Debate moderators failed to ask Harris the most important question
“Vice President Harris, you and President Trump were elected four years ago,” began the second sentence debate moderator David Muir of ABC News uttered to kick off Tuesday night’s showdown between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris.
Muir clearly meant to say “President Biden” in his question, but he, like his co-moderator Linsey Davis, had Trump on the mind all night. It was an embarrassing and inauspicious start, but instructive about the incompetence to come.
Tuesday could have been an important opportunity to showcase two very different visions for America. Instead, the performance by all four participants in that barren room was lacking. Harris stuck to her memorized soliloquies and baited Trump rather than answer any direct questions with a substantive response.
For his part, Trump gleefully took the bait every time, triggered by Harris’s obvious poking and prodding at his ego. He focused on the tiny trees while ignoring the forest entirely.
The moderators were clearly focused on walking away from the night winning praise from the elite consensus-pushers in the Acela media: fact-checking Trump at every turn, sometimes incorrectly, while ignoring Harris’ false statements entirely. That put them in lockstep with their colleagues in post-debate coverage, like Daniel Dale on CNN, who actually tried to sell the narrative that Trump made 33 false claims while Harris made....one.
But the ABC debate will be remembered not for what was said, but for what wasn’t — both from the candidates and the moderators. Because Muir and Davis had more than 90 minutes to ask the most important question of the Democratic nominee, and they failed to do so.
That question: “Why are you here?”
Seventy-five days earlier, President Joe Biden was the one standing opposite Trump on the presidential debate stage. And what a chaotic, consequential 75 days it has been. Ultra-casual consumers of the news might be wondering what happened in the intervening two-and-a-half months to flip the page from one nominee to another.
Why was the sitting president jettisoned off to California vacations and beach trips while his vice president was installed as the nominee in a matter of hours — with no voter involvement? And most importantly, what did Harris know about Biden’s cognitive decline and mental fitness? How could she not know? And why did she keep what she knew a secret from the country and the world?
It was left to Trump himself to raise the issue in a brief aside that, characteristically for his Tuesday performance, he undermined while throwing out a bizarre insult in the middle of his rant. “She got no votes, he got 14 million votes. You talk about a threat to democracy, he [Biden] got 14 million votes and they threw him out of office,” he said. “And you know what, I’ll give you a little secret, he hates her, he can’t stand her. But he got 14 million votes, and they threw him out.”
A few seconds later, Muir jumped in with a “your time is up, we’ve got a lot more to get to.”
And he did — like Trump’s threats to democracy, while ignoring the very undemocratic way a few thousand delegates selected Harris as the Democratic nominee after the sham of a primary process had already been concluded.
This echoed a similar lack of interest in how Harris became the nominee, and what she really knew about her boss’s fitness for office, during the lone interview she has given. “After the debate you insisted that President Biden was extraordinarily strong. Given where we are now, do you have any regrets about what you told the American people?” asked Dana Bash near the end of the sit-down.
“Not at all,” answered Harris, as she rambled some talking points about the administration. Bash moved on right away: When Biden called and said he was dropping out, “what was that like?” she asked, as if she were Oprah talking to a celebrity about a new relationship.
This matters, because it relates to other elements of the Harris story. ABC allowed her to coast on “my principles haven’t changed” when it comes to serious policy positions she says she no longer believes — everything from banning fracking to, yes, “gender transition surgery for detained migrants."
But that’s not acceptable. In the same way these policy evolutions have taken place in the dark with no explanation, so has her leap from vice president to Democratic nominee, with no accounting for what she actually knew behind the scenes.
And it matters that she wasn’t asked to address the elephant in the 2024 electoral room once and for all, because she so rarely offers the public the opportunity to hear her answering a journalist’s questions.
ABC News avoided the issue entirely because they don’t care — they don’t see it as a problem. When Biden was flailing in early July and looked to be heading for a November loss to Trump, the legacy media suddenly became very curious to uncover the truth. Now that Harris is better positioned, why rock the boat?
Harris needs to sit for another interview soon — alone this time. And when the next member of the media gets a chance to ask her the key questions that matter, hopefully someone gets at the basics: “You’re the candidate. How did we get here?”
Steve Krakauer, a NewsNation contributor, is the author of “Uncovered: How the Media Got Cozy with Power, Abandoned Its Principles, and Lost the People” and editor and host of the Fourth Watch newsletter and podcast.
Date: |
Topics
-
The Hill - Politics
The Harris-Trump debate gave us more questions than answers on foreign policy
Foreign policy was not a major focus of the discussion, but what was said — and left unsaid — by the candidates was cause for concern.8 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Joe Rogan says Harris is 'nailing it' in debate with Trump
Podcaster Joe Rogan gave Vice President Harris her props after the Sept. 10 ABC News debate telling listeners she’s “nailing it.” “I just wanna say, whoever’s helping her, whoever’s coaching her, ...3 hours ago - Donald Trump -
ESPN - Sports
How all 32 teams stack up in this week’s Power Rankings: Rises for Saints, Vikings, Seahawks
Our ranks have shuffled. Plus, reporters pick the most important backup / role player on each team.36 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
O'Reilly: Trump should ask Harris to co-sign anti-hatred letter
O'Reilly thinks Donald Trump should call on Kamala Harris to co-sign a letter to "tamp down" on political hatred.10 hours ago - Donald Trump -
NBC News - Top stories
Harris to field questions from Black reporters weeks after Trump questioned her heritage
Kamala Harris will take questions from three members of the National Association of Black Journalists on Tuesday, six weeks after Trump's NABJ conference appearance.13 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Harris holds 6-point national lead over Trump in postdebate polling
Vice President Harris is leading former President Trump nationally by 6 points, according to a polling released a week after the first debate between the major party nominees. The Morning Consult ...10 hours ago - Donald Trump -
ABC News - Top stories
Senate IVF bill fails again to advance on mostly party line vote
Senate Majority Leader Schumer wanted to put Republicans on record with their vote on IVF, which has become a flashpoint in the presidential election.2 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Lucy Letby: mother of murdered baby demands apology over hospital ‘failings’
Mother of Child D describes feeling she was ‘losing mind’ as she pushed for investigations. The mother of a baby girl murdered by Lucy Letby has demanded an apology from the hospital for “dozens” ...9 hours ago -
ESPN - Sports
Alisson on more UCL games: Nobody asks players
Liverpool goalkeeper Alisson Becker has said football's governing bodies must begin consulting players ahead of the arrival of new Champions League format.49 minutes ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
GOP senator insults Arab-American witness at hate crimes hearing
Sen. John Kennedy (R-La.) told an Arab-American witness that she should "hide [her] head in a bag" after repeatedly asking her if she supported Hamas and Hezbollah during a congressional hearing on ...20 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Former governors press for election certification by federal deadline
Former governors pressed for election certification by the federal December deadline, saying the process "is not open to debate" in a Tuesday letter addressed to current governors. “The voters in ...32 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Mail voting faces significant challenges ahead of November
Election officials are warning that mail voting could face delays and disruption if the U.S. mail delivery system fails to fix persistent issues ahead of November’s contests. In a recent letter to ...45 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Johnson outlines economic plan under Trump if GOP controls government in 2025
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) on Tuesday outlined his economic agenda for the first 100 days under a second Trump administration — a plan that assumes Republicans will win unified control of ...47 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Republicans question proposal to boost Secret Service funding
Some Republicans are questioning whether a boost in spending for the Secret Service as part of the upcoming government funding bill would help protect former President Trump in the immediate term. ...53 minutes ago - Republican Party