Colorado River negotiators express urgency, uncertainty as deadline nears

Lead negotiators from the Colorado River's Upper Basin states expressed a dual sense of uncertainty and urgency on Tuesday, as a deadline to determine the fate of the entire system looms near.

"If you are in the Upper Basin states or probably anywhere across the West, you know it's not looking so good right now," said Becky Mitchell, director of the Colorado Water Conservation Board.

Mitchell was addressing a meeting of the Upper Colorado River Commission, which also included federal Bureau of Reclamation representatives and the lead negotiators for the other Upper Basin states: Wyoming, Utah and New Mexico.

The commissioners convened to discuss basin-wide hydrology and share updates on longer-term Colorado River negotiations, which have been occurring for more than a year with Lower Basin counterparts: Arizona, Nevada and California.

The talks concern a long-anticipated update of the Colorado River’s operational guidelines, which are set to expire at the end of 2026. These 2007 interim rules govern conservation policies for the 1,450-mile river, which provides water to about 40 million people in the U.S. and Mexico.

With the Upper and Lower basins still far from reaching any collaborative arrangement, the Biden administration in late November tried to propel the process forward — releasing a bullet-point list of five potential alternatives for the watershed’s long-term management.

Just days before President Trump's inauguration, former President Biden's team released a detailed version of the alternatives, placing the Bureau of Reclamation on a path to issue a draft environmental impact statement — a key step in the federal environmental process — by this summer.

Chuck Cullom, executive director of the Upper Colorado River Commission, confirmed at the Tuesday meeting that this initial framework would need to be in place "by early summer of 2025" in order to trigger the development of state-level implementation plans.

"Those are the types of agreements between states, and the basin states as a whole, that would be part of the foundation for whatever those post-2026 operations might be," Cullom said, noting that some of those plans might require the passage of legislation.

The Bureau of Reclamation had initially given the states an early March 2024 deadline to submit a consensus-backed alternative for updated guidelines for the river’s management. But two days after that deadline, the basins ended up publishing competing proposals.

The Lower Basin states presented a proposal that incorporated reductions for themselves but also called for cuts across the entire watershed — calculating storage capacity not just on the massive Lake Powell and Lake Mead, but also on five smaller reservoirs, including three in the Upper Basin.

The Upper Basin states, meanwhile, issued plans that they said would consider real-time hydrological conditions in an area dependent on mountain snowpack for its water supply.

Having received no unified vision among all seven states, Biden's Bureau of Reclamation proposed a range of management solutions, none of which precisely match either basin’s proposal.

Most of the federal alternatives presented, however, require some level of consensus agreement, Cullom noted at the Tuesday meeting.

"A consensus is the best option out there for everyone, and I'm hopeful that we'll get there," Mitchell said. "That is the highest level of certainty that we will have as seven basin states."

Mitchell stressed the importance of the states determining their own future, adding that all parties must "acknowledge that cuts are probable, possible and likely."

"We need to do that for certainty, and everyone needs to do that," she said. "We are committed to work with the Lower Basin states toward that seven-state consensus."

Her Upper Basin colleagues offered similar perspectives, with Estevan Lopez of New Mexico and Brandon Gebhart of Wyoming both expressing their commitment to such collaboration.

"We are meeting with all of the states," added Gene Shawcroft, Utah's commissioner. "Discussions have been frank and fruitful."

Shawcroft expressed optimism "that there is a box that we can work within that will allow us to come to a seven-state consensus,

"But certainly, there's a lot of work yet to do," he added.

As for the Colorado River's hydrological conditions, Alex Pivarnik of the Bureau of Reclamation told the commissioners that Lake Powell — the main reservoir for the Upper Basin — is only 35 percent full, while Upper Colorado River system storage is sitting at 43 percent capacity and total system storage in both basins is at 42 percent.

"January was a really bad month for us in the basin," Pivarnik said, noting that conditions were "pretty much dry" across all the states.

Pivarnik described the initial weeks of February as "kind of a make or break for us," recognizing that precipitation has since increased substantially.

Mitchell echoed these sentiments, acknowledging that water officials have "been slightly optimistic because of the snow."

"But it still does not look as good as we'd like," she said.

Topics

Stream Near Buenos Aires Turns Red, ‘Like a River Covered in Blood’

A stream south of the Argentine capital turned a freakish vermilion this week, prompting concerns about pollution. Officials said it could be the result of “some type of organic dye.”
The New York Times - Feb. 7
Tensions Mount in Lebanon as Deadline Nears for Israeli Withdrawal

The United States has reportedly told Lebanese officials that Israel’s military intends to remain in five strategic points inside Lebanon, but will withdraw from towns it still occupies.
The New York Times - 5d
River near Buenos Aires turns bright red after suspected industrial dye leak

Residents living near the Sarandí have long complained about pollution in the area. A small river in greater Buenos Aires was dyed a deep and worrying shade of red on Thursday after what is thought ...
The Guardian - Feb. 7
‘Backsliding’: most countries to miss vital climate deadline as Cop30 nears

Developing countries urge biggest polluters to act as Trump’s return to the White House heightens geopolitical turmoil. The vast majority of governments are likely to miss a looming deadline to ...
The Guardian - Feb. 8
Kevin Durant trade? What summer landscape looks like for Suns after near deals at deadline

The Durant trade market changes drastically over the summer
CBS Sports - Feb. 10
Managing uncertainty in the Trump age

Multinationals need to dust off the pandemic playbook to cope with disruption
Financial Times - Feb. 7
The Restaurant That Started Panda Express

The parent restaurant of Panda Express underwent a multimillion-dollar renovation. The deep, comforting pleasures are still on the menu.
The New York Times - 5d
Tariff Uncertainty Taxes the Auto Industry

For some in the car industry, the uncertainty surrounding a US-border trade war is almost worse than the tariffs themselves. If the tariffs go through, the costs might get passed down to buyers.
Wired - Feb. 6
Fed Chair Jerome Powell Shows Little Urgency to Lower Rates

Jerome H. Powell testifies as inflation risks are resurfacing, regulatory changes are in flux and the Federal Reserve’s policy independence is in the spotlight.
The New York Times - Feb. 12
Bodies found in river in Aberdeen confirmed as missing sisters

Eliza and Henrietta Huszti - both 32 and originally from Hungary - disappeared in Aberdeen on 7 January.
BBC News - Feb. 11
Atmospheric river threatens parts of California scorched by wildfires

An atmospheric river could bring mudslides to parts of California ravaged by massive wildfires. CBS News' Carter Evans is monitoring the weather, and meteorologist Jessica Burch has the latest ...
CBS News - Feb. 13
Mudslides and floods in California from atmospheric river

There are flooding concerns near San Francisco and mudslides are being reported in Santa Cruz, California. CBS News Los Angeles' Rick Montanez reports, and meteorologist Jessica Burch has more on ...
CBS News - Feb. 13
Norway to open protected rivers to hydropower plants

Green politicians describe plan as ‘a historic attack on Norwegian nature’. The Norwegian parliament has voted to open up protected rivers to hydropower plants, prompting fury from conservation ...
The Guardian - Feb. 13
Atmospheric river brings mudslides, flooding to Southern California

Areas already devastated by January's California wildfires are now dealing with an atmospheric river, dropping rain and snow. CBS News correspondent Carter Evans has the latest.
CBS News - 5d
Body found in search for missing Colorado college student

A search is underway for missing University of Colorado Boulder student Megan Trussell who was last seen on Feb. 9.
ABC News - 4d
European companies warn over Trump tariff uncertainty

Executives left guessing at scale and impact of any US levies on EU imports
Financial Times - Feb. 9
Starmer expresses support for Zelenskyy after Trump criticism

UK prime minister pushes back against Trump’s suggestion that elections should be held in Ukraine
Financial Times - 22h
North Carlolina coach Hubert Davis 'just sad' about team's lack of urgency after blowout loss to Clemson

With their NCAA Tournament hopes teetering, the Tar Heels failed to answer the bell on Monday
CBS Sports - Feb. 11
Deion Sanders adds Marshall Faulk to Colorado staff as RB coach

A third NFL Hall of Famers has joined the Colorado coaching staff.
Yahoo Sports - Feb. 7
Colorado's Polis backs Trump's halt on penny production: 'Great move'

Colorado Gov. Jared Polis (D) on Monday backed President Trump’s direction to halt penny production, calling it a “great move.” On Sunday, Trump announced that he had requested that the Treasury ...
The Hill - Feb. 10
EV Sales Climb in Spite of Automaker Losses and Trump-Related Uncertainty

