Trump and Harris’s tax policies offer more of the same — states can pave a better way
No matter which presidential candidate wins on Nov. 5, business groups are bracing for another epic tax policy fight in 2025. Predictable battle lines have already fallen into place: Harris wants to raise corporate taxes and Trump wants to lower them.
A more interesting but lesser known tax debate will take place in state capitals around the country. Most states will have new legislatures and 13 states could have new governors in 2025.
Our laboratories of democracy will naturally take different approaches as they compete for jobs and investment during a year that could bring an economic recession. North Carolina is already scheduled to eliminate its corporate income tax by 2030. Meanwhile, New York and Maryland are considering tax increases to plug their growing budget shortfalls.
But no matter whether states want to raise taxes or lower them, our current tax policy treats all companies the same. We don’t factor in their commitment to our states and nation.
Or, lawmakers have treated the budget as a political Rorschach test — they see an opportunity to reward their favorite industries with tax breaks. Democrats might reward clean energy projects with lower tax rates. Republicans might reward traditional energy producers.
Instead, we should reward companies that benefit our communities, regardless of political priorities that can change every four years.
State governments should adopt tax policy that favors businesses that make real investments in the local economy. If your business invests in local real estate, local products and local people, you should get a better tax rate than, say, an online Chinese retailer whose only connection to your state is via a high-speed internet cable.
Nebraska has adopted a small-scale version of this approach. Next year, the governor wants to continue with a larger overhaul of the state tax structure that would allow for broadly lowering property taxes. This would reward companies that make direct investments in the community.
More states could experiment and expand upon this policy. Direct investment translates into more local infrastructure, more local jobs and more employee development.
Companies that pay for real estate, physical assets and other infrastructure in their communities could pay a lower rate. The Department of Treasury estimates that every dollar invested in infrastructure generates about $1.50 in economic output. These assets make the community a better place to do business and attract other companies that hire more workers and make further investments in local infrastructure.
Companies that actually create local jobs could pay a lower rate. This would encourage companies to hire local workers whose paychecks stay in the community and help grow the local economy.
Companies that invest in job training could pay a lower rate. Research has consistently shown that investment in human capital improves the quality of the workforce over the long term. It strengthens the socio-economic fabric of the community, reducing income inequality and supporting sustainable economic growth.
On the other hand, big corporations that do business in the state — but are located across the ocean and sell products also made there — might pay a premium rate. Rather than investing in the community, they see it only as a marketplace of buyers. They don’t create local jobs and rely on local infrastructure that others paid for and built.
State legislators might ask how they can quantify a company’s commitment to the state and, thus, determine the tax rate they should pay.
One measure a state could consider is an employee-to-profit ratio. For example, if a company employs 10 people in the state for every $10,000 of profit they make, it would pay a lower tax rate. If a company only employs one person for every $10,000 in profit, it would pay a premium rate.
Similarly, the value of a company’s investments in local real estate and infrastructure could factor into its tax rate.
States could also factor in the company’s spending on local employee training and development.
Small businesses are the backbone of many communities, and they would naturally have an advantage under this tax structure. For example, a business owner who opens a restaurant will invest in local retail space, hire and train local staff, and buy equipment. This business would benefit from lower tax rates because of its commitment to the community.
A locally-focused tax policy will be even more important in the coming decades as our economy shifts due to the rise of artificial intelligence, as companies have less need for local people and local infrastructure.
To be sure, states can embrace new technologies while at the same time making them contribute to the success of our communities.
As states debate tax policy reform, they would be wise to consider the impact of businesses that make real investments in the local economy, versus those that view the locals as merely a market to be reached remotely.
Karen Harned is president of Harned Strategies LLC. From 2002 to 2022, she served as executive director of the National Federation of Independent Business Small Business Legal Center
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
-
Inc. - Business
3 Ways Leaders Can Support Better Mental Health at Work
Mental health matters to workers. At the Fast Company Innovation Festival, executives from Rare Beauty, Ikea, and Pie discussed the role leaders play in workplace well-being.3 days ago -
The Hill - Politics
Neither Harris nor Trump can make housing more affordable
Neither candidate’s proposals would increase the supply of affordable homes — and Vice President Kamala Harris’s plan would make matters worse.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
Tab for Trump's tax proposals is adding up. Can the U.S. afford them?
Former President Donald Trump has unveiled a flurry of proposed tax cuts aimed at seniors, homeowners, tipped workers and more.2 days ago - Donald Trump -
Financial Times - Business
Reeves paves way for capital spending increase
Speech at Labour party conference fuels debate over future of chancellor’s borrowing rules7 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Can debt relief help with your tax debt?
Dealing with overdue tax debt? There are debt relief options that can help — but they may not be what you expect.3 days ago -
ABC News - World
Facebook loses jurisdiction appeal in Kenyan court paving the way for moderators' case to proceed
Meta, Facebook’s parent company, has lost an appeal in a Kenyan labor court3 days ago - Facebook -
NBC News - Politics
Harris and Trump hit key swing states as early voting begins
Vice President Kamala Harris was in Georgia and Wisconsin on Friday with events centered on reproductive rights. While former President Donald Trump heads to the swing state of North Carolina on ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Harris slightly improves lead over Trump in battleground states: Poll
Vice President Harris has improved her lead over former President Trump in battleground states, but the race still remains close, a new survey found. The poll, conducted by CBS News and YouGov, ...Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Inc. - Business
Harris to Reveal Economic Policies for Building Wealth
Sources did not provide specifics on the expected new policies, but they could be released Wednesday in Pittsburgh.Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Evening Report — Trump gunman left assassination note, DOJ says
Plus: Key Nebraska Republican says he won't back proposed electoral vote change {beacon} Evening Report © AP Authorities: Trump golf course suspect left assassination note, offered bounty The ...24 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Pressure grows on Trump to accept second Harris debate
The pressure is on former President Trump to debate Vice President Harris again now that she has accepted a CNN invite for an October match-up, with Republicans encouraging him to go up against her ...30 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Trump rallies supporters in Pennsylvania
Former President Trump will rally supporters Monday evening at Indiana University of Pennsylvania, a little over an hour outside Pittsburgh. The Keystone State is a crucial prize in November's ...30 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Pentagon to spend $500M on women's health research
First lady Jill Biden on Monday will announce the Pentagon intends to commit $500 million on women's health research as part of a broader White House push to increase funding for the study of ...30 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Trump threatens John Deere with 200 percent tariff if it outsources manufacturing
Former President Trump on Monday threatened Illinois-based John Deere with massive tariffs on its products if it outsources some of its manufacturing to Mexico as it had previously announced, the ...32 minutes ago - Donald Trump