Here’s why some Latinos are genuinely embracing the Republican Party
With the presidential election less than one month away, many people are still trying to make sense of why some Latinos support Donald Trump and the Republican Party, who display clear nativist stances. Here are our data-driven answers to this puzzle.
For more than 40 years now, Latinos have been steadfast Democrats, with two out of three of them self-identifying with this party and voting for its candidates. What is different today, however, is that many political observers have awakened to the flip side of that reality: that nearly one out of three Latinos genuinely identify as Republicans. In a context of increasing polarization, these political nuances now stand out more sharply than ever.
Although it may be surprising to some people, Latinos not only identify as an ethnic group, but also as Americans. The degree to which a Latino adult prioritizes one of these identities over the other reliably explains why they identify as a Democrat or a Republican.
The more that Latino prioritize American identity over their own ethnic identity, the more likely they are to think of themselves as Republican — a byproduct of polarization where this party is tightly and mentally associated with “real” Americans. In contrast, the more Latino adults identify with their ethnic group, the more they will identify as Democratic — also a byproduct of polarization, where this party is mentally linked with people of color in general.
Using high-quality surveys of Latino adults since 2006, we find that about 27 percent of Latino adults prioritize their American identity over their ethnic identity — a remarkably close figure to the one third of Latinos who identify as Republicans.
This association between identity and political party becomes starkly clear in highly controlled laboratory experiments my colleagues and I have run. Simple exposure to the American flag and other national symbols makes Latinos automatically think of the Republican Party. Similarly, Latinos automatically think of Democrats when they encounter imagery related to their respective ethnic group. These snap judgments emerge from the continued polarization between Democrats and Republicans — two parties that, in essence, are distilled coalitions between multiple social, economic and racial groups.
Why does something so psychological matter for each party’s electoral fortunes?
Without more careful messaging and outreach efforts, our data suggest that Democrats and Republicans risk reaching out to Latinos based on an identity that is of lower importance to them — a political mismatch. For example, if 27 percent of Latinos report prioritizing their American identity and a party reaches out to them as ethnics, this could trigger a defense mechanism whereby Latinos will self-identify with the party that better reflects their prioritized identity.
To show this, we undertook a large-scale experiment with Latino adults. Here, Latino participants were assigned on a random basis to read one of three news articles. In the control group, participants read a news brief about how the number of giant tortoises around the globe is declining.
In another condition, participants read about how, despite their similarity to Americans in terms of some characteristics (e.g., optimism, hard-working), many Latinos prioritize their ethnic identity. In the last condition, participants read an article explaining that, despite being characterized largely as an ethnic group, many Latinos place greater weight on their American identity. After reading their assigned article, all participants reported their degree of self-identification as a Democrat or Republican.
Two insights emerge from this study. First, when Latinos are characterized as a largely ethnic population, those who prioritize their Latino identity express significantly greater allegiance to Democrats — which is the status quo. Yet this same message propels Latinos who prioritize their American identity to express significantly lower allegiance to Democrats. This trend suggests that while characterizations of Latinos as ethnics reinforces the allegiance of some Latinos to the Democratic Party, it comes at the expense of losing support among other Latinos because of how mismatched their prioritized identity is to descriptions of their group.
Second, when Latinos are characterized as Americans, those who prioritize their ethnic identity distance themselves from Democrats, while those who prioritize their American identity embrace the Republican Party more tightly.
The take-away lessons from our accumulation of findings are clear.
First, Latinos are multifaceted, with some of those facets contradicting our expectations of them. An effective solution here is simply for party operatives to know — with more precision than now — what kind of Latinos they are reaching out to and using that information to fine-tune their messaging to this electoral segment.
Second, more than culturally sensitive outreach (e.g., Spanish-language ads versus English-language ads), political candidates must reach out to Latinos in ways that acknowledge and affirm the identities that they themselves value most. This entails each party suspending its stereotypes about what kind of voters Latinos are and instead meeting these voters where they stand and accept how they see themselves.
Implementing both lessons will invigorate future campaigns as they vie for Latino support in a racially and ethnically complex electoral landscape.
Efrén Pérez is Full Professor of Political Science and Psychology at UCLA, where he directs the Race, Ethnicity, Politics & Society Lab. He is the author of “Diversity’s Child: People of Color and the Politics of Identity.”
Date: |
-
Politics - The Hill
Extra check coming to some Social Security recipients in November: Here's why
These two-check months happen a few times each year.4 days ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
America Is on the Brink of a Great Political Realignment. It’s Already Visible in Arizona.
He and his acolytes purged the G.O.P. to make it smaller and more strident.4 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Republicans grapple with storm misinformation from their own party
Republicans representing states hit by hurricanes Helene and Milton are grappling with the spread of storm misinformation, much of which has stemmed from prominent figures in their own party — ...3 days ago - Republican Party -
Top stories - The New York Times
Why Trump’s Weird Dance Party Is Deeply Alarming
There have been too many recent times he has wandered away from his thoughts.3 days ago - Donald Trump -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Harris calls on Republican voters to put 'country first' as Trump woos Latino voters
WASHINGTON CROSSING, Pa. (AP) — Surrounded by more than 100 former Republican officeholders and officials, Democrat Kamala Harris urged GOP voters on Wednesday to put “country first” and abandon ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court turns away self-proclaimed Republican’s defense in claiming party’s support
The Supreme Court turned away a failed Minnesota state Senate candidate’s challenge to rulings that he falsely implied to have the Republican Party’s support during his 2022 write-in campaign. The ...4 days ago -
Business - The New York Times
Family Car Insurance Bills Are Rising. Here Are Some Money-Saving Tips.
Have several children, a driveway full of cars and a few moving violations? Good luck to you. There are some ways to lessen the financial pain.12 hours ago -
Business - Inc.
Here’s Why the Gender Pay Gap Is Getting Wider
Reversing a 20-year trend, the gap between men’s and women’s wages increased in 2023.3 days ago -
Top stories - CBS News
Why some emergency alert systems failed during Hurricane Helene
Some people living in the path of Hurricane Helene may not have received crucial warnings to evacuate from the dangerous storm that killed more than 200 people across multiple states. While severe ...5 days ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Harris makes last-ditch appeal to disenchanted Republicans
Vice President Harris and her allies are making a last-ditch effort to peel off Republican support from former President Trump in the final days of the election. Harris rallied with a number of her ...22 minutes ago - Republican Party -
Politics - The Hill
Frozen waffles recalled due to listeria risk
Treehouse Foods recalled frozen waffles due to a possible listeria outbreak in a Friday release. The brand sells items in commercial stores across the United States and Canada. The company says the ...45 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Hurricane Oscar forms in the Caribbean
Hurricane Oscar formed in the Caribbean on Saturday, according to the National Weather Service (NWS) Miami-South Florida. NWS said Oscar is expected to move toward the Turks and Caicos Islands, ...1 hour ago - Oscars -
Politics - The Hill
Cuba hit by second blackout after grid collapse
Cubans experienced their second black out wave Saturday after government officials said they were working to restore electrical service to hospitals and crucial service centers after a grid failure ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Sunday shows preview: Harris, Trump battle for battlegrounds; Hamas leader killed
With just 17 days to go until Election Day, Vice President Harris and former President Trump are ramping up their campaigning in key battleground states. Tensions in the Middle East and fears of a ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump