As US isolationism deepens, Europe needs to step up
As the U.S. withdraws into isolationism, European nations are racing to fill the vacuum, but they face great challenges.
Following his appalling treatment in the Oval Office, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky received a hero’s welcome in Britain, including a private meeting with King Charles at his Sandringham estate.
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer is taking the lead in organizing a “coalition of the willing” to provide Ukraine with the security guarantees it desperately needs before it can engage in meaningful negotiations with Russia.
Starmer is providing Ukraine weapons, loans and the promise of British peacekeeping troops once a deal is reached. He said that while the NATO allies need U.S. support, Europe must do the “heavy lifting.”
French President Emmanuel Macron went further. “I want to believe that the U.S. will stand by our side,” he told the French people, “But we have to be ready for that not to be the case."
In addition to promising Ukraine aid, Macron has raised the possibility of extending France’s nuclear weapons umbrella over the rest of Europe to deter Putin from further aggression.
France’s 290 nuclear weapons don’t come close to matching Russia’s 6,375, but they don’t need to for an effective deterrent. If just 10 percent of these weapons reach their targets, they might destroy 29 cities — far more than any nation on the planet could afford to lose.
Germany is seriously considering reinstating conscription.
Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk told his parliament “We will try to have a model ready by the end of this year so that every adult male in Poland is trained in the event of war so that this reserve is comparable and adequate to the potential threats."
Other European countries are increasing their defense spending.
At the emergency summit in Brussels, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen declared that to ensure its security, the European Union is determined “to invest more, to invest better and to invest faster together.” She backed that pledge with a plan to increase defense spending by $843 billion and offered €150 billion in loans to help meet that goal.
Leaders of the 27 nations also agreed to loosen budget restrictions, allowing member states to spend more on defense.
These developments suggest that Europe may finally be stepping up to develop the common defense policy that has been the subject of so much discussion but little action in past decades.
Encouraging though the signs are, turning the continent’s extensive resources into military assets will take time, which Ukraine may not have.
With a population of 448 million (larger than the U.S. and more than double that of Russia), a GDP of $18.4 trillion, and the largest share of trade in manufactured goods and services (14 percent), the EU could produce a military to match that of the U.S. and exceed that of Russia.
Even before the proposed build-up, member states already have considerable combined power.
While no individual nation comes close to matching the 1.5 million military personnel in Putin’s war machine, collectively EU armed forces far exceed it with a combined strength of approximately 1.9 million in 2020.
Although European nations, as well as Ukraine, have grown dependent on U.S. armaments, the EU has the resources, infrastructure and technological capacity for a “defense industry renaissance,” provided there is the political will to implement it.
Europe has recently surpassed the U.S. in the proportion of weapons provided to Ukraine, although the U.S. still provides the most advanced air defense and offensive systems.
Creating a European defense force, however, requires more than adding up the capabilities of EU member states and increasing weapons production.
Common doctrine, interoperability (standardized ammunition, communications, etc.) and an overall command system are necessary to meld the various militaries into a unified force.
Fortunately, NATO membership has provided some of these requirements, including a military command committee capable of strategic planning.
Estimates on how long it would take for Europe to build up its militaries to match Russia’s range from 2-5 years.
Beyond developing its forces, the real challenge for Europeans will be maintaining the political will to act in concert. While EU states would certainly stand together to resist a full-scale Russian attack, how might they respond to lower-level threats? For example, what would they do if Putin used the large Russian minorities in Latvia and Estonia to launch an insurgency against their governments and intervene to support it?
Ukraine will be a test of solidarity.
Military experts estimate that Starmer’s “coalition of the willing” could deploy 30,000 of the up to 200,000 international peacekeepers Zelensky says would be necessary to deter a renewed Russian offensive following a ceasefire.
Europe will not be able to build up its forces in time to save Ukraine, although it might provide enough money and hardware to delay defeat.
Without U.S. military aid and intelligence, experts believe the Ukrainian military could start to crack within four months.
Even if Kyiv and Moscow hammer out a deal and especially if Ukraine falls, the EU would be wise to forge ahead with its aggressive defense buildup and complete it as soon as possible.
The threat from Russia will not go away.
Putin has made clear his intent to rebuild as much of the Soviet empire as possible and to reassert Russian power on the world stage.
EU states boarding Russia and Belarus (a Moscow satellite) are particularly vulnerable and will need the same security guarantees Ukraine demands.
The current U.S. administration’s pull-back from NATO may be temporary, but it serves as a grim warning that Europe can no longer count on unconditional American support.
A robust defensive capability would not only enable the EU to defend itself against Russia. It would also enable Brussels to stand up to Washington.
American dominance of NATO does not benefit either Europe or the U.S. It leaves our allies vulnerable and allows our government to bully rather than lead.
