Democrats should expect to keep losing in 2026
Historical trends suggest that President Trump should suffer a midterm setback in 2026. It is axiomatic that the party out of the presidency prospers in midterm elections.
But current trends offer a counterargument. And Sen. Gary Peters’s (D-Mich.) recent retirement announcement has made Democrats’ already deceptively difficult 2026 even more difficult.
Moreover, if there has ever been a president to buck trends, it is the man in the White House right now.
The history is clear: From 1938 through 2022, the president’s party has a record of only 2-20 when it comes to net-seat midterm outcomes. Only George W. Bush, back in 2002, saw a gain of seats in both the House and the Senate. In 2018, Trump suffered a dramatic 40-seat loss in the House that ushered in two years of hearings and investigations and two impeachments.
So why won't the 2026 midterms hold to historical form for Democrats?
For one thing, the last two elections (2022 and 2024) have been disappointments to both parties when it comes to winning seats. In 2022, Republicans did not reap nearly the House windfall they expected, although they did narrowly win the House. In 2024, Democrats failed to flip it back.
One of the reasons for these recent bipartisan disappointments is that gerrymandering in the House has reached such an art form that there simply are not that many seats in play anymore. And as to 2026 specifically, the map is not as favorable to Democrats as it at first appears.
In the Senate, Democrats would seem to have an advantage because, of the 33 seats up in 2026, only 13 are held by Democrats. Republicans are defending the other 20. However, looking more closely, Democrats have three vulnerable seats to defend — those of Sens. Jon Ossoff (D-Ga.), and Jeanne Shaheen (D-N.H.) and now Peters’ open seat in Michigan. Trump just won both Georgia and Michigan in 2024, and he came within three points in New Hampshire.
Republicans have only two seats that could really be labeled vulnerable — those of Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) and the open seat of Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), assuming he retires. Collins has been an elusive target for Democrats for decades now. Kentucky, meanwhile, is a deeply red state that Trump won by more than 30 percentage points in 2024.
Trump also came within 10 percentage points of winning several states where Senate Democrats will be running in 2026: Sens. Cory Booker (D-N.J.), Ben Ray Lujan (D-N.M.) Tina Smith (D-Minn.) and Mark Warner (D-Va.)
Does that make these seats vulnerable? Not necessarily, but it should make Democrats cautious.
The House is numerically much more likely to flip because of Republicans’ precarious 220-215 majority. But again, appearances can be deceiving. Democrats were expected to flip the House in 2024 and did not. There are also 13 House Democrats who hold seats Trump won in 2024. There are also 46 House seats where Democrats won by 10 percentage points or less in 2024 — meaning that a mere 5-point swing could flip them.
And expect Trump himself to be a major factor in the 2026 midterms, just as he was eight years earlier. Note that Trump 2025 is much stronger than Trump 2017, at least for now. According to Real Clear Politics’ average of national polling, Trump has a net plus-four job approval and net plus-one favorability rating. In comparison, on January 29, 2017, Trump had a minus-8 favorability rating.
There are also regular polls that show Trump's agenda is more than he is — which is to say, he could gain further as his agenda is more fully implemented.
Democrats are also arguably weaker than they have been since Obama won the presidency in 2008. Currently, they lack a leader and an agenda. If you don’t believe it, ask yourself what prominent Democrat would Democrat candidates want to put next to their picture in a campaign ad. Joe Biden? Kamala Harris? Tim Walz? Gavin Newsom?
The same applies to the Democrats' agenda. The issues on which prominent Democrats vowed to oppose the incoming Trump administration — illegal immigration, electric vehicle subsidies, transgender surgeries, unrestricted abortion — were all losers in 2024 and will be again in 2026.
Trump also has a huge improvement over 2017 because he is following Biden this time instead of Obama. The latter was well remembered at the time. The former is now widely viewed as a failure.
Two years is a long time. But really, it is just 20 months. In politics, 20 months is tomorrow. And today, tomorrow doesn’t look all that good for Democrats.
J.T. Young is the author of “Unprecedented Assault: How Big Government Unleashed America’s Socialist Left." He has more than three decades’ experience working in Congress, the Department of Treasury, the Office of Management, and Budget, and representing a Fortune 20 company.
Topics
-
This obscure law is one reason Trump's agenda keeps losing in court
Lawyers challenging Trump's use of executive power are turning to a familiar weapon in their armory: the Administrative Procedure Act.NBC News - 5h -
Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei warns: AI will match ‘country of geniuses’ by 2026
Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei warns AI will reach genius-level capabilities by 2026, calling Paris Summit a "missed opportunity" as U.S. and European leaders clash over regulation of rapidly advancing ...VentureBeat - 14h -
Democrats are divided on government shutdown threats
Politico - 23h -
Who Should Tell Employees About Raises?
