Harris-backed filibuster change would ‘break’ the Senate, McConnell says
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell lambasted a proposal from Vice President Kamala Harris that would eliminate the filibuster to pass abortion rights legislation — warning Democrats that they will rue the move when Republicans next control Washington.
“What they want to do is break the institution in order to achieve what they want to achieve,” he said in an interview Thursday.
McConnell spoke two days after Harris told Wisconsin Public Radio that “we should eliminate the filibuster for Roe” — in other words, changing the Senate’s rules to exempt a vote to restore the abortion rights guarantee under Roe v. Wade from the chamber’s usual 60-vote threshold for legislation.
Such a scenario would be likely only if Harris wins the presidency and Democrats keep the Senate and retake the House majority — currently a tall order for a party facing a tough Senate map. Notably, two former Democrats who blocked prior attempts to undermine the 60-vote rule — Sens. Joe Manchin (I-W.Va.) and Kyrsten Sinema (I-Ariz.) — are retiring.
But McConnell, delivering some of his most pointed and substantial criticism of a Harris proposal since she became a presidential candidate, said that the proposal would spell the end of the filibuster altogether, explaining that her suggested exemption for Roe would put the chamber down a steep and slippery slope.
“There's no way you can have a minor carve-out” for one issue, he said. “Because then you’ll come up with the next idea that’s more important than the rule — then, practically, it’s over.”
Democrats last tried to break the filibuster to pass voting rights legislation in the early years of President Joe Biden’s administration, when they had control of both the House and Senate. Manchin and Sinema’s opposition tanked that effort, but the 2022 Supreme Court ruling overturning Dobbs focused new attention on the rule — with Harris, a former senator, joining many other Democrats in backing filibuster changes in the immediate aftermath of the decision.
Such a move, Harris said Tuesday, would “get us to the point where 51 votes would be what we need to actually put back in law the protections for reproductive freedom and for the ability of every person and every woman to make decisions about their own body and not have their government tell them what to do.”
McConnell said that would permanently change the nature of the Senate, for the worse.
While at least some presidential nominations have been exempt from the filibuster for more than a decade, doing the same for legislation is a "totally different matter, he said: “The Senate was designed to do one of two things: Kill bad stuff or force a reasonable compromise — and that's what it's done all along.”
The Harris campaign did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
McConnell warned that if they adjusted the filibuster rules Democrats would then use simple-majority votes to entrench their power by admitting D.C. and Puerto Rico as states, likely adding four additional Democratic senators. “Then,” he said, they’ll “go after the Supreme Court.”
“So it would fundamentally, in my view, turn America to California,” he continued. “And I think that is a major structural change to the country.”
McConnell has long been a fierce defender of the Senate’s legislative filibuster, withstanding public pressure to change the rules during Donald Trump’s presidency and then openly encouraging Manchin and Sinema as they stood athwart their fellow Democrats’ recent push.
If Democrats do go nuclear, McConnell said Thursday, Republicans will also take advantage of the new system: “They never think about what might happen when the shoe is on the other foot.”
Asked what bills Republicans would pass without the filibuster, McConnell said, “I don't know, but I'm sure they wouldn't like it.”
Over the past decade, a similar dynamic played out over the use of the filibuster for Senate confirmations. In 2013, McConnell cautioned then-Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) not to break the filibuster for lower-level court nominations, which Republicans had been blocking.
“You’ll regret this, and you may regret this a lot sooner than you think,” McConnell said at the time.
When Republicans took the chamber a few years later, McConnell cited Reid’s rule change to justify going nuclear for Supreme Court nominations — helping Trump confirm three conservative justices in what’s become the most sweeping overhaul to the court in a generation.
Asked if he has any regrets about that move, McConnell said he did not.
“I said to my members, if a candidate like [Neil] Gorsuch — who is so obviously totally qualified — can't get 60 votes, there's nobody we can pick that we're comfortable with that can get confirmed,” he said. “And so we lowered the threshold for the Supreme Court.”
Like this content? Sign up for POLITICO's Playbook newsletter.
Date: |
Topics
-
World - The Guardian
‘Ruined’ Gaza economy would take 350 years to return to pre-conflict level, UN says
49 minutes ago -
Top stories - ABC News
Tim Walz says Trump is 'spiraling down,' pitches Harris' message of change
20 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Business - CNBC
Trump plan would make Social Security insolvent in just 6 years, budget group says
22 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - NBC News
Democratic senators slam McDonald's for menu price hikes they say have outpaced inflation
8 hours ago -
Top stories - ABC News
Communication expert breaks down Wisconsin Senate debate performances
Yesterday -
Top stories - BBC News
Moldova says 'Yes' to pro-EU constitutional changes by tiny margin
Yesterday -
Top stories - NBC News
Trump vows to deport millions. Builders say it would drain their crews and drive up home costs.
