America inching toward World War III? Nonsense.
More Republicans are warning that the election of Kamala Harris as president could lead to World War III. Republicans further assert that a Trump presidency would eliminate that threat.
Their so-called reasoning is that if Trump had won in 2020, the Gaza War would never have started and the Ukraine conflict would have been resolved.
People are entitled to their opinions, regardless of reality. But facts are different.
In the case of those who see the likelihood of global war as possible, their argument goes like this: China is flexing its economic might as it embarks on a major military buildup, and its president, Xi Jinping, has reportedly directed his military to “be prepared to invade Taiwan by 2027.”
Vladimir Putin threatens to use nuclear weapons against NATO if it allows Ukraine to use Western systems to attack deeply into Russia or intervenes in the fight in some form. The war in Gaza is expanding to Lebanon. Iran is increasing its malign terrorist and cyber activities.
All that is true, but a deeper inspection is needed.
The use of thermonuclear weapons in a world war cannot be discounted. Thermonuclear weapons are 1,000 times more powerful than nuclear weapons. Extinction of much of society would follow in America, Europe and Russia. As leaders of the U.S., Russia and China have maintained, nuclear war must never be fought and can never be won.
Since a global war risks becoming a nuclear war, deterrence will work. China will not have the thousands of ships and small craft and hundreds of thousands of troops needed to launch a direct amphibious assault on Taiwan by 2027. But it has other, non-military options, from economic blockade to regime change from within.
Despite Putin’s threats, Russia does not have the ability to launch a conventional attack west against NATO. In every category other than tactical nuclear weapons, NATO has overwhelming military superiority over Russia.
Five other wars in the Middle East — those of 1948, 1956, 1967, 1973 and the 1982 invasion of Lebanon — did not escalate globally. Iran’s malign activities, especially cyber, are also nothing new.
Thus, if an objective, fact-based analysis is made, no matter how dangerous conditions may appear superficially, no evidence is forthcoming that suggests a world war looms.
War by accident or miscalculation is a different issue. We have read “The March of Folly.” The closest the U.S. and USSR came to nuclear war was not the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962, but a relatively obscure NATO exercise called Able Archer in 1983 that almost led to disaster. Moscow erroneously thought NATO was launching a first strike when it was not.
As for those who maintain that in a second Trump term, neither the war in Gaza nor the invasion of Ukraine would have taken place, history is an unkind referee. The disastrous Afghan withdrawal is cited as the basis for convincing Hamas and Russia that a Biden administration would tolerate or appease any aggressive action on their part.
The Trump administration signed the Doha Accords in 2019 with the Taliban promising to withdraw from Afghanistan by May 2021, provided the Taliban did not attack Americans. The Afghan government was not present. Trump ordered a complete U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan in December 2020. That order was not followed. Nor was his invitation to the Taliban to join him at Camp David on Sept. 11, 2019.
The accord was regarded as “erratic” by National Security Advisor John Bolton and so distasteful that Secretary of State Mike Pompeo refused to sign it, directing negotiator Zalmay Khalilzad to that duty.
Had Trump been in office, the U.S. would still have withdrawn. And while that proved to be a disaster, it could have happened to Trump.
One of the achievements of the Trump administration was the Abraham Accords, which brought Israel and the Gulf states closer ultimately leading to mutual recognition with Saudi Arabia. Iran could not tolerate that happening. Oct. 7, ensured recognition was on hold.
Whether Trump was president or not, Putin would still likely have invaded Ukraine. Putin expected to seize control of Kyiv, and thus, Ukraine, within days. Whoever was U.S. president made no difference.
History and facts count. Since they do, crying “ready, fire, aim” may be a bit premature. Let’s look more closely before predicting a looming world war.
Harlan K. Ullman, Ph.D., is a senior advisor at the Atlantic Council and the prime author of the “shock and awe” military doctrine. His 12th book, “The Fifth Horseman and the New MAD: How Massive Attacks of Disruption Became the Looming Existential Danger to a Divided Nation and the World at Large,” is available on Amazon.
Date: |
-
The Wall Street Journal - World
Israel and Hezbollah Slide Toward Full-Scale War in Night of Intense Strikes
The militant group said it targeted an air base and a developer of Israel’s Iron Dome system, while dozens of Israeli warplanes struck southern Lebanon.21 hours ago - Israel -
Financial Times - World
Putin’s gambit infuses the chess world with cold war intrigue
Moscow aims to checkmate Ukraine and the west by overturning a ban on Russia’s federation membership3 days ago -
ABC News - World
Hundreds of parachutists drop over Dutch heath to commemorate World War II operation
Hundreds of paratroopers have dropped out of near-cloudless skies over a heath in the central Netherlands to commemorate the 80th anniversary Operation Market Garden2 days ago - Netherlands -
Wired - Tech
America’s Dairy Farms Have Vanished
US dairy farms are disappearing, down 95 percent in terms of numbers since the 1970s—milk price rules are one reason why.2 days ago -
Yahoo News - World
Musk's X platform takes first step toward lifting Brazil ban
Yesterday - Brazil -
CNBC - Business
Europe careens toward a downturn as its biggest economies fight crises at home
With both Germany and France fighting political and economic woes, analysts say there's a danger of a leadership vacuum and more fragmentation.8 hours ago - Europe -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
NFL injury report Week 3: Jordan Love questionable, Joe Mixon, George Kittle and A.J. Brown ruled out
Here's everything you need to know injury-wise for Week 3.3 days ago - NFL -
The Hill - Politics
Sunday shows preview: Election Day inches closer; Middle East tensions at ultimate high
Candidates are gearing up with less than 50 days to go until Election Day. Tensions between Israel and Hezbollah are at an all-time high following a series of explosions in Lebanon this week, ...Yesterday -
ABC News - Sports
Tigers beat the Orioles 6-4 to inch closer in the AL wild-card race
Beau Brieske pitched out of a jam in the ninth inning, Riley Greene drove in the go-ahead run in the 10th and the Detroit Tigers inched closer in the AL wild-card chase by beating the Baltimore ...Yesterday - MLB
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Harris topping Trump by 5 points in Pennsylvania: Poll
Vice President Harris is leading former President Trump in the swing state of Pennsylvania, according to a new Spotlight PA/MassINC poll. Harris is winning 49 percent in the poll, compared to 44 ...38 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Harris tops Trump by 5 points in Minnesota: Poll
Vice President Harris topped former President Trump by 5 points in Minnesota, according to a new poll. Harris garnered 48 percent support from registered voters in the North Star State to Trump’s ...46 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Harris to skip, Trump to attend annual Al Smith dinner
Vice President Harris will not attend the annual Al Smith dinner in New York next month, while former President Trump said on Monday that he will be there. The New York Catholic Charities ...47 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Trump and Harris’s tax policies offer more of the same — states can pave a better way
State governments are considering tax policy that favors businesses that make real investments in the local economy, while also considering the impact of businesses that view the locals as merely a ...55 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Growing number of GOP national security leaders back Harris
A growing number of Republican national security figures are endorsing Vice President Harris in the 2024 contest, firing off a series of letters warning of the risks of re-electing former President ...58 minutes ago