Tom Mockaitis is a professor of history at DePaul University and the author of “Conventional and Unconventional War: A History of Modern Conflict.”
-
Zelenskyy flying to Riyadh to meet crown prince as Russia steps up attacks
Ukrainian president to meet Mohammed bin Salman but will not be at Saudi-led talks with US officials later this week. Europe live – latest updates Volodymyr Zelenskyy is flying to Saudi Arabia ...The Guardian - 4d -
Taiwan's leader says tougher measures needed to counter stepped-up Chinese infiltration and spying
Taiwanese President William Lai Ching-te says tougher measures are needed to counter stepped-up Chinese infiltration, spying and other efforts to weaken the island’s defensesABC News - 1d -
'We need more Brunos' - Fernandes 'steps up all the time' for Man Utd
Manchester United head coach Ruben Amorim says the club need 'more' players like Bruno Fernandes.BBC News - 5d -
Ireland defence must 'hugely step up' - Ryan
Ireland second row James Ryan says Ireland's defence will need to be much better in Saturday's concluding Six Nations match against Italy.Yahoo Sports - 13h -
Trump says Nato ‘stepping up’ and hopes Russia will do ‘right thing’ after Putin’s ceasefire comments – live
US president meeting Nato secretary-general after Russian president says he is in favour of ceasefire but flags ‘serious issues’ with proposal. Russia wary of proposed ceasefire plan Suspilne, ...The Guardian - 1d -
Corporate Gloom Deepens as New Trump Tariffs Take Effect
Businesses need stability and clarity and instead they are getting calamity from Washington.Inc. - 2d -
‘I feel utter anger’: From Canada to Europe, a movement to boycott US goods is spreading
Tesla sales are falling and apps and online groups are springing up to help consumers choose non-US items . The renowned German classical violinist Christian Tetzlaff was blunt in explaining why he ...The Guardian - 2d -
My boyfriend wants us to move in together – but I need my independence and his dog won’t let us have sex
I used to struggle with living alone, but now I’m thriving. Should I give it all up?. My boyfriend and I are in our late 50s. He never married and doesn’t have kids, while I am divorced with ...The Guardian - 3d -
Russian strikes kill at least 25, Ukraine says
Russia has stepped up attacks in recent days as the US paused military and intelligence aid to Kyiv.BBC News - 6d
More from The Hill
-
‘Not quite yet beautiful’: Republicans at odds over spending cuts after meeting Trump
Senate Republicans aren’t seeing eye to eye with their colleagues in the House over places to cut spending in order to pay for their extension of the 2017 Trump tax cuts. GOP members of the Senate ...The Hill - 11m -
Trump takes victory lap during Justice Department speech
President Trump on Friday visited the Justice Department for a remarkable victory lap eight weeks into his triumphant return to the White House. Trump has long blamed the department under his ...The Hill - 13m -
Live updates: Government funding bill passes procedural vote in Senate
The Senate inched closer to funding the government before the deadline Friday. Needing 60 votes to keep the lights on and prevent a shutdown beginning Saturday morning, the House-passed continuing ...The Hill - 13m -
10 Democrats help Republicans advance GOP funding bill to avoid shutdown
A group of 10 Democrats, including Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), on Friday voted to advance a Republican-crafted bill to fund the government through Sept. 30, taking a crucial step ...The Hill - 16m -
Newsom tells Senate Dems to 'do the right thing,' oppose CR
California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) has called on Senate Democrats "to stand up and do the right thing" and vote no on the GOP-backed stop-gap bill that would avert a looming government shutdown. ...The Hill - 18m
More in Politics
-
‘Not quite yet beautiful’: Republicans at odds over spending cuts after meeting Trump
Senate Republicans aren’t seeing eye to eye with their colleagues in the House over places to cut spending in order to pay for their extension of the 2017 Trump tax cuts. GOP members of the Senate ...The Hill - 11m -
Trump takes victory lap during Justice Department speech
President Trump on Friday visited the Justice Department for a remarkable victory lap eight weeks into his triumphant return to the White House. Trump has long blamed the department under his ...The Hill - 13m -
Live updates: Government funding bill passes procedural vote in Senate
The Senate inched closer to funding the government before the deadline Friday. Needing 60 votes to keep the lights on and prevent a shutdown beginning Saturday morning, the House-passed continuing ...The Hill - 13m -
10 Democrats help Republicans advance GOP funding bill to avoid shutdown
A group of 10 Democrats, including Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), on Friday voted to advance a Republican-crafted bill to fund the government through Sept. 30, taking a crucial step ...The Hill - 16m -
Newsom tells Senate Dems to 'do the right thing,' oppose CR
California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) has called on Senate Democrats "to stand up and do the right thing" and vote no on the GOP-backed stop-gap bill that would avert a looming government shutdown. ...The Hill - 18m