3 days ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - The New York Times
A Candidate for U.S. Senate Says He Was Shot in War. Was He?
3 days ago -
Business - MarketWatch
Dan Loeb’s Third Point says a Trump win would boost markets, drive up infrastructure spending
4 days ago - Donald Trump -
World - The Guardian
American Danielle Collins says she’s changed her mind about quitting tennis
4 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
McConnell exposes deep anti-Trump sentiment within Senate GOP
4 days ago - Donald Trump -
World - Financial Times
UK inheritance tax raid would be ‘painful’ but not fatal for Aim, says LSE executive
4 days ago - United Kingdom -
Entertainment - ABC News
McConnell called Trump 'stupid' and 'despicable' in private after the 2020 election, a new book says
4 days ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - NBC News
Mitch McConnell privately called Trump a 'despicable human' and unfit for office, new book says
4 days ago - Donald Trump -
Business - Financial Times
ECB lowers rates to 3.25% as inflation slows
5 days ago -
Business - MarketWatch
LVMH executive says it would be a mistake to offer more affordable products. Here’s why he’s right.
5 days ago -
Business - CNBC
Jim Cramer says he would be a buyer of Disney if the stock goes to this key level
5 days ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Harris spars with Fox News host and says she wouldn't be a 'continuation' of Biden
5 days ago - Joe Biden -
Top stories - NBC News
Vance says Trump didn't lose the 2020 election: 'Not by the words I would use'
5 days ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Vance says Trump did not lose in 2020 'by the words that I would use'
5 days ago - Donald Trump -
World - Yahoo News
Climate change worsened deadly Nepal floods, scientists say
5 days ago - Climate -
Business - CNBC
Key change coming for 401(k) ‘max savers’ in 2025, expert says — here's what you need to know
5 days ago -
World - The Guardian
US election live: Trump holds rally in Atlanta after Georgia sees record first day of early voting
6 days ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - The New York Times
Trump Says It Would Be a ‘Smart Thing’ if He Had Talked to Putin
6 days ago - Donald Trump -
Business - Inc.
Here’s Why Economists Say Trump’s Economic Plans Would Worsen Inflation
6 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Tillis warns conservatives’ 'unwise' reforms would 'weaken' Senate GOP
6 days ago -
Business - The New York Times
Would a Strong Job Market Stop Fed Rate Cuts? This Official Says No.
6 days ago - Federal Reserve -
World - The Guardian
No 10 rejects claims PM received Taylor Swift tickets as ‘thank you’ for security measures – as it happened
October 15 -
Top stories - BBC News
Would raising employer National Insurance break Labour's pledge?
October 15 -
Sports - CBS Sports
West Virginia's Neal Brown offers plea for fan support: 'What I would say is -- did they have a good time?'
October 15 -
Business - CNBC
Here's who would benefit from Trump's proposed tax break on car loan interest
October 14 - Donald Trump -
Sports - ABC News
'Shocker' has Cowboys at crossroads as Jerry Jones says he isn't considering a coaching change
October 14 - NFL -
Politics - The Hill
Chris Matthews: 'Big mistake' for Harris to say policies would be the same as Biden's
October 14 - Joe Biden -
World - ABC News
Polish democracy leader Lech Walesa says a Trump victory would be a 'misfortune' for the world
October 14 - Donald Trump -
Business - Financial Times
Trump would not weaken the dollar, says adviser Scott Bessent
October 13 - Donald Trump
More from Politico
-
Politics - Politico
House GOP braces for bitter fight over the power to oust a speaker
4 hours ago - House -
Politics - Politico
Internal GOP poll shows trouble for Peltola in Alaska
Yesterday -
Politics - Politico
Law enforcement missed ‘pivotal moments’ to engage Trump gunman, House panel finds
Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Politics - Politico
What if it's President Harris, but a GOP Senate? That's her allies' fear.
2 days ago -
Politics - Politico
Congressional leaders negotiating potential lame-duck deal to address AI concerns
3 days ago
Latest in Politics
-
Politics - NBC News
Trump unleashes a torrent of personal attacks on Harris, calling her 'the worst' and 'lazy as hell'
25 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Chris Matthews: Democrats need to 'repay' Liz Cheney if Harris wins
27 minutes ago - Kamala Harris -
Politics - The Hill
The punishment doesn’t fit the crime when it comes to the felony murder rule
30 minutes ago -
Politics - NBC News
Bulletproof vests, snipers and drones: Election officials beef up security at the polls
30 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
How third-party candidates could make a difference in swing states
39 minutes ago