GOP-leaning polls trigger questions about accuracy
The prevalence of Republican-leaning polls in recent weeks is raising questions about their effect on the overall polling average as the presidential race between Vice President Harris and former President Trump tightens even further.
Surveys from pollsters that lean toward one party are a regular occurrence in presidential contests along with independent polling.
In recent weeks, however, GOP-leaning polls have flooded the zone, fueling speculation that they could be skewing perceptions of the race. But experts note their average models have methodologies in place to prepare for this.
“When you look across all the averages, the net effect is less than a point, if you take out the Republican polls, or the partisan ones, so to speak,” said Scott Tranter, the director of data science for Decision Desk HQ. “So I don’t necessarily think it’s a huge thing there.”
Across the board, election models and polling averages consider the race almost neck and neck without a clear leader. The Hill/DDHQ model has the race as almost exactly even in each candidates’ chance to prevail at 50-50.
In FiveThirtyEight’s simulations of 1,000 possible outcomes, Trump wins in just more than 500 of them, a bit ahead of Harris. Pollster Nate Silver has Trump just ahead in likelihood of winning, still in line with other models.
Polling in general has been picking up as Election Day approaches — and in particular surveys from Republican-affiliated firms. Various averages include several polls from Republican-leaning pollsters or with Republican-leaning sponsors while not as many from Democratic-leaning pollsters.
This has raised the question of whether these GOP-leaning polls are to explain for why the race is tightening even more so with Trump seeming to make slight gains nationally and in key swing states.
Tranter said these Republican partisan polls are having a minimal effect on the averages.
He said DDHQ doesn’t weigh polls based on party associations. Polls that are most recent are given more weight than older ones, and sample size and meeting “basic requirements” are taken into consideration, but otherwise polls are treated the same way.
Tranter acknowledged that if the Republican-leaning pollsters were finding better results for Trump, the average would be more affected, but he noted that DDHQ’s model gives Harris a slightly better chance at winning than others that include a weighting system to limit the effect of partisan polls.
Silver’s model, for example, has Harris as the slight underdog but does weigh polls based on pollster quality and bias.
An elections analyst for Silver rejected the idea of GOP-leaning polls having much influence on the average in a post on Wednesday, noting that Harris led by 3 points nationally in the overall average, while her lead shrunk to 2 points with just Republican-aligned pollsters. Taking them out, her lead increased to 3.4 points.
But the analyst said the weighing system prevents partisan polls from skewing the average, causing most models to roughly have the same averages on the national and state level, generally with differences within 1 percentage point.
Tranter also noted that not all GOP-leaning polls present good news for Republicans, pointing to internal polls from the Senate Leadership Fund, a super PAC that works to elect Republicans to the Senate, which showed several GOP candidates trailing their Democratic opponents in key states that the party has expressed high hopes for.
He said the impulse to consider the effect of partisan polls is a “reaction to the reaction,” with various media outlets reporting on good polls for one side or new surveys that move the average.
“In a way, the polls are doing their job right,” he said. “They're getting the media to talk about a potential movement here.”
But Tranter said he ultimately expects the polling for the race will appear mostly similar right before Election Day to how it currently looks and has looked throughout much of the race. He noted that DDHQ’s model has “inched” Harris’s probability of winning down from 53 percent to 50 percent over the past two months, which is measurable, but “it’s still essentially a coin flip.”
The closeness of the race is why these slight changes are seen as notable, Tranter said.
“My take on it now is neither candidate should be surprised if they win or lose,” he said.
Date: |
-
Top stories - CBS News
Speaker Johnson pivots on questions about possible Jan. 6-like violence
House Speaker Mike Johnson diverted Sunday on questions about possible violence and security concerns ahead of the certification of the presidential election results early next year.6 days ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Trump ends town hall to listen to music, reigniting questions about his mental acuity
Donald Trump’s campaign wants its candidate to talk more about policy, but on Monday night it was all about the music.4 days ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Chris Wallace: Questions about Trump's fitness 'working for Harris'
CNN host Chris Wallace said that questions about former President Trump’s physical state, well-being and age are working in favor of Vice President Harris. “This question of mental and physical ...20 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Jerry Jones objects to being questioned about Cowboys' offseason inactivity: 'I'll get somebody else to ask these questions'
The Cowboys' owner said changes aren't coming and he has faith in his current roster to turn around a 3-3 start.4 days ago - NFL -
Politics - The Hill
Many GOP voters worried poll workers could tamper with ballots: Survey
More than half of Republican voters in a new survey said they are worried poll workers could tamper with ballots during the 2024 election, now less than three weeks away. The poll, released Friday ...5 hours ago -
Top stories - CBS News
Speaker Mike Johnson diverts on questions about possible Jan. 6-like violence
House Speaker Mike Johnson diverted from answering questions about violence after the election, saying the "greater issue" is with election integrity. "There's a lot of great work that's been done ...6 days ago -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Harris gets testy to start Fox interview as she is questioned about the border: Live
Kamala Harris was interviewed by Bret Baier of Fox News, hours after Donald Trump doubled down on remarks calling Democrats ‘enemy within’ in pre-recorded town hall on same network2 days ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Here’s why some Latinos are genuinely embracing the Republican Party
Latinos who prioritize their American identity are more likely to identify as Republicans, while those who prioritize their ethnic identity are more likely to identify as Democrats, due to ...27 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Charlamagne tha God on Walz as VP: 'I don’t see the impact'
Radio host Charlamagne tha God critiqued Vice President Harris’s choice of Gov. Tim Walz (D-Minn.) as a running mate in a Friday discussion on his show The Breakfast Club. “I don’t think he’s ...31 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
With Sinwar dead, Israel has a choice to make
Will it exploit this moment to further its military aims of eradicating Hamas? Or will it leverage Sinwar’s death as an opportunity to secure a pause in hostilities and obtain the release of the ...1 hour ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Maher: October surprise wont 'save us' from second Trump term
With Election Day just shy of two weeks away, comedian and TV personality Bill Maher urged Democrats on Friday to stop waiting for an "October surprise." "Democrats need to stop thinking an October ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Trump says he will 'do everything' at McDonalds during Pennsylvania visit
Former President Trump quipped in a recent interview that he will "do everything" at a McDonald's during his visit to battleground Pennsylvania over the weekend. "A friend of mine owns a McDonald's ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump