put Republicans in charge of all levers of power in Washington.
In that instance, GOP leaders could return to the drawing board in an attempt to win over the moderates by reducing the size and scope of the spending cuts. But that move would likely erode support from conservative budget hawks hoping to shrink the government and rein in deficits.
Alternatively, House leaders could shift to the Senate’s budget strategy, which splits Trump’s agenda between two bills. The first of those, featuring more spending for the military, domestic energy production and border security, is the one that passed through the upper chamber on Friday.
But that approach punted on the toughest parts of the budget debate, including the details over how to pay for those spending increases; which tax cuts should be extended or created; and what programs will be cut to help offset the resulting loss of revenues so deficits don’t explode.
For those reasons, House GOP leaders have argued from the beginning that their one-bill strategy is the better way to get Trump’s agenda over the finish line this year. It’s a message they’re amplifying heading into this week’s vote.
“The best chance for bold tax and spending reform and the entirety of Trump’s America First agenda rests on the success of the House budget resolution,” House Budget Committee Chair Rep. Jodey Arrington (R-Texas) said Friday.
“If Republicans can avoid breaking this process up into two bills, our probabilities for the Trump ‘rocket ship’ economy go up exponentially.”
To advance the House approach, Trump and GOP leaders have sought to ease lingering concerns about the potentially harmful effects of the proposed cuts. Indeed, while the president has previously made promises not to erode benefits under Social Security or Medicare, he went out of his way last week to add Medicaid to that list.
“Social Security won’t be touched — other than if there’s fraud or something, we’re going to find it. It’s going to be strengthened, but won’t be touched,” Trump said Tuesday during an interview with Sean Hannity of Fox News.
“Medicare, Medicaid: None of that stuff is going to be touched,” he added. “We don’t have to.”
Johnson has also dismissed the idea that the GOP’s budget will gut benefits for low-income people. Medicaid, he said recently, “has never been on the chopping block.”
“Medicaid is infamous for fraud, waste and abuse,” he said. “And so we do right to go into those programs and find that and show the people what's happened and make sure it doesn't happen again.
“If you eliminate fraud, waste and abuse in Medicaid,” he added, “you've got a huge amount of money that you can spend on real priorities for the country.”
Those arguments have yet to convince the moderate GOP holdouts, however, creating plenty of uncertainty surrounding the outcome of this week’s vote.
Just hours after the Senate passed its budget bill, Trump softened his advocacy for “one big beautiful bill,” leaving open the possibility for multiple proposals. The outcome, he said, is more important than the process.
“I guess you could make the case you could do three. You could do 10,” Trump said in an interview with Fox News.
“As long as we get them all added up and it’s the same thing.”
Emily Brooks contributed reporting.
Topics
-
Trump stuns Senate GOP with House budget endorsement
“Did not see that one coming,” Senate Majority Leader John Thune said.Politico - 4d -
Senate adopts budget resolution after marathon overnight vote-a-rama
The Senate on Friday adopted a budget resolution intended to serve as a blueprint to deliver the first part of President Trump’s agenda. Senators voted 52-48 along party lines on the resolution ...The Hill - 3d -
Senate G.O.P. Passes Budget Resolution, and Punts on Tough Questions
Approval of the Republican budget plan left major questions about tax cuts and spending reduction for another day.The New York Times - 2d -
US Senate passes budget resolution to fund Trump’s deportation plan
Bill approving $175bn for border security and extra $150bn for Pentagon faces tough challenge in House. US politics live – latest updates The US Senate has passed a budget resolution that ...The Guardian - 2d -
Details on Senate-passed GOP budget plan after "vote-a-rama"
Senate Republicans have passed a budget resolution after pulling an all-nighter through a process known as "vote-a-rama." The passage comes despite President Trump's earlier backing of a competing ...CBS News - 2d -
A DOGE dividend could be a win-win-win for the GOP and Team Trump
With Democrats screaming that the sky is falling every time the Department of Government Efficiency axes one federal worker, Elon Musk’s team needs some good public relations.The Hill - 3d -
Graham defends Senate budget resolution amid Trump opposition: 'Complete game changer'
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) defended the Senate's budget resolution, which rolled in during the wee hours of Friday morning and involves a two-track process instead of the one large spending bill ...The Hill - 3d -
Senate adopts GOP budget plan in "vote-a-rama," despite Trump backing competing House plan
The Senate has adopted a slimmed-down GOP budget proposal focusing on defense, border security, and energy priorities, despite President Trump's earlier backing of a competing plan put forward by ...CBS News - 3d -
PBS and NPR on edge over FCC letter and Trump budget scrutiny
PBS President Paula Kerger has felt the heat from politicians over government funding before. But this time the FCC is focusing on the nonprofit's sponsorships.Los Angeles Times - 3d
More from The Hill
-
11 dead after supplemental shakes linked to listeria cases in 21 states
Frozen shakes sold to nursing homes and other institutions are being recalled after a listeria outbreak in 21 states that has caused 11 deaths, according to the Federal Food and Drug Administration.The Hill - 43m -
Democrats need to make a compelling case to win back America
Voters have little idea what Democrats stand for, only who they stand against.The Hill - 45m -
Zelensky praises ‘absolute heroism of Ukrainians’ three years after Russian invasion
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is praising the “absolute heroism” of his people on the third anniversary of Russia’s invasion. “Three years of resistance. Three years of gratitude. Three ...The Hill - 50m -
To stop corruption and rescue democracy, we must take money out of politics
Donald Trump is attempting to replace our democratic Republic with a plutocratic dictatorship that looks a lot like Vladimir Putin's. How has this happened? One answer is the corrupting influence ...The Hill - 1h -
Musk: Federal workers who haven’t returned to office will be placed on leave this week
Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) leader Elon Musk said early Monday that federal workers who haven’t returned to the office will be placed on administrative leave this week. Last month, ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
11 dead after supplemental shakes linked to listeria cases in 21 states
Frozen shakes sold to nursing homes and other institutions are being recalled after a listeria outbreak in 21 states that has caused 11 deaths, according to the Federal Food and Drug Administration.The Hill - 43m -
Democrats need to make a compelling case to win back America
Voters have little idea what Democrats stand for, only who they stand against.The Hill - 45m -
Zelensky praises ‘absolute heroism of Ukrainians’ three years after Russian invasion
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is praising the “absolute heroism” of his people on the third anniversary of Russia’s invasion. “Three years of resistance. Three years of gratitude. Three ...The Hill - 50m -
DOGE's Musk says federal employees must document their work or resign
Some federal agencies, including the State and Defense Departments, told their employees not to respond to an email asking for a list of tasks they completed.CBS News - 53m -
To stop corruption and rescue democracy, we must take money out of politics
Donald Trump is attempting to replace our democratic Republic with a plutocratic dictatorship that looks a lot like Vladimir Putin's. How has this happened? One answer is the corrupting influence ...The Hill - 1h