Will Dune: Messiah be Villeneuve’s crowning achievement, or the moment the spice runs dry?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/28c75/28c75becf070f21090f113490514e0bdfb73204a" alt="Will Dune: Messiah be Villeneuve’s crowning achievement, or the moment the spice runs dry?"
Denis Villeneuve has already done the well-nigh impossible, making two brilliant big-screen versions of Dune, but given the history of sci-fi film sequels, another could be a terrifying sandworm too many
Hollywood has a long history of making great first sci-fi instalments that slowly turn into pompous, inconsequential, and increasingly mind-numbing dross as the sequels keep rolling. The Matrix went from a revolutionary cyberpunk masterpiece to an interminable slog of a philosophy dissertation in which both humans and machines alike seemed to be forever fighting a losing battle with a CGI hurricane. The Terminator franchise started out as a brutally sleek and sinuous time-travel thriller that plucked at the very heartstrings of the eternal fear of the unknown at the heart of the human condition – yet ended up as the living embodiment of what happens when Hollywood repeatedly tears the living skin off its own dead-eyed robo-franchise, as if stuck in some kind of endless corporate judgment day doom-loop. Let’s not even mention Jurassic Park, which began life as an awe-inspiring blockbuster about the dangers of unchecked scientific hubris and ended up as the prosaic tale of dinosaurs just sort-of existing in the background while we all focused heavily on a dull corporate espionage subplot about genetically modified locusts.
All of which is why Denis Villeneuve’s current efforts to bring Dune back to life on the big screen (more than four decades after the late, lamented David Lynch’s version poured psychedelic spice-soaked fever dreams into our quivering mid-80s retinas) are the subject of so much breathless anticipation and existential dread among fans. Because, damn it, Villeneuve has (as anyone who watched any of his previous films expected) done a simply incredible job of adapting Frank Herbert’s sprawling, monolithic space fantasy into not one but two synapse-crushingly epic movies of almost impossible power and majesty – operatic, awe-inspiring spectacles that somehow make interstellar feudalism, giant sandworms, and psychic drug trips feel utterly essential to the very fabric of existence, as though humanity’s ultimate destiny was always to brood majestically in the dunes while contemplating the crushing weight of prophecy.
Continue reading...Topics
-
'Dune: Part Two': Foreshadowing a savior
In photographing Denis Villeneuve's "Dune: Part Two," cinematographer Greig Fraser says it was "important to create iconic images" for the sequel that sees Paul Atreides (Timothée Chalamet) embrace ...Los Angeles Times - Feb. 13 -
Dune: Awakening Releases On PC In May
Funcom has announced that its MMO survival game, Dune: Awakening, will launch for PC on May 20. The game is also slated for a PS5 and Xbox Series X|S launch, but a release date for those versions ...GameSpot - 3h -
Trump meets with the king and crown prince of Jordan
Trump meets with the king and crown prince of Jordan at the White House today as he proposes the U.S. take control over the Gaza Strip.NBC News - Feb. 11 -
How Much Can 10,000 Mexican Troops Achieve at the Border?
To stave off U.S. tariffs, Mexico agreed to deploy 10,000 troops to its northern border. Analysts and former officials question whether they can effectively stop the flow of fentanyl.The New York Times - Feb. 7 -
How RFK Jr. achieved his HHS confirmation after vaccine controversy
The Senate confirmed Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as Secretary of Health and Human Services on Thursday. He faced questions over his past remarks on the efficacy of vaccines during his confirmation ...CBS News - 6d -
A lifetime achievement award for Don James, Nintendo’s behind-the-scenes man | interview
Don James, executive vice president of Nintendo of America, received the Lifetime Achievement Award at the Dice Awards.VentureBeat - 5d -
Rahm Emanuel: Trump helping achieve Stalin’s dream with Russia-Ukraine comments
Former U.S. Ambassador to Japan Rahm Emanuel said President Trump is helping to achieve former Soviet Union dictator Joseph Stalin’s dream with his recent actions surrounding the Russia-Ukraine ...The Hill - 19h -
Collier takes home $200K, Unrivaled 1-on-1 crown
Napheesa Collier of the WNBA's Lynx took home $200,000 after she beat Mystics forward Aaliyah Edwards in the final of Unrivaled's 1-on-1 tournament.ESPN - 5d -
Rubio meets with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman
Secretary of State Marco Rubio held a meeting Monday with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman in Riyadh. The State Department issued a statement on Rubio's meeting with the Saudi crown prince, ...The Hill - 2d
More from The Guardian
-
Trump ‘very frustrated’ with Zelenskyy for allegedly failing to ‘take opportunity’ of US-brokered peace – live
US national security adviser claims Ukrainian president has failed to ‘come to the table’ despite not being invited to Russia-US talks this week. Vance poses immigrants as ‘greatest threat’ to US ...The Guardian - 35m -
‘One of the hardest days’ in Israel as Hamas hands over hostages’ bodies
Remains of two young children, their mother and an elderly man arrive in Tel Aviv after ‘cruel’ handover in Gaza. The remains of two young children, their mother, and an elderly man taken hostage ...The Guardian - 2h -
Trump appears to agree to cut checks to Americans to share portion of savings from Doge cost-cutting
‘Department of government efficiency’ head Elon Musk suggested $5,000 checks to US households if targets met. Donald Trump has appeared to embrace a proposal to share a portion of the cuts in US ...The Guardian - 1h -
Americans’ confidence in air travel falls after string of plane crashes, poll shows
Survey indicates 64% of Americans believe flying is safe, down from 71% who said so last year. Americans’ confidence in aviation has slipped following a string of plane crashes in 2025, according ...The Guardian - 1h -
US Senate narrowly confirms Kash Patel as next FBI director
Patel, who was confirmed along party lines, aligns with Donald Trump on a range of issues. The US Senate has confirmed Kash Patel as the next FBI director, handing oversight of the nation’s premier ...The Guardian - 26m
More in World
-
Europa League playoffs: Roma v Porto, Galatasaray v AZ and more – live
Europa League updates from around the grounds Live scoreboard | Read Football Daily | And mail Rob 45 min: Roma 2-1 Porto (agg: 3-2) Roma almost scored a third a moment ago, with a shot ...The Guardian - 20m -
US Senate narrowly confirms Kash Patel as next FBI director
Patel, who was confirmed along party lines, aligns with Donald Trump on a range of issues. The US Senate has confirmed Kash Patel as the next FBI director, handing oversight of the nation’s premier ...The Guardian - 26m -
Trump ‘very frustrated’ with Zelenskyy for allegedly failing to ‘take opportunity’ of US-brokered peace – live
US national security adviser claims Ukrainian president has failed to ‘come to the table’ despite not being invited to Russia-US talks this week. Vance poses immigrants as ‘greatest threat’ to US ...The Guardian - 35m -
Senators applaud McConnell as Republican vows to keep working until end of term in 2026 – live
Republican senator announces he won’t seek re-election in 2026, capping a decadeslong career in Congress. Mitch McConnell won’t seek Senate re-election in 2026 Donald Trump signed another ...The Guardian - 37m -
Nigel Farage dissents from Trump’s Zelenskyy ‘dictator’ claim
Reform leader contradicts Trump rant, saying ‘you shouldn’t always take things Donald Trump says absolutely literally’. Nigel Farage has contradicted his ally Donald Trump, saying Volodymyr ...The Guardian - 56m