Ford’s EV unit lost billions of dollars, but at the same time, EV sales as a whole were up in the U.S. in 2024 compared to the year before.
Inc. - Feb. 6
Kosovo faces political uncertainty as ruling party fails to secure election majority

PM Albin Kurti claims ‘victory’ and vows to form government but analysts warn of prolonged crisis and instability. The governing party of the prime minister, Albin Kurti, is on track to secure the ...
The Guardian - Feb. 10
Advice for student loan borrowers amid uncertainty surrounding U.S. Department of Education

President Trump is seeking to dismantle the Department of Education with the help of billionaire Elon Musk, potentially causing major disruptions for Americans paying student loans. CBS News ...
CBS News - Feb. 11
Uncertainty about gender affirming care for transgender children and teenagers

After a flurry of executive orders signed by President Trump since he took office, there are now many questions about the medical care transgender children and teenagers will receive…with hospitals ...
NBC News - Feb. 11
Trump signals uncertainty on Ukraine talks at Modi news conference

At a news conference with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, President Trump offered a vague response about Russia's role in the Ukraine war, suggesting negotiations haven’t truly begun and ...
NBC News - 6d
‘Who is Trump to decide our fate?’: takeover threat adds to uncertainty in Gaza

Palestinians say the US president will never succeed in his plan to force them from their homes to build a ‘Riviera’. Middle East crisis – live updates One month after the announcement of a ...
The Guardian - 6d
Latest Israeli hostages to be freed named amid uncertainty over truce

Iair Horn, Sasha Troufanov and Sagui Dekel-Chen due to be exchanged for 369 Palestinian prisoners. Palestinian militant groups have named the three hostages they plan to free on Saturday in return ...
The Guardian - 6d
Wisconsin dairy farms face uncertainty amid immigration crackdown

According to the Department of Agriculture, more than 40% of the country's farm workers are undocumented immigrants. Camilo Montoya-Galvez traveled to a dairy farm in Wisconsin to report on the ...
CBS News - 18h
Hegseth says of Ukraine negotiations "everything is on the table"

A day after telegraphing potential concessions to Russia, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth reconsidered his comment that it's unrealistic for Ukraine to join NATO.
CBS News - Feb. 13
Hegseth says 'everything is on the table' for Ukraine negotiations

Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story Hegseth: 'Everything is on the table' for Ukraine talks Defense ...
The Hill - 6d
Rubio: Ukraine and Europe must be part of 'real' negotiations

Yahoo News - 4d
Trump sidelines allies in Ukraine-Russia negotiations

Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story Trump sidelines allies in opening Ukraine-Russia gambit European ...
The Hill - 2d
Trump says Russia holds 'the cards' in peace negotiations

The US leader tells the BBC he trusts that Moscow wants to see an end to the war in Ukraine.
BBC News - 15h
Carl Edwards, Ricky Rudd express gratitude with induction to NASCAR Hall of Fame

Famed car builder Ralph Moody joins Carl Edwards and Ricky Rudd in Class of 2025.
Yahoo Sports - Feb. 8
Israelis express outrage over conditions of hostages released in latest swap with Hamas

Many Israelis say they're outraged over the conditions of the three hostages released by Hamas over the weekend after more than 16 months in captivity. CBS News' Chris Livesay has the latest.
CBS News - Feb. 10
Ex-Treasury secretaries express worries over DOGE payment systems

Former Treasury Secretaries penned an op-ed Monday expressing their concerns that officials at Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) gained access to the federal payment systems. ...
The Hill - Feb. 10
Trump expresses confidence Democrats will help extend tax cuts

President Trump expressed confidence that Democrats will help Republicans extend his 2017-era tax cuts, despite the minority party showing no interest in helping with the president’s agenda. The ...
The Hill - Feb. 11
Trump expresses hope for renewed Russia relations after prisoner release

President makes remarks following release of Pennsylvania teacher Marc Fogel, held in Russia since 2021. A US teacher who has been held in Russia since 2021 has been released after a deal which ...
The Guardian - Feb. 11
Daughters of Target cofounder express alarm at company's DEI rollback

The daughters of one of the cofounders of Target are expressing their alarm and shock at the discounter's recent moves to roll back its diversity, equity and inclusion program.
CBS News - 5d