Conquering in Chaos: How Trump is reinventing America’s foreign policy

President Trump is not only changing the rules. He's creating a whole different game.

His America First strategy is not just removing the signage from the USAID building but is detaching from the traditional U.S. foreign policy. And this is not necessarily a bad thing — in fact, it appears to offer a new pathway to success and recovery of lost American leadership around the world.

The new administration has made a blunt statement: Mexico has an intolerable alliance with drug cartels. This declaration, and the threat of new tariffs, generated immediate results. Mexico sent more than 10,000 soldiers to the border to fight drug trafficking and stop illegal migration. During the previous administration, Mexico only promoted a policy called “Hugs, not bullets.” Trump put an end to that madness.

Mexico, the main trade partner of the U.S., decided to extend its arms open wide to China in 2023. The result was $4.6 billion in car purchases subsidized by the communist regime — a figure lower than the $4.4 billion spent there on American cars.

Under Trump, those days are over. In less than 20 days, Trump has sent a clear message, and Mexico sees the writing on the wall. The America First Trade Policy has been declared a critical component in national security. Even though many criticized the tariffs threats, nobody can disagree with the results.

The U.S. has confiscated a plane from the Venezuelan dictatorship, secured the release of 6 American citizens and guaranteed that the communist regime receives the deportation of hundreds of dangerous criminals from the Tren de Aragua street gang. Venezuela is even paying for the flights. Those are outstanding results after less than a month in office.

Meanwhile, El Salvador has offered to receive and re-imprison criminals not only from El Salvador's notorious gangs, but also from Mexican cartels and convicts from other nationalities, including Americans. President Nayib Bukele has promised to be a key partner on security, migration and fight against drug trafficking.

The U.S. has also announced that it will support cooperation on civilian nuclear energy in El Salvador to ensure greater, cheaper and safer electricity generation.

Trump and his new secretary of state, Marco Rubio, also scored a quick and massive victory in Panama. In less than 24 hours, they put China in its place, expanded cooperation on migration with Panama, strengthened the trade agenda and advanced security collaboration. President Jose Raul Mulino pledged not to renew or extend his country's participation in communist China's Belt and Road Initiative. This is perhaps the most resounding victory of Rubio's visit there.

The next step is to increase pressure on companies controlled by the Chinese Communist Party. The Hong Kong-based company Hutchison Ports operates the port terminals at both ends of the canal and recently received a 25-year concession without bidding. These agreements will be audited, reviewed and perhaps reversed.

During his recent visit to Guatemala, Rubio noted that China is obsessed with establishing or dominating telecommunications through Huawei and other companies. Rubio stated that the U.S. government supports Guatemala’s firm decision to maintain diplomatic ties with Taiwan and will do anything possible to bring more investments to the Central American country.

“It's not easy in a world where there is a lot of pressure to change that recognition and to break those ties," Rubio said. "But you have always stood firm, and we look for opportunities for that only – not only to be a diplomatic relationship, but for it also to be an economic relationship with investments and opportunities.”

The Trump administration is convinced that China's influence in the Americas is its main commercial and security threat. Everything else is secondary. The path to success will be to promote the three R's: Restricting China's advance, Reinforcing alliances with regional partners and Regaining lost U.S. leadership.

Trump has managed to win important battles in the region, making clear what his priorities and concerns are. This is not necessary President Teddy Roosevelt's “Big Stick” policy, but perhaps it could be called a method of "Conquering in Chaos." This is a new form of disruptive and challenging foreign policy, but also a new opportunity for hemispheric well-being, security and prosperity.

Arturo McFields is an exiled journalist, former ambassador to the Organization of American States and former member of the Norwegian Peace Corps. He is a graduate of the National Defense University's Security and Defense Seminar and the HarvardX Leadership Course.

Topics

Is there a foreign policy ‘Trump Doctrine’?

While Trump might consider withdrawing land forces from overseas bases, American naval and air forces are likely to be a different matter.
The Hill - 5d
Trump’s foreign policy creates unprecedented global challenges

The withdrawal of American leadership from Europe, embodied by Trump’s approach to Ukraine, has ramifications that will reverberate around the world.
The Hill - 1d
1st lawsuits targeting foreign aid freeze bemoan 'chaos' in Trump order

Several nonprofit groups are accusing the Trump administration of failing to disperse congressionally approved funds by freezing all foreign aid for 90 days.
ABC News - Feb. 11
‘Cost and chaos’: Trump’s metal tariffs sweep across corporate America

Executives grapple with uncertainty and price volatility even before levies come into effect
Financial Times - Feb. 12
12:30 Report — Trump’s foreign policy whiplash week

{beacon} 12:30 REPORT Happy Valentine’s Day to all my 12:30 readers! 💘 I appreciate each and every one of you. In this edition: Vance scolds Europe in his big foreign policy address. Hegseth ...
The Hill - 5d
An Unchecked Trump Rapidly Remakes U.S. Government and Foreign Policy

The president’s swift moves underscore the confidence of an administration with a much firmer grip on the levers of government than during his first term.
The New York Times - 4d
Trump administration's mixed messaging on foreign policy leaves world guessing

Different narratives from senior US officials on the future of Ukraine have sown confusion in Europe - but was that perhaps the point?
BBC News - 3d
Trump's seismic foreign policy shift: From the Politics Desk

Within a week, Trump upended decades of U.S. foreign policy with Russia and Europe. And he raised grave questions in the minds of every American ally.
NBC News - 7h
How America's chief consumer-protection agency came into the Trump administration's crosshairs

When the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau made an appearance in the Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025 blueprint, the conservative group’s plan was simple: Abolish it entirely.
NBC News - Feb. 12

More from The Hill

Rep. Don Bacon says Trump 'wrong' to call Zelensky a dictator

Rep. Don Bacon (R-Neb.) said President Trump was “wrong” to call Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky a dictator on Wednesday and for appearing to be “standing on the side” of Russian President ...
The Hill - 2h
Trump says federal government should 'take over' DC

President Trump on Wednesday said the federal government should "take over the governance" of Washington, D.C. "I think that we should govern the District of Columbia," Trump told reporters aboard ...
The Hill - 3h
Trump signs order targeting any federal benefits going to those in the country illegally

President Trump on Wednesday signed an executive order intended to identify and eliminate any federal financial benefits going to immigrants who entered the country illegally, something already ...
The Hill - 4h
Appeals court won’t immediately revive Trump’s birthright citizenship order

A federal appeals court Wednesday evening declined the Trump administration’s request to partially revive the president’s executive order restricting birthright citizenship. The Justice Department ...
The Hill - 4h
Senate GOP dismayed by Trump, Zelensky war of words

{beacon} Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story Senate GOP dismayed by Trump, Zelensky war of words Public ...
The Hill - 4h