GOP presses ahead with holding Blinken in contempt over Afghanistan testimony
The Republican-led House Foreign Affairs Committee on Tuesday moved forward with holding Secretary of State Antony Blinken in contempt of a subpoena to appear before the committee, drawing accusations from Democratic members of partisan maneuvering ahead of the November elections.
Blinken argued it was not possible for him to attend the hearing, given his commitments at the United Nations General Assembly in New York City this week. He was among the U.S. representatives watching President Biden deliver his final address to the U.N. Tuesday morning as the hearing gaveled in.
The contempt measure is related to the Chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee Rep. Michael McCaul’s (R-Texas) pursuit of the secretary’s testimony following the publication earlier this month of a three-year investigation into the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan.
Democrats have slammed the report as partisan and narrowly focused on Biden’s execution of the withdrawal — a chaotic and deadly episode— without taking into account the role former President Trump had in agreeing to exit Afghanistan, and the two-decade scope of U.S. policy there.
“This investigation is just not about serious fact-finding or oversight, it’s about narrowing the scope of the end of the United States longest war to just a few months of the Biden administration, not for the purpose of getting the facts right… but to play politics,” Rep. Gregory Meeks (D-N.Y.), the ranking member of the committee, said in opening remarks.
“Why is there suddenly a rush to hold this contempt vote when the secretary has made it very clear, time and time again, that he’s willing to testify?” he added. “Is it the elections coming up on Nov. 5? Is it politics that's causing this urgency?”
The House will recess this week and through the month of October to campaign for the November election, and resume afterwards.
Blinken, in a letter to McCaul sent on Sept 22, said he had “personally sought to reach an accommodation” with the chairman for alternate dates to testify before the committee, and offered either of his top deputies to testify before the committee on days he wasn’t available.
Blinken said he had spoken twice by phone with McCaul about trying to find alternate dates for testifying.
“I am profoundly disappointed you have once again chosen to send me a subpoena and threaten contempt, rather than engage with me and the Department in a meaningful way to resolve this matter through the constitutionally-mandated accommodation process,” the letter read, according to a copy obtained by The Hill.
But McCaul accused Blinken of stone-walling requests for his testimony in September, and dismissed the State Department’s defense that the secretary had testified over the U.S. withdrawal 14 times in front of Congress and four times in front of the committee, saying he sought testimony specifically on the findings of his report, which was published on Sep. 8.
“I take no joy in this procedure, after months of the secretary ignoring countless requests for his testimony, I was forced to subpoena with him to discuss my findings of the catastrophic withdrawal from Afghanistan,” McCaul said at Tuesday’s hearing. “Let the record reflect that for four months I patiently waited on his availability for September, but Bilnken made false promises and accused me of politicizing this important issue.”
“I offered any day in September, just a few hours in September. The secretary couldn’t find one day, couldn’t find one hour, to come before the United States Congress and respond to our report so we could legislate on that. I find that incredible. His timing, not mine.” he added.
But Democrats seized on the optics of forcing the secretary to appear before the committee in September, ahead of the election, and at the exact time he is representing the country at the U.N.’s annual gathering. Blinken, in his letter, detailed his particularly busy schedule on Tuesday.
“This is a purely political move. We are 40 some days before a presidential election and isn't it shocking that there is no accommodation for Secretary Blinken’s request that his appearance be rescheduled some date other than when he had to appear before the UN General Assembly,” said Rep. Susan Wild (D-Penn.).
“Let me be clear, I was vocally and publicly critical of the execution of the withdrawal of Afghanistan.. But I was also vocal about bringing this war to an end,” she added.
Still, both Republicans and Democrats agreed they want Blinken to appear before the committee, and the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan in August 2021 has received bipartisan criticism. It remains among the darkest stains on President Biden’s term in office, with the administration ill-prepared for the rapid collapse of the U.S.-backed Afghan government as the Taliban surrounded Kabul, and the massive civilian evacuation that ensued.
A terrorist bombing at the Kabul airport carried out by ISIS-K killed 13 U.S. service members and killed and wounded scores of Afghans. And while more than 120,000 people were flown out of Afghanistan over the course of two weeks, thousands of American citizens and Afghan allies were left behind amid the drawdown of the U.S. military and diplomatic presence in the country.
