California court slams state water regulators for overstepping authority in key agricultural hub
A California Superior Court has cracked down on state regulators for penalizing a key agricultural region's water managers, chastising officials for potentially unlawful behavior.
Judge Kathy Ciuffini, of Central California's Kings County Superior Court, last week issued a preliminary injunction that prevents the State Water Resources Control Board from requiring fees and reports from growers who over-pump the area's groundwater.
In the injunction, Ciuffini affirmed allegations that the State Water Board had issued "underground regulations," which could cause undue harm to the livelihoods of the region's growers.
Officials put this southern portion of the San Joaquin Valley under "probation" in April, saying they had identified multiple deficiencies in the Tulare Lake basin's groundwater sustainability plans.
Water extraction had caused so much damage to certain areas that the Tulare Lake basin sunk as much as six feet from June 2015 to April 2023, according to a State Water Board staff report.
Probation would have meant that farmers who pumped 500 acre-feet or more of water each year would have had to meter and register their wells at a cost of $300 each, report their pumping activities and pay $20 for each acre-foot extracted, according to the SJV Water news site.
The State Water Board defines probation as a “first phase of intervention,” in which groundwater pumpers must cover the costs associated with assessment, planning and enforcement of that intervention.
In the weeks following the State Water Board's announcement, the petitioning parties, led by the Kings County Farm Bureau, filed a complaint to the court requesting a judgment voiding the probationary resolution.
The petition accused the State Water Board of undertaking "a series of processes which were outside its authority" and imposing protocols that would be "expensive, duplicative and punitive."
In the injunction, Ciuffini agreed with the plaintiffs' assertion that the State Water Board was "exceeding its authority," adding that "the Court believes plaintiffs will prevail" on this issue in court.
"The harms to the Plaintiffs have been and will be substantial if a preliminary injunction is not issued," Ciuffini wrote.
The judge stressed the court's recognition of the State Water Board's responsibility "to consider adverse impacts groundwater extraction would have on public trust resources," while acknowledging the need "to protect such resources where feasible."
Nonetheless, she said that the court did not identify sufficient merits in a state argument that an injunction would cause harm to domestic water quality.
Responding to the injunction, State Water Board spokesperson Edward Ortiz expressed the agency's disagreement with the ruling, noting in an emailed statement that it blocks regulators from taking probationary action in "the critically overdrafted Tulare Lake Subbasin."
"All Californians benefit when groundwater is managed sustainably," Ortiz stated. "Groundwater makes up a significant portion of the state’s water supply and serves as a critical buffer against the impacts of drought and climate change."
Under the state's Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA), passed 10 years ago, Ortiz said that "local agencies are responsible for the sustainable management of their groundwater basins." But state agencies, he explained, must ensure that local managers achieve the law's goals.
"The State Water Board believes that SGMA is clear and that the Board has the authority it needs to implement SGMA, as it has in the Tulare Lake Subbasin, to protect vital groundwater supplies," Ortiz said.
"We are considering further legal options to uphold the Board’s oversight of critically overdrafted basins," he added.
Meanwhile on Tuesday, the State Water Board placed another part of the same region, called the Tule Groundwater Subbasin, under probationary status, noting that overdraft there is likewise threatening drinking water quality and groundwater levels.
“The ultimate goal of SGMA, and the probationary process, is for groundwater subbasins to be managed sustainably at the local level," Joaquin Esquivel, chair of the State Water Board, said in a statement. "We are committed to helping groundwater agencies make that happen by providing guidance and support.”
Date: | |
Tag: | California |
Topics
-
The New York Times - Tech
California Gov. Newsom Signs Laws Regulating Election A.I. ‘Deepfakes’
The state joins dozens of others in regulating the A.I. fakery in ways that could impact this year’s presidential race.Yesterday - California -
BBC News - Top stories
Indian state accepts key demands of protesting doctors in rape case
The West Bengal government has agreed to remove a top police officer and two senior health officials.2 days ago -
The Hill - Politics
Local Teamsters unions in key battleground states endorse Harris
Local unions within the International Brotherhood of Teamsters are putting their support behind Vice President Harris in November, despite the wider union's decision to withhold a presidential ...2 hours ago -
GameSpot - Tech
Minecraft Guides Hub
Minecraft is one of the deeper and more complex video games you can play, despite its overall simplicity when it comes to initial gameplay. The more you play, the more you learn and discover about ...11 hours ago -
NBC News - Politics
Where third-party candidates have gotten on — or off — the ballot in key swing states
Third-party candidates have played a big role in deciding key presidential battleground states in the last few years. Here's who is on the ballot in which states.2 days ago -
NBC News - Top stories
Black swing-state voters back Harris — with key divides on age and gender, Howard poll shows
An overwhelming majority of Black likely voters in battleground states said they’ll vote for Kamala Harris — though she needs to close the deal with some skeptical undecideds to reach Joe Biden’s ...6 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Vance slams Harris on immigration at Wisconsin rally
Republican vice presidential candidate Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) sharply criticized Vice President Harris over immigration and public safety in a Wisconsin rally Tuesday afternoon. Speaking to a crowd ...Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Trump slams Howard Stern: 'He went woke'
Former President Trump is blasting Howard Stern, saying the SiriusXM host has "changed" and is now "woke." "I was on Howard Stern's show as much as anybody," Trump said during a Wednesday night ...14 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Former Georgia lieutenant governor says Trump is 'not God': 'He's a loser'
Georgia’s former Lt. Gov Geoff Duncan (R) slammed Trump for sinking the latest government funding bill after delivering an ultimatum calling for the plan to include a proof of citizenship voting ...14 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
New rules for disadvantaged businesses should maintain integrity
The SBA is currently rethinking the small disadvantaged business program after federal court rulings and has placed a “pause” on new 8(a) applications and new rules and regulations will be coming ...16 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
GOP lawmaker: 'It doesn't feel safe right now to be in politics'
Florida Rep. Anna Paulina Luna (R) on Wednesday said in an interview on NewsNation's CUOMO that she is more concerned with her safety as a member of Congress than when she served in the military ...22 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Senate panel votes to hold Steward Health CEO in contempt of Congress
A Senate panel investigating the bankruptcy of hospital chain Steward Health Care voted on Thursday to hold the company's CEO in contempt of Congress for defying a subpoena and refusing to appear ...33 minutes ago