10 years later, the House Freedom Caucus is (mostly) a failure
It was 10 years ago this month that the House Freedom Caucus was born. Stemming from frustration with government spending and with Republican leadership, this group of far-right conservatives has had two overarching goals over the past decade.
First, they have sought to decrease government spending and to balance the federal budget through spending cuts. Second, they have sought to democratize the House of Representatives by redistributing power from leadership and putting it back in the hands of the members themselves.
Given these priorities, how successful have they been?
With respect to spending, the members of the Freedom Caucus won’t be unfurling the “Mission Accomplished” banner. In January 2015, the national debt stood near $23 trillion. It has since increased to over $36 trillion, with much of that coming with a fellow Republican, Donald Trump, in the White House. Members may try to point to some legislative victories, such as border control spending under the first Trump administration, but the fiscal goals that guided the group’s formation have not come to fruition.
The Freedom Caucus is often responsible for actually making laws less conservative. Members want legislation that is more conservative than the rest of the Republican caucus can support. When the caucus refuses to compromise with their fellow party members, Republican leadership then turns to Democrats for support. To earn the votes of these more liberal members, however, the legislation needs to shift to the left. The bill that passes the House is thus more moderate than the original piece of legislation. This has played out over and over again during the past decade, ranging from funding the Department of Homeland Security in 2015 to navigating the debt ceiling last session.
What about House procedure? Here, the Freedom Caucus has also been unsuccessful. For example, the group has fought for a return to “regular order,” which for them includes allowing individual members of the House to offer amendments to legislation on the floor. This finally happened during the previous session of Congress, but it remains the exception to the rule. Often, legislation cannot be amended at all, or amendments need to be pre-approved. In other words, the process concerns raised by the Freedom Caucus have gone largely unheeded.
Where the Freedom Caucus may have had its most demonstrable effect is on congressional leadership, particularly the position of Speaker of the House. Many conservatives who voted against John Boehner’s speakership in 2015 went on to form the Freedom Caucus. It was Freedom Caucus member Rep. Mark Meadows (R-N.C.) who introduced the motion to vacate that year, which presaged Boehner’s resignation.
Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) was next in line for the position, only to be vetoed by the Freedom Caucus before they acquiesced to Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wisc.). In 2023, the Freedom Caucus was able to extract numerous concessions from McCarthy before he was elevated to the speakership. Many Freedom Caucus members also supported the motion to vacate that removed McCarthy just months later. However, they have not been able to elevate one of their own to the position, as Freedom Caucus member Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) failed repeatedly to replace McCarthy.
So how should the House Freedom Caucus be evaluated? On its own terms, the group has come up short. Whether the issue is spending or congressional procedure, it has not achieved its founding goals.
That is not to say that the Freedom Caucus has not had an impact. Its members have been far more successful at stopping things from happening than getting what they want. They have also shaped the leadership of the House for years and have nudged legislation in a more moderate direction. In a time of intense polarization, coupled with narrow margins in the House, they have proven to be very important players. As long as these conditions hold, look for them to continue to be a powerful force in Congress — even if they don’t accomplish what they set out to.
Michael E. Bednarczuk, Ph.D., is an assistant professor of Political Science at Austin Peay State University. He studies political behavior and public service.
Topics
-
10 Years Later, Endless Legend 2 Revealed With An Unsettling First Trailer
Just over a decade ago, Amplitude Studios released Endless Legend , an inventive 4X fantasy-strategy game. Now, Amplitude Studios is unveiling the sequel, Endless Legend 2, and sharing an early ...GameSpot - 1d -
Deflategate 10 years later: Was it an actual scandal or an absurd comedy?