Republicans have homed in on the bombing as a defining symbol of Biden’s mishandling of the withdrawal, and McCaul has focused his investigative efforts on seeking accountability for the security failures that allowed the attack.
But Democrats have slammed the report as a political attack, and say it has tainted the work of a committee that often views itself as rising above partisan politics.
“It is one of the very few vestiges of decency, collaboration, cooperation and shared principles that remain in the United States Congress and I think what’s contemptible is that we’re doing this today,” said Rep. Dean Phillips (D-Minn.), a gold-star son whose father was killed fighting in Vietnam.
Phillips said an investigation into the failures of Afghanistan are necessary to honor the more than 2,000 soldiers who died fighting over 20 years in the country, as well as those who were injured in combat, like his colleague on the panel, Rep. Brian Mast (R-Fla.), who lost both his legs serving in Afghanistan.
But he criticized the polarization of the committee under McCaul’s chairmanship.
“Damn, have we lost respect, reverence for this institution, for our friendships, for our collegiality,” Phillips said. “And that’s all I wanted to say today, for the American public that is once again watching us, watching us act like this, is what’s contemptible, and I apologize to every single one of the 350 million or so Americans that are wondering what the heck is going on in this most important institution in the world.”
Date: |
-
CBS News - Top stories
House panel weighs holding Blinken in contempt over Afghanistan testimony
Republicans on the House Foreign Affairs Committee recently released a critical report about the Biden administration's handling of the chaotic exit from Afghanistan.5 hours ago -
Politico - Politics
House GOP moves toward holding Blinken in contempt of Congress
6 hours ago -
NBC News - Politics
House Foreign Affairs Committee subpoenas Blinken to testify on Afghanistan withdrawal
Secretary of State Antony Blinken has been subpoenaed to testify before the House Foreign Affairs Committee about the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan. NBC News’ Ali Vitali reports on how committee ...8 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: House GOP leaders hold presser as shutdown looms
House Republican leaders are set to hold a press conference Tuesday morning following their closed-door meeting, as the threat of a government shutdown still hangs in the air. Speaker Mike Johnson ...6 hours ago -
Politico - Politics
Hours before vote, Trump again presses House GOP on short-term spending bill
6 days ago - Donald Trump -
CNBC - Business
China central bank releases slate of support measures amid a deepening economic slump
Beijing will cut the amount of cash banks need to have on hand, known as the reserve requirement ratio, or RRR, by 50 basis points in the near term, People's Bank of China Gov. Pan Gongsheng said.14 hours ago - China -
NBC News - Politics
GOP candidate for governor urged to drop out over explicit posts
Mark Robinson, the Republican candidate for governor in North Carolina, is facing pressure to drop out, over inflammatory and lewd comments he reportedly made online. He denies these reports and ...4 days ago -
Yahoo News - World
Italy holds a trial into the killing of a woman that sparked debate over femicide
Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Gunfire damages Harris campaign office in Arizona
An Arizona office used by Vice President Harris's campaign and state Democratic congressional candidates was damaged by gunfire on Monday, according to report from NBC News. The Tempe City Police ...25 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Biden gives Climate Week speech at Bloomberg forum
President Biden will address the Bloomberg Global Business Forum on Tuesday in observance of Climate Week. The remarks are expected to review the efforts his administration has made to address the ...27 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Russia military planes detected off Alaskan coast after Army deploys troops to region
The U.S. military detected and tracked four Russian military planes off the coast of Alaska Monday amid a spike in such activity from Moscow off the U.S. coast. The four Russian aircraft were ...34 minutes ago - Russia -
The Hill - Politics
22 states want to employ 1 million people in climate apprenticeships by 2035
Governors of 22 states and two U.S. territories say they want to get 1 million people to complete apprenticeships related to low-carbon energy or other climate-friendly jobs by 2035. The U.S. ...36 minutes ago - Climate -
The Hill - Politics
7 in 10 worried about politically motivated violence after election: Survey
Seven in 10 likely voters are worried about politically motivated violence after the 2024 presidential election, a new poll found. In the poll, from Quinnipiac University, 73 percent of likely ...46 minutes ago