GOP to California: Build back better
With wildfires still burning in Southern California, congressional Republicans are getting more detailed about how they plan to handle the politically sensitive topic of delivering potentially tens of billions of dollars of federal disaster aid to the largely Democratic area.
Strings, they are making clear, will be attached.
Some House Republicans who met with President-elect Donald Trump this past weekend floated using the funding as a bargaining chip in debt-limit negotiations with Democrats. And there is an emerging consensus that some unspecified policy changes should be included to prevent future wildfires.
“We don’t play politics with disaster aid,” Speaker Mike Johnson said at a POLITICO Live event Tuesday. “But there were policy decisions that were made in California at the state and local level, by all appearances, that made this exponentially worse, and so those are things that have to be factored in with regard to the level of aid and whether there are conditions upon that.”
Johnson’s posture was echoed by other congressional Republicans — including some from disaster-prone states who have typically resisted turning federal assistance into a political football.
“I believe that if a state is so grossly mismanaged that the initial disaster is not quickly contained, then we have a responsibility to do common-sense things,” said Rep. Byron Donalds (R-Fla.).
“Rebuild maybe so that the conditions are such that the threat from fire is lessened so that we won't have to do it again,” added Rep. Carlos Giménez (R-Fla.).
Republicans have pointed to how Democrats pursued a “Build Back Better” approach to massive infrastructure and climate bills that put similar strings on federal funding to improve climate resilience. President Joe Biden issued executive orders mandating “climate-smart infrastructure.”
But critics say that emergency disaster aid is another thing entirely, and lawmakers on both sides of the aisle are pushing back on the idea.
“That’s just one of the most cruel and ignorant things you could possibly say, especially in this moment,” said Rep. Jared Huffman (D-Calif.), one of many incensed Democrats. “You don’t condition it. We didn’t do that for Louisiana; we didn’t do that for Florida. I’m hoping that that was just a dumb thing that [Johnson] said, which on reflection won’t go any further.”
Some Republicans in closest proximity to recent disasters are striking a similar tone.
Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.), who saw parts of his state ravaged by Hurricane Helene, told reporters this week conditioning aid is “not a good thing to do.” And Rep. Young Kim (R-Calif.), who represents an Orange County district with similar terrain to where the Los Angeles fires have spread, said any debate about policies should come later.
“We need to get the aid to Southern California communities as soon as possible,” Kim said Wednesday. “The conditions … is not something that we need to be focused on right now.”
Any aid package is still a ways off, with fire crews still working to extinguish the Los Angeles area fires and damage estimates even further off. Republican leaders have floated including the disaster aid into an expected government funding package that will come together in March, when funding is set to lapse.
The debt ceiling will also need to get raised in the coming months, sparking the suggestion that disaster money could serve as a sweetener to get Democratic votes for that politically unsavory task. “It’s going to be very difficult to do something with only Republican votes,” Rep. Mario Diaz-Balart (R-Fla.) said about the borrowing limit.
That kind of horse-trading would represent a new frontier in the politicization of the debt ceiling, and former Rep. Peter King (R-N.Y.), who helped push through emergency aid requests after the 9/11 terror attacks and Superstorm Sandy in 2012, said that would be a bad idea.
“You’re playing games with Americans’ solvency, our credit rating, and it’s just never gone anywhere,” he said. “We have enough real issues to address, and you can’t be tying — to me — anything and everything to the debt ceiling.”
King and other Republicans have been more open to adding policy strings to any aid requests, but they have been vague on what exactly those conditions might entail. Donalds cited “forestry management” and “building out reservoir systems that they should have built 60 years ago.”
“Let’s just mitigate the issues,” he said, “so that we’re not spending future money that is unnecessarily significant because they won’t do sound policy which is done in virtually every other state in the country.”
Those policy prescriptions, however, likely wouldn’t have much bearing on preventing a repeat of what LA has faced over the past week. The fires are in urban areas, not the forests that have been a target of Trump’s ire, and the city’s fire hydrant issues aren’t linked to the state's water management system.
Johnson, who represents a district in hurricane-prone Louisiana, acknowledged on Tuesday that tying disaster funding to policy changes is a “brand new idea” but one, he argued, that is justified “so that we can properly balance the interests of the American people and our financial condition right now.”
But Californians watching their neighbors lose their homes — and in some cases, their lives — have little appetite for lectures about the national debt or forest management.
