Confederate statues' removal does not erase history
![Confederate statues' removal does not erase history](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/Monument_Avenue-1241027463.jpg?w=900)
The argument made by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., in a recent interview, that Confederate statue removals are erasing history — is based on a false notion that removing the public honoring of historical figures removes those figures from the historical record or public discussion.
Public honorings like statues and named public facilities are intended to do just that — honor the subject person for their positive service or contribution to society. To earn that honor, you should have positively contributed to society through acts of service for the greater good, or a specific good to the place bearing your name or likeness.
The removal of a statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee from the public square doesn’t mean Lee is being canceled from the history books. The removal simply undoes something that should never have never happened in the first place — the honoring a man who betrayed his country and attacked his own people.
To use an extreme example, Adolf Hitler will never be erased from history. Yet we would not condone a statue of him in any public square, even in his hometown.
If we must make statues, what would be just is a statue to the fallen soldiers of the Confederacy (who were sold a false narrative about what the war was about) alongside a statue of the many enslaved men and women and their abolitionist allies who resisted the slave state.
Some have argued that this is dishonoring southern heritage. I was born in West Virginia and grew up in Virginia, and as a white Virginian I never identified with the goals of the Confederacy, which were to maintain an undemocratic feudal state founded on white supremacy. The Confederacy was antithetical to our founding principles and to the U.S. Constitution.
The historical record shows that white southern leaders knew it then as much as we know it now — this is not a controversial revisionist take on the situation. There were plenty of people in the South who did not agree with the system and sought to abolish it, most notably the Black residents, enslaved and free, who continually resisted and rebelled in the face of white terror.
Slavery was an economic tool of the white ruling class, of which most white southerners were not a part. Enslavement was certainly not the chosen heritage of the multitudes of enslaved people in the South and across the U.S. territories. The Confederacy was a movement of racist authoritarian rule and wage theft, not a heritage.
In the mid-1980s, the first time I drove down Monument Avenue in Richmond, then home to several statues of high-ranking members of the Confederacy, I thought it was a dystopian construct. Here was a broad, beautiful avenue in the midst of an American city with a large Black population, lined with statues of men who fought for the right to subjugate Black Americans — a city that the defeated Confederate leaders burned to the ground at war’s end as they abandoned it to the advancing Union army.
It is right and just that the names and likenesses of these men have been confined to their rightful place in our history books and museums, as cautionary tales of betrayal. Let those statues fill halls of shame, with the names of the “Lost Cause” propagandists and Jim Crow architects alongside, and let the melting of Lee’s infamous statue be a ritual cleansing from 160 years of false history.
Don Willson is a carpenter and industrial arts teacher living in the Pacific Northwest.
Date: |
Filter
-
MarketWatch - Business
Trump Media’s stock erases early gains as markets react to Biden’s uneven debate performance
Trump Media & Technology Group Corp.’s stock reversed its premarket gains to trade down 1.9% Friday, as investors continued to digest the first presidential debate between incumbent President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump..Donald Trump -
The New York Times - Sports
The Dirtiest Game in the History of the Euros
Sixteen yellow cards and two players sent off: This is how one soccer game descended into chaos. -
Financial Times - World
Simon Schama’s history of British elections
As voters prepare to head to the polls, the historian reflects on campaigns through the centuries and their depiction in great art -
CBS News - Top stories
Students making history
At a time when educators may face restrictions on what they can teach, a contest sponsored by the non-profit organization National History Day offers students in grades 6-12 the opportunity to explore significant topics of history. Correspondent ... -
Financial Times - World
Turkey removed from money laundering ‘grey list’
FATF decision set to give international investors more confidence about country’s assetsTurkey -
The Hill - Politics
Pentagon removing Gaza pier, no clear date on reinstallation
The U.S. military is once again removing the Gaza pier due to poor weather, and there is no clear timeline on when it would be reanchored, the Pentagon confirmed Friday. Pentagon deputy press secretary Sabrina Singh said heavy seas and high winds ... -
The Hill - Politics
Pentagon once again removing Gaza pier
Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story Pentagon removes Gaza pier again, no clear date on reinstallation The U.S. military is once again removing the Gaza ... -
Financial Times - World
On the banks of the Thames, 2,000 years of history
A treasure-hunting trail with Lara Maiklem, aka ‘The London Mudlark’ -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Supreme Court Expands Cities' Power to Remove Homeless Camps
Justices rejected a claim that penalizing people with nowhere else to sleep is unconstitutionally cruel.
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Carville says Biden should be replaced
Longtime Democratic strategist James Carville said Monday that President Biden should be replaced at the top of the 2024 ticket following his poor debate performance against former President Trump. CNN host Jake Tapper asked Carville what the ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
70 percent of voters have decided who they will back in November: Poll
More than 7 in 10 voters have already decided whom they will vote for in the November presidential election, according to a new poll. The Harvard CAPS/Harris poll released Monday showed 72 percent of respondents said they have already made up ... -
The Hill - Politics
Republicans tout Supreme Court immunity ruling as victory in 'weaponization' fight
Republicans are hailing the Supreme Court’s ruling that presidents have immunity from prosecution for official acts as a major victory over government “weaponization” as the decision deals a blow to special counsel Jack Smith’s prosecution of ...Republican Party -
The Hill - Politics
Hillary Clinton sides with Sotomayor over 'MAGA wing of the Supreme Court'
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said Monday the “MAGA wing of the Supreme Court" issued the majority decision granting presidential immunity for official acts in office, as she backed Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s scathing dissent in the ... -
The Hill - Politics
Luna proposes fining Garland $10K per day instead of taking him into custody
Rep. Anna Paulina Luna (R-Fla.) is proposing a less dramatic way to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in “inherent contempt” of Congress over his refusal to turn over the audio from President Biden’s interview with special counsel Robert Hur ...