Court revives anti-Christian bias claims for school official fired after objecting to Matthew Shepard play
A U.S. Court of Appeals on Tuesday ruled that a former assistant principal may proceed with his religious discrimination lawsuit against his former school district, which he alleges fired him over “religious comments” he made objecting to a school play about the brutal murder of a young gay man.
A three-judge panel of the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a lower court’s dismissal of the lawsuit and said the plaintiff, Corey McNellis, had provided enough circumstantial evidence against the defendant, Douglas County School District (DCSD), “to give rise to an inference of discrimination.”
“[McNellis] alleged he was treated less favorably than other DCSD employees and claimed DCSD’s termination decision was ‘premised on [his] religious beliefs,’” U.S. Circuit Judge Veronica Rossman, a President Biden appointee, wrote for the court. “We agree.”
McNellis was fired in 2020, two years before he filed the lawsuit. His termination followed a DCSD investigation into “religious comments” he made in response to an email from the theater director announcing the school’s play would be “The Laramie Project” — a play centered on the 1998 death of college student Matthew Shepard, whose death is widely seen as one of the worst anti-gay hate crimes in recent history.
McNellis replied, asking what avenues of recourse he would have “as a Dad of a student here and also as an employee in the school” to express concern about the play selection. The email, sent to all staff, spurred a subsequent conversation in which McNellis sent three additional emails with “religious comments” that allegedly were the basis for his termination.
“As a [C]hristian I would love to collaborate with your project. Please let me know if the love that Jesus can provide will help your play,” he wrote in one email, adding in a second, “I understand people support this. Forgive me for having a different viewpoint and the audacity to publicly share it.”
“For the record, all of administration does not agree with me on this. I am totally solo. Good night Mustangs!” he said in a third email.
The court noted that DCSD cited “religious comments” when administrators informed McNellis that he needed to stay home the next day, and when he was placed on leave and informed three days later of an investigation into the religious comments.
When he was ultimately terminated less than a month later, “Defendant directly cited Mr. McNellis’s emails regarding The Laramie Project as the reason for his termination,” according to the court filing.
“Here, Mr. McNellis’s allegations that DCSD repeatedly invoked his ‘religious comments’ before investigating and terminating him provide a plausible link between his termination and a discriminatory motive. Under these circumstances, and at this procedural stage, that is sufficient to nudge [his] claims across the line from conceivable to plausible,” Rossman wrote in her decision.
The Hill has reached out to McNellis’s lawyer and the school district’s lawyer for a response.
While the three judges disagreed with the lower court’s dismissal of McNellis’s bias claims, they agreed McNellis could not prove his claims of retaliation and free-speech violations and upheld the lower court’s dismissal of the claims.
The decision was unanimous. The two other judges include Judge Robert Bacharach, a President Obama appointee, and Judge Harris Hartz, a President George W. Bush appointee.
Date: |
-
CBS News - Top stories
Springfield, Ohio, schools ramp up security after false claims, bomb threats
Gov. Mike DeWine announced Monday he's sending three dozen state troopers to be stationed around Springfield schools.17 hours ago -
Los Angeles Times - Entertainment
Objection! Kathy Bates won't retire after 'Matlock' reboot, she says
Bates said the retirement buzz was a 'misunderstanding' after she referred to 'Matlock' as her 'last dance' in an interview with the New York Times.18 hours ago -
ESPN - Sports
Ronaldo's Saudi club fires coach after slow start
Cristiano Ronaldo's Saudi Arabian club, Al Nassr, is looking for a new coach after firing Luis Castro on Tuesday in the second managerial change since the Portugal star's arrival.37 minutes ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Violent threats surge in Springfield, Ohio, after Trump, Vance false claims
The town of Springfield, Ohio, has been on edge ever since former President Donald Trump's baseless debate comments that Haitian immigrants there are eating pets. CBS News congressional ...17 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Yahoo News - World
Statue of French charity icon Abbe Pierre removed after abuse claims
23 minutes ago -
NBC News - Top stories
Falcons stun Eagles after Saquon Barkley drops potentially game-icing play
Atlanta’s Kirk Cousins squares off with Philadelphia’s Jalen Hurts22 hours ago - NFL -
ABC News - World
Dozens wounded after pagers detonate in Lebanon, officials point to Israel
Lebanese state media and security officials say dozens of people have been injured in Beirut’s suburbs after their handheld pagers exploded4 hours ago - Israel -
ABC News - Tech
Hezbollah hit by a wave of exploding pagers in Lebanon and Syria. At least 9 dead, hundreds injured
Hundreds of handheld pagers exploded near simultaneously in parts of Lebanon and Syria, killing at least nine people — including members of the militant group Hezbollah and a young girl15 minutes ago -
ABC News - Entertainment
Sean 'Diddy' Combs has been indicted on sex trafficking and racketeering charges
Sean “Diddy” Combs has been indicted on federal sex trafficking and racketeering charges1 hour ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Prosecutors seeking to keep Sean Combs in prison ahead of trial
Federal prosecutors are urging a Manhattan court to keep defendant Sean “Diddy” Combs in detention ahead of his trial, calling him a flight risk and a “significant risk” to obstruction of justice. ...13 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Harris speaks with NABJ reporters in Philadelphia
Vice President Harris, the democratic presidential nominee, is slated to answer questions Tuesday from National Association of Black Journalists (NABJ) members in Philadelphia. Tuesday's forum is ...36 minutes ago - Kamala Harris -
The Hill - Politics
Putin’s attempt to destroy Ukraine's nationhood backfired
Ukrainians are no longer a ragtag bunch of people thrown together by fate.36 minutes ago - Ukraine -
The Hill - Politics
Hezbollah leaders killed, thousands of people injured in pager explosions in Lebanon, Syria
Hundreds of handheld pagers exploded in Lebanon and parts of Syria on Tuesday, killing several people, including members of the militant group Hezbollah, and wounding thousands, officials said. ...42 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Billie Eilish endorses Harris: 'Vote like your life depends on it'
Billie Eilish is the latest high-profile entertainer to back Vice President Harris's White House bid, urging her fans to "vote like your life depends on it." "We are voting for Kamala Harris and ...52 minutes ago