It's been 10 years since Tom Brady was accused of deflating footballs, a controversy that is one of the wilder and weirder stories in NFL lore.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Roy joins House Freedom Caucus for Trump meeting at Mar-a-Lago
Rep. Chip Roy (R-Texas), who President-elect Trump threatened to primary last month, joined the House Freedom Caucus meeting with Trump at Mar-a-Lago on Friday. Rep. Eli Craine (R-Ariz.) shared a ...The Hill - Jan. 11 -
Freedom Caucus members to huddle with Trump on strategy
Members of the House Freedom Caucus say they will make the case for their preferred policies and strategy when they meet with President-elect Trump at Mar-a-Lago on Friday to discuss his ambitious ...The Hill - Jan. 10 -
Andy Harris steers hard-line Freedom Caucus into the Trump era
House Freedom Caucus Chair Andy Harris (R-Md.) has taken the famously confrontational group in a slightly more agreeable direction as it prepares for a Trump-controlled Washington, where the goal ...The Hill - Jan. 9 -
Freedom Caucus holds its fire on Johnson’s strategy for passing Trump agenda
Members of the conservative House Freedom Caucus are holding their fire despite Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) bucking their preferred strategy for passing President-elect Trump’s agenda, arguing ...The Hill - Jan. 7 -
The Jan. 6 Rioters, 4 Years Later
Hundreds of rioters accused of nonviolent crimes during the attack on the Capitol have wrapped up their cases. Here’s what some of their lives look like now.The New York Times - Jan. 6 -
White House announces Presidential Medal of Freedom recipients
The White House announced the recipients of the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the nation’s highest civilian honor. The 19 honorees include former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, international ...NBC News - Jan. 4 -
Freedom Caucus board sends warning shot to Johnson despite making him Speaker
Board members on the hard-line conservative House Freedom Caucus sent a warning shot to Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) shortly after he was reelected Friday, despite the members voting to let him ...The Hill - Jan. 3
More from The Hill
-
Trump signs actions curtailing federal funding for abortion
President Trump on Friday took a pair of actions to limit U.S. government funding for abortions, reversing some of the Biden administration's efforts to increase access to the procedure. Trump ...The Hill - 36m -
Another Jan. 6 rioter rejects Trump's pardon: 'I did those things'
Another Jan. 6 rioter has rejected President Trump’s pardon, saying that he “did those things” and his actions do not merit forgiveness. “It's almost like he was trying to say it didn't happen. ...The Hill - 1h -
Anti-RFK Jr. ads target GOP senators
Click in for more news from The Hill {beacon} Health Care Health Care The Big Story Anti-RFK Jr. ads target GOP senators A progressive nonprofit is ramping up its campaign to convince senators ...The Hill - 1h -
Trump, Newsom enjoy friendly greeting, suggest they can work together
President Trump greeted California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) with a very friendly exchange when he landed in the Los Angeles area to survey wildfire damage, after the two have sparred over relief ...The Hill - 1h -
Live updates: Trump, Newsom enjoy friendly greeting as president lands in California
President Trump enjoyed a friendly greeting with California Gov. Gavin Newsom as he landed Friday evening in California to view the devastation from the greater Los Angeles wildfires. The two ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Jan. 6 prosecutors describe 'shocking,' 'guttural' week after Trump's pardons
WASHINGTON — Federal prosecutors in the now-disbanded Capitol Siege Section of the D.C. U.S. attorney's office spent much of the last four years prosecuting cases against Jan. 6 rioters.NBC News - 27m -
Secretary of State Marco Rubio orders halt to almost all U.S. foreign aid
The directive follows President Donald Trump’s executive order Monday pausing new obligations and disbursements of foreign aid pending review.NBC News - 35m -
Trump signs actions curtailing federal funding for abortion
President Trump on Friday took a pair of actions to limit U.S. government funding for abortions, reversing some of the Biden administration's efforts to increase access to the procedure. Trump ...The Hill - 36m -
In hurricane-ravaged North Carolina, Trump suggests that FEMA should be overhauled or shut down
On a visit to a North Carolina neighborhood destroyed by Hurricane Helene, President Trump was highly critical of FEMA, suggesting it should be shut down. Trump arrived late Friday in Los Angeles ...NBC News - 1h -
Another Jan. 6 rioter rejects Trump's pardon: 'I did those things'
Another Jan. 6 rioter has rejected President Trump’s pardon, saying that he “did those things” and his actions do not merit forgiveness. “It's almost like he was trying to say it didn't happen. ...The Hill - 1h