Defenders of a failed status quo are spreading a myth that school choice is racist
Opponents of voucher and other educational choice programs have been pushing a new narrative concerning the origins of such programs: that they were born in 1950s Southern racism.
Although segregationists did attempt to use vouchers to circumvent the Supreme Court’s order to desegregate public schools in Brown v. Board of Education, that was by no means the origin of educational choice. In fact, it was an aberration.
As I discuss in the Syracuse Law Review, the true roots of school choice run deeper — two centuries deeper. The modern educational choice movement, meanwhile, which counts Black parents among its most fervent supporters, arose in inner city Washington, D.C., Milwaukee and Cleveland. This movement traces its lineage to classical liberal thinkers — not to reactionary racists.
The gradual turn to race as the basis for attacks on educational choice began in 2017. That year, the Center for American Progress published a report titled The Racist Origins of Private School Vouchers. It spun an origin story that grounded the educational choice movement in racial bigotry. According to the report, vouchers had their genesis in the 1950s South, where states used them to evade the Supreme Court’s decision in Brown. Rather than see their public schools integrated, the report explained, Southern states created voucher programs that enabled white students to attend all-white private schools.
This argument quickly gained traction in the court of public opinion, and it was only a matter of time before it found its way into a court of law, as well. For instance, a recent lawsuit challenging an educational choice program in Arkansas alleges that the “predecessors” of the program were segregationist voucher proposals struck down by courts in the late 1950s. That is hardly the case.
The genealogy of school choice traces to two of the greatest intellectual influences on America’s founders: Adam Smith and Thomas Paine. In "The Wealth of Nations," Smith posited ways to inject competition into education as a means of improving teacher effectiveness and responsiveness. And in "Rights of Man," Paine advocated a true voucher system to provide for the education of children from poor and low-income families.
Fast-forward to the mid-19th century, when John Stuart Mill, widely regarded as the father of modern constitutional liberalism, called for vouchers in his classic work "On Liberty." He urged government to “leave to parents to obtain the education where and how they pleased, and content itself with helping to pay the school fees of the poorer classes of children, and defraying the entire school expenses of those who have no one else to pay for them.”
It was this classical liberal tradition that Nobel laureate economist Milton Friedman, considered the father of the modern educational choice movement, built upon. But Friedman was not the only champion of choice in the 20th century. Progressives in the 1960s and 70s, including sociologist and former New Republic editor Christopher Jencks, Harvard Graduate School of Education dean Ted Sizer and Berkeley law professor John Coons, advocated for vouchers as a means of empowering poor and minority families failed by the public-school establishment.
And it was Black intellectuals, activists and elected officials such as Polly Williams, Howard Fuller, Fannie Lewis, Anthony Williams and Virginia Walden Ford who led the charge for educational choice programs adopted in Milwaukee, Cleveland and the District of Columbia in the 1990s and early 2000s.
Those programs were certainly pioneering, but they were not the first school choice programs to operate in this country. In 1802, the Pennsylvania legislature enacted a law that required municipalities to pay for the education of poor students at “any school in their neighborhood” chosen by their parents.
In 1856, the Texas legislature passed a law appropriating funds to counties based on student population, directing county courts to apportion those funds “among the children between the ages of six and eighteen years, who may attend any school in their respective counties.
And around the turn of the 20th century, Vermont and Maine adopted voucher programs to provide for the education of children in towns that lacked public schools.
It would be irresponsible to ignore the use of vouchers to evade school integration. But it is also important to understand two critical aspects of that ugly episode.
First, vouchers were being used as a means not of maximizing parental choice in education, but of denying it. In fact, they were often used as part of a bigger scheme that included closure of the public schools that were being forced to integrate. Students were given vouchers in the public schools’ stead, and in many areas, all-white private schools, or “segregation academies,” were the only option, leaving Black families with no choice at all (and white families without the choice of a public school). This objective — denying choice to maintain segregation — was the opposite of the goal of today’s educational choice movement: maximizing parental choice to ensure that every child can get the education that will work best.
