Deepfakes in politics and society require more than one solution
![Deepfakes in politics and society require more than one solution](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/08/deepfake_video_artificial_intelligence_AI_04032024_GettyImages-2147833902.jpg?w=900)
This week, former President Trump falsely claimed that images of a recent Harris campaign rally were fabricated by artificial intelligence — the first clear instance of a major American candidate sewing deepfake uncertainty.
Trump’s comments come on the back of an increasing tempo of deepfake deception, including someone’s ham-handed attempt to use generated audio of President Biden to sway the New Hampshire primary and a perhaps more impactful use of deepfakes to influence Slovakia's October election. Meanwhile, xAI is rolling out an astounding new model that enables remarkably realistic, unfiltered imagery.
Just as AI is creating institutional uncertainty, the tech is zooming ahead.
The challenge of trust and authenticity in an era of highly capable deepfakes should not be understated. The potential electoral strains are familiar by now, but few have fully grappled with how serious the strain could be on other facets of society.
During a trial, for instance, what’s to stop a criminal from introducing generated security camera footage to clear their name, or crying “AI!” when damning audio evidence is introduced? Baseline expectations of authenticity not only inform democratic institutions but are deeply woven into the basic rule of law.
Beyond the courtroom, synthetic media is actively being used to defraud. In 2023 alone, Deloitte estimated that generative AI enabled the pilfering of $12.3 billion, a figure that will no doubt increase as capability improves. Deepfakes are growing powerful and a tipping point of trust may be near.
The bad news is that shouting for a catch-all “solution” isn't the solution. There are no easy answers and no simple legal text can swat this growing problem. This tech is out there, in use, and scattered across hard drives and the internet. Instead of hoping for a clean regulatory fix, what we need now is triangulation.
The good news is that partial solutions exist. The first and most important step is developing and deploying a slate of reliable, easy-to-use forensics techniques to provide a technical basis for ground truth. Already we have a decent first step: watermarking technology. When used, this tech can embed content with signatures to verify authenticity. Use, however, is inconsistent.
To augment watermarks, we will also need to develop a suite of standardized, easy-to-employ and easy-to-verify content authenticity techniques, perhaps involving a mix of automated deepfake detectors, learned best practices and contextual evidence. Thankfully, research is already underway. However, things need to be both accelerated and sustained over time as the tech keeps pushing forward.
To get this done, policymakers should consider authorizing a series of AI forensics research investments and grand challenges, with the recognition that it requires a long-term commitment to ensure tools keep up with quick-moving technical evolution.
With tools in place, the second step is to that ensure institutions at all levels of society are equipped to wield them, and consistently.
While the bulk of the deepfake discussion has focused on threats to federal electoral politics, the depth of impact is most likely to be felt in local politics, institutions and courts which lack the institutional capacity and civil resources needed to vet and navigate authenticity questions. Simplicity, consistency and clarity are key.
Federal standards-setting bodies can help by commissioning approachable standards of practice intentionally designed to accommodate low-resource, low-knowledge local actors. States, meanwhile, should fund outreach to educate and promote the use and integration of these processes and standards.
The final, and perhaps the most actionable step right now, is more education. In the immediate term, there will be considerable confusion, fraud and deception due to what Professor Ethan Mollick of the Wharton School recently termed “change blindness.” The public’s understanding of generative AI’s evolution significantly lags behind the breakneck state of the art.
A quick scan of internet comment sections suggests many either cannot identify obviously generated media or assume that outdated rules-of-thumb — such as the presence of too many thumbs — remain meaningful. The bar for deception is low.
Here, simple PSAs could go a long way. Already the Senate is considering the Artificial Intelligence Public Awareness and Education Campaign Act, which would sponsor a campaign of such PSAs. While a one-shot campaign can help, policymakers must be prepared to make this continuous and mitigate change blindness as the technology improves.
All of these steps would help. Through a triangulation of efforts, policymakers and civil society can hopefully seed the ground with tools, institutions and understanding needed to encourage trust. The bulk of action must ultimately fall on the backs of civil institutions to create critical, socially driven norms to push society towards a comfortable new normal.
That said, to ensure trust is preserved on the path to that new normal, immediate effort and institutional action are needed today.
Matthew Mittelsteadt is a technologist and research fellow with the Mercatus Center at George Mason University.
Date: |
-
CBS News - Top stories
Israeli strike on UN school in Gaza kills more than a dozen people
With the war in Gaza approaching one year, Palestinian officials say an Israeli airstrike hit a United Nations school sheltering displaced families. CBS News senior foreign correspondent Elizabeth ...23 minutes ago - Israel -
NBC News - Politics
More than 337,000 people visit Taylor Swift's link to register to vote
Taylor Swift’s endorsement of Vice President Kamala Harris for president may boost voter registration beyond Democrats’ "wildest dreams."1 hour ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Parents' transplant plea: 'One more infection and we could lose our boy'
Two-year-old Zachary Bradford could die in weeks if a donor cannot be found.3 hours ago -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Oil Futures Rise As Storm Crosses Offshore Oil Patch
Oil futures rise as Hurricane Francine causes some U.S. offshore production to be shut in, with the rebound from yesterday’s heavy selling tempered by weekly builds in U.S. crude and product ...3 hours ago -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Europe's Resilience Might Be More Fragile Than It Looks
Markets may be too optimistic about Europe’s economic resilience, Raffaele Prencipe and Andre Figueira de Sousa, fixed income fund managers at Degroof Petercam Asset Management say in a note.8 hours ago -
ABC News - Top stories
Inflation falls more than expected, paving way for interest rate cut
The Fed is widely expected to cut interest rates next week.10 hours ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
More upsets, please! Why David toppling Goliath is needed in college football now more than ever
Stunners like Northern Illinois taking down Notre Dame carry a little more weight as college football enters a new era10 hours ago -
NBC News - Top stories
Inflation cools to 2.5%, slowest rate in more than three years
Inflation's steady march lower continued Wednesday, with the Bureau of Labor Statistics reporting that consumer price growth slowed to 2.5% in August, the lowest measure since 2021.12 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Thousands flee Vietnam floods after typhoon hits
One of the country's largest rivers reached its highest level in two decades on Wednesday.12 hours ago -
Yahoo News - World
Lufthansa Cargo invests more than $600M to overhaul Frankfurt hub
12 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
CNN's Acosta repeatedly cuts off GOP strategist: 'This ain't C-SPAN'
CNN anchor Jim Acosta got into a back-and-forth with GOP strategist and former Trump aide Bryan Lanza over the topic of former President Trump and a national abortion ban on Wednesday. “Trump ...33 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Court revives anti-Christian bias claims for school official fired after objecting to Matthew Shepard play
A U.S. Court of Appeals on Tuesday ruled that a former assistant principal may proceed with his religious discrimination lawsuit against his former school district, which he alleges fired him over ...54 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Gas prices slump, marking possible good news for Harris
Oil prices hit a three-year low this week, a milestone that comes after six weeks of consecutive gasoline price decline. The drop has little to do with the Biden administration’s direct ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Defense hawks oppose House GOP's six-month CR plan
House Speaker Mike Johnson's (R-La.) Plan B for a stopgap federal spending bill is a no-go if it still includes a six-month time frame, according to GOP defense hawks. “If it goes past December 31, ...2 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
GSA says 337K Taylor Swift referrals have come to vote.gov
More than 330,000 visitors have flocked to vote.gov by way of pop superstar Taylor Swift’s postdebate endorsement of Vice President Harris, according to the General Services Administration (GSA). ...2 hours ago