“It’s ridiculous,” said Santa Barbara-area Rep. Salud Carbajal (D-Calif.). “It’s a fucking shame, and it speaks to the values of of my colleagues on the other side that want to play politics with those that are hurting right now and being impacted by a natural disaster.”
Emily Ngo contributed to this report.
Topics
-
GOP rep suggests California relief aid should be withheld over state policies
Rep. Warren Davidson (R-Ohio) said he believes Congress should withhold disaster relief funds from California in the wake of Los Angeles wildfires until environmental policy changes are made by the ...The Hill - 3d -
Sunday shows preview: Wildfires rage through Southern California; GOP tackles Trump agenda
Federal response teams spent the week combating Los Angeles wildfires blazing across hundreds of acres, forcing local residents to evacuate from their homes as a result of the damage. Throughout ...The Hill - 4d -
California wildfires highlight the fast pace of home building in fire-prone areas
“More people are building in fire-prone areas than ever before, and they are not building with fire resistance in mind, because it’s expensive,” one expert said.MarketWatch - 4d -
Happiness expert Gretchen Rubin on the truth behind building better habits
Bestselling author and happiness expert Gretchen Rubin talks about how to separate fact from fiction when it comes to sticking to New Year's resolutions.CBS News - Jan. 8 -
Georgia GOP boots former lieutenant governor who backed Harris
The Georgia Republican Party has booted longtime President-elect Trump critic former Lt. Gov. Geoff Duncan (R), who backed Vice President Harris’s 2024 bid for the White House. A resolution from ...The Hill - Jan. 7 -
GOP holdout Spartz to back Speaker Johnson
Rep. Victoria Spartz (R-Ind.), a key GOP vote who previously suggested she would not back Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.), minutes before the vote signaled she'd back him. "I appreciate ...The Hill - Jan. 3 -
2 dead and 18 injured in plane crash into Southern California building
Two people died and 18 were injured Thursday when a small plane crashed through the roof of a sprawling furniture manufacturing building in Southern California where at least 200 people were ...NBC News - Jan. 3 -
2 dead, 18 hurt after small plane crashes into building in Southern California
Police in Southern California say two people are dead and 18 people are hurt after a small plane crashed into a building in Fullerton, California, Thursday afternoon.ABC News - Jan. 2 -
New Yankees 1B Paul Goldschmidt looking to bounce back from down 2024 season: 'I’m better than this'
Paul Goldschmidt was introduced as the newest member of the Yankees on Thursday, saying he's hopeful he'll bounce back from his down season in 2024.Yahoo Sports - Jan. 2
More from Politico
-
'Everything's on the table': Jordan mulls calling Jack Smith to Judiciary
Politico - 2h -
Watch: Senators grill Pam Bondi at attorney general confirmation hearing
Politico - 3h -
Google CEO to attend inauguration
Politico - 3h -
Johnson removes Mike Turner as House Intelligence chair
The Ohio Republican has been an outspoken advocate for Ukraine funding and other hawkish national security stances.Politico - 3h -
Trump’s pick for budget chief echoes his ‘power of the purse’ dreams
The president-elect's nominee for White House budget director reiterated that Trump believes law protecting Congress’ funding power is unconstitutional.Politico - 3h
More in Politics
-
Watch Live: Biden delivers farewell address
President Biden is delivering his fifth and final address from the Oval Office five days before the end of his single term in office.CBS News - 14m -
Live coverage: Biden's farewell speech comes on heels of raucous confirmation hearings
President Biden is set to deliver a primetime farewell speech on Wednesday from the Oval Office in the final days of his presidency. It will be one of Biden’s final speeches in the closing days of ...The Hill - 32m -
Watch live: Biden gives farewell address from Oval Office
President Biden is set to address the nation Wednesday evening in a farewell speech from the Oval Office with just days left in his first and only term. This will be among Biden's final speeches as ...The Hill - 1h -
Key Trump cabinet picks appear at Senate confirmation hearings
Some of President-elect Trump's key Cabinet picks appeared at Senate confirmation hearings. Former Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi, Trump's pick for attorney general, vowed to keep politics out ...NBC News - 1h -
Democrats grill Trump budget pick
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Trump’s pick for budget chief faces fire in hearing Democrats grilled Russell ...The Hill - 1h