… And two other tricky workplace dilemmas.Inc. - 1d -
Tim Scott to top donors: 2026 will likely break spending records
Politico - 1d -
Treasury Secretary Expected to Visit Kyiv
The visit by Scott Bessent will be the first by a Trump official since the president’s return to office and comes amid uncertainty about the future of U.S. support for Ukraine.The New York Times - 3h -
Where the 2026 House map stands for Democrats
The Cook Political Report is already spotlighting toss-up races to watch in 2026. Erin Covey, U.S. House editor for the Cook Political Report, joins "America Decides" with analysis of the contests ...CBS News - 14h -
More job cuts expected at Justice Department, FBI
Staff within the Justice Department and FBI are on edge and bracing for more firings due to the changes under the new Trump administration. CBS News Department of Justice correspondent Scott ...CBS News - 1d -
Gold could hit $3,000 soon and $4,000 in 2026, this market pro says. Here’s why.
Yardeni: Inflation, tariffs, plus countries accumulating gold as a haven from U.S. sanctions.MarketWatch - 1d -
Trump expected to pardon Rod Blagojevich
President Trump is expected to pardon former Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich, who served eight years in prison on corruption charges until Trump commuted his sentence in 2020. A source familiar with ...The Hill - 1d -
Littler loses early in opening Players Championship
Luke Littler is knocked out of the first Players Championship of 2025 as he suffers a 6-3 defeat by Joe Cullen, who goes on to lose to Rob Cross in the final.BBC News - 1d -
The Democratic Party is not dead yet
Democrats can’t ignore the Americans’ disillusionment with our political institutions. They need to offer a plausible and persuasive message of change.The Hill - 2d -
Senate Republicans just keep rolling over for Trump
Republican senators have no backbone when it comes to Trump's nominees.The Hill - 2d -
Don’t expect Hamas to surrender any time soon
Surrender is one of the most essential rules in international humanitarian law. Don't expect it any time soon in the Middle East.The Hill - 2d -
Is it true that … you should feed a cold and starve a fever?
A professor of medicine weighs in on the old wives tale, and discusses the fastest routes to recovery. Tom Wilkinson, professor of respiratory medicine at the University of Southampton, says there ...The Guardian - 2d -
'Losing the Super Bowl is the worst feeling in the world' - Mahomes
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes says losing the Super Bowl is "the worst feeling in the world" after his side 40-22 to the Philadelphia Eagles in New Orleans.BBC News - 2d -
2026 Super Bowl odds: Eagles open as favorites; Commanders, Bengals among five value bets to consider placing
Examining the odds for next year's Super Bowl winnerCBS Sports - 2d -
When and where will Super Bowl LX be played in 2026?
Here's everything we know about Super Bowl LX in 2026, including where and when it will take place and what channel it will be on.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Aaron Rodgers Is Expected to Leave the Jets
Woody Johnson, the team’s co-owner, is said to have listened to the feedback from the current coaching staff, prompting speculation of a split.The New York Times - 2d -
Should The NHL Change Its Playoff Format?
If you’ve grown tired of the NHL’s wild-card playoff format, there are a few other options worth considering.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Jets, Aaron Rodgers expected to part ways
Aaron Rodgers' time with the New York Jets will end after two seasons and an announcement about the future hall of fame quarterback's future could be made this week.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Should The Rangers Attempt To Sign Jesse Puljujärvi?
Analyzing weather or not the Rangers should sign Jesse Puljujärvi.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Rangers players 'lose everything' in cup humiliation
Rangers players have lost all of the credit they built with the fans in recent weeks after suffering one of the worst Scottish Cup defeats in the club's history.BBC News - 2d -
A compromise on emergency abortions that red states should embrace
It is time for states that have banned abortion to put an end to the horror stories of women being refused emergency medical treatment when their pregnancies go terribly wrong.The Hill - 2d -
Where is 2026 Super Bowl? Looking ahead to next year's championship game, location of Super Bowl LX
The big game will be held in Santa Clara at Levi's Stadium -- home of the 49ersCBS Sports - 2d -
7 competitive primaries to watch in 2026
Primary battles are already underway in key Senate and gubernatorial races ahead of the 2026 midterms, an election that will determine not only control of Congress but also the governorships in ...The Hill - 3d -
'We are figuring it out': Democrats struggle to keep up with Trump's dizzying pace
Actions are coming at so dizzying a pace that it can be tough to track what Trump has done and what he's turned around and undone.NBC News - 3d -
Record Valentine's Day spending expected
Valentine's Day is just a week away, and candy sales are expected to soar. It's a busy time of year for chocolatiers, including Norman Love Confections, a Florida company that produces ...CBS News - 3d -
An expecting mom's headache was an early warning of an alarming condition
Jennifer Tavares' pregnancy was going smoothly until a headache and swelling signaled she might have a dangerous condition.CBS News - 4d -
Trump should not take bond investors for granted
It needs only a small reduction in the dollar slice of global reserves to hit prices and raise borrowing costsFinancial Times - 4d -
Democrats Take Aim at Elon Musk
It’s the first sign of unified opposition for a rudderless and leaderless Democratic Party.The New York Times - 4d -
Trump wants to deregulate. Progressives should help him.