It is also important to remember that these voucher and public-school closure schemes were often advocated for by the public-school establishment itself. In many instances, the public schools simply turned over their facilities and equipment to the new, all-white supposedly private schools, which were often staffed by the very same teachers and administrators.
We should never ignore that vouchers were used for horrible ends in the post-Brown South. But nor should we accept a false origin story. Educational choice — as an idea and a practice — is far older than Brown and has noble origins. Its brief deployment by racists as a tool to circumvent the Supreme Court was an opportunistic aberration, one in which the public-school establishment played an unfortunate part.
Michael Bindas is a senior attorney with the Institute for Justice and author of School Choice is Racist (and Other Myths).
Date: |
-
The Guardian - World
Trump says he won’t participate in future debates as Harris says ‘we owe it to the voters to have another’ – live
Trump says he won’t debate Harris but claims he won the matchup; Harris tells North Carolina crowd that Americans should see another one. Harris heads to North Carolina as Trump says ‘there will ...8 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Trump Ally Laura Loomer's Racist Comments Draw Rebuke From Marjorie Taylor Greene
Loomer’s influence on the former president has long concerned some of his aides.1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
CBS Sports - Sports
Heat to unveil Dwyane Wade statue outside arena in October; Rick Ross to perform during two-day celebration
The bronze statue will be unveiled a day before Miami plays Detroit on 'Dwyane Wade Statue Night'1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
White House: Loomer mocking Harris’s Indian heritage is ‘racist poison’
The White House on Thursday condemned right-wing activist Laura Loomer for mocking Vice President Harris’s Indian heritage. Loomer, a former congressional candidate, recently said on social media ...2 hours ago -
MarketWatch - Business
A Lumen executive talks AI, Verizon’s fiber deal — and meme-stock status
MarketWatch recently caught up with Lumen CFO Chris Stansbury, who discussed the opportunities ahead in AI and consumer fiber.2 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Debate moderators failed to ask Harris the most important question
That question: “Why are you here?”2 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Trump fails (again) to hit Biden-Harris on national security
The former commander in chief’s failure to take advantage of the abject incompetence of President Biden and his national security team is yet another missed opportunity that is turning a race Trump ...3 hours ago - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
Most school shootings happen outside school walls
CBS News analysis of data on every U.S. school shooting since 1966 found many safety steps taken by school administrators don't address a significant threat to students and teachers.3 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Greene, Loomer get into back-and-forth over 'racist' Harris attack
Two top allies of former President Trump are warring on social media about a bigoted social media post mocking Vice President Harris's Indian heritage, exposing fault lines within the Republican ...6 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Rape crisis centre failed to protect women-only spaces, review finds
The centre unfairly dismissed a worker who believed victims should know the sex of staff who deal with their case.10 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Harris campaigned $47M in 24 post-debate
Vice President Harris’s campaign raised $47 million in the 24 hours after the debate against former President Trump, a campaign official said on Thursday. The haul was driven by grassroots ...16 minutes ago - Kamala Harris -
The Hill - Politics
Senate Dem: ‘Neither party has any credibility’ on taxes and debt levels
Ahead of expirations in the tax code scheduled for next year, Sen. Mark Warner (D-Va.) said Thursday that neither Democrats nor Republicans were particularly trustworthy when it comes to the ...26 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
FDA approves Apple's AirPod hearing aid capability
Apple’s new Airpod Pros will double as an over the counter hearing aid. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved a hearing aid feature, which is a software-only mobile medical application on ...30 minutes ago - FDA -
The Hill - Politics
Harris mocks Trump's debate performance at campaign rally
Vice President Harris on Thursday mocked former President Trump’s debate performance, calling him out for having “concepts of a plan” at a rally in North Carolina. Harris poked at Trump for saying ...32 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Democrats seek to tax fossil fuel companies over climate change
A large group of Democrats is looking to force the fossil fuel industry to pay for climate change. Lawmakers unveiled a bill Thursday that would allow the Treasury Department to impose fees on ...52 minutes ago - Climate