From Jimmy Carter to Ted Kennedy, progressives once saw the wisdom of cutting red tape — especially if the tape tied the hands of consumers and would-be competitors in order to privilege industry ...The Hill - 4d -
FireAid benefit show will keep streaming for another year
The broadcast of the FireAid benefit concert, which took place Jan. 30 at Inglewood's Intuit Dome and Kia Forum, will stay in circulation on multiple platforms.Los Angeles Times - 4d -
The Trauma of Losing Your Home in the Eaton Fire
Daniel Ramirez, a Times audio engineer, writes about the trauma of losing everything in the Eaton fire.The New York Times - 4d -
Here’s how Democrats should fight back against Trump | Margaret Sullivan
Democrats in a new generation are punching back hard. And, in so doing, showing their colleagues how to overcome their reputation for dithering. It’s easy to be disgusted with the Democratic party ...The Guardian - 4d -
One year to the 2026 Milano Cortina Olympics: Twenty athletes from Team USA to watch
With the Winter Olympics set to begin one year from today, here’s a look at 20 Americans worth keeping an eye onYahoo Sports - 5d -
The Physics That Keeps a Crowd From Becoming a Stampede
A group of scientists studying the San Fermín festival in Pamplona, Spain, believe there’s a way to predict the motions of a large crowd.The New York Times - 6d
More from The Hill
-
Trump’s Gaza proposal is reckless. Here is a feasible plan.
Instead of such headline-chasing chicanery, what is needed is a serious, enforceable regional security arrangement — one that anchors stability in Arab-state involvement, coordinated security ...The Hill - 19m -
Apple renames Gulf of Mexico as Gulf of America on maps
Apple Maps has renamed the Gulf of Mexico the Gulf of America, after the Trump administration updated the U.S. database for geographic names to reflect the president’s order renaming the body of ...The Hill - 20m -
Read: House budget resolution
House Republicans on Wednesday released their budget resolution in an effort to advance President Trump's ambitious legislative agenda. Rep. Jodey Arrington (R-Texas), the chair of the House Budget ...The Hill - 22m -
Watch live: Senate weighs importance of Greenland to US amid Trump acquisition push
The Senate Commerce Committee on Wednesday morning is holding a hearing looking into the importance of Greenland to U.S. interests. The hearing comes as President Trump has consistently floated the ...The Hill - 31m -
Global war fears rising among security experts: Survey
Global war fears are rising among experts around the world with over 40 percent expecting a new world conflict in the next decade, according to a new survey. The poll, released Wednesday by the ...The Hill - 33m
More in Politics
-
Trump’s Gaza proposal is reckless. Here is a feasible plan.
Instead of such headline-chasing chicanery, what is needed is a serious, enforceable regional security arrangement — one that anchors stability in Arab-state involvement, coordinated security ...The Hill - 19m -
Apple renames Gulf of Mexico as Gulf of America on maps
Apple Maps has renamed the Gulf of Mexico the Gulf of America, after the Trump administration updated the U.S. database for geographic names to reflect the president’s order renaming the body of ...The Hill - 20m -
Read: House budget resolution
House Republicans on Wednesday released their budget resolution in an effort to advance President Trump's ambitious legislative agenda. Rep. Jodey Arrington (R-Texas), the chair of the House Budget ...The Hill - 22m -
Watch live: Senate weighs importance of Greenland to US amid Trump acquisition push
The Senate Commerce Committee on Wednesday morning is holding a hearing looking into the importance of Greenland to U.S. interests. The hearing comes as President Trump has consistently floated the ...The Hill - 31m -
Global war fears rising among security experts: Survey
Global war fears are rising among experts around the world with over 40 percent expecting a new world conflict in the next decade, according to a new survey. The poll, released Wednesday by the ...The Hill - 33m