When historians and directors clash: ‘Ridley Scott was Napoleonic – there was no doubt who was in charge’

Film and TV have a slippery relationship with the truth when it comes to historical epics. So spare a thought for the historical experts whose advice often goes unheeded

If we set aside the more glaring historical inaccuracies in the trailers for the long-awaited Gladiator sequel – the guy riding a rhinoceros for example – there were early signs that its director Ridley Scott remained committed to one of the first film’s more subtle flaws.

They are there in the posters, if you know where to look, and they feature throughout the film itself, which hits cinemas this week with Paul Mescal in the leading role. We’re talking about the leather wrist guards.

Topics

Director Ridley Scott says he won’t retire from movies despite being 86: ‘Are you kidding?’
Business - MarketWatch - November 7
Ridley Scott Clarifies Those Gladiator 3 Reports
Tech - GameSpot - October 23
Ridley Scott on ‘Gladiator II,” Denzel Washington and Joaquin Phoenix
Top stories - The New York Times - November 7
Gladiator II review – Paul Mescal slays in Ridley Scott’s gobsmacking reboot
World - The Guardian - 5 days ago
Sources: Rice (broken toe) doubt for Chelsea clash
Sports - ESPN - November 8
Paul Mescal interviews Ridley Scott: ‘I was so ahead of the game. The Oxbridge lot were aghast’
World - The Guardian - 2 days ago
Joseph Rykwert, 98, Dies; Historian of Architecture Challenged Modernism
Top stories - The New York Times - November 7
7 charged with cyberbullying after Paris Olympics artistic director's opening ceremony backlash
World - ABC News - October 25
Trump says former Ice director Tom Homan will be in charge of borders and deportations
World - The Guardian - 6 days ago

Latest in World

Russia grinds deeper into Ukraine after 1,000 days of grueling war
World - ABC News - 13 minutes ago
Israeli police make arrests after flares fired at prime minister's private residence
World - ABC News - 13 minutes ago
‘Have your bot speak to my bot’: can AI productivity apps turbocharge my life?
World - The Guardian - 56 minutes ago
‘I’ve had a wild, chaotic, beautiful life’: Rebecca Hall on race, regrets and learning to be herself
World - The Guardian - 56 minutes ago
Didion & Babitz by Lili Anolik review –the seductress and the sphinx
World - The Guardian - 56 minutes ago

When historians and directors clash: ‘Ridley Scott was Napoleonic – there was no doubt who was in charge’

Topics

Related

Director Ridley Scott says he won’t retire from movies despite being 86: ‘Are you kidding?’

Ridley Scott Clarifies Those Gladiator 3 Reports

Ridley Scott on ‘Gladiator II,” Denzel Washington and Joaquin Phoenix

Gladiator II review – Paul Mescal slays in Ridley Scott’s gobsmacking reboot

Sources: Rice (broken toe) doubt for Chelsea clash

Paul Mescal interviews Ridley Scott: ‘I was so ahead of the game. The Oxbridge lot were aghast’

Joseph Rykwert, 98, Dies; Historian of Architecture Challenged Modernism

7 charged with cyberbullying after Paris Olympics artistic director's opening ceremony backlash

Trump says former Ice director Tom Homan will be in charge of borders and deportations

More from The Guardian

UK must choose between EU and Trump, trade experts warn

Rightwing settlers in Israel welcome ‘dream team’ of Trump and his hardline appointments

Xi says China is ‘ready to work’ with Trump in final meeting with Biden

Trump picks oil and gas industry CEO Chris Wright as next energy secretary

Kemi Badenoch’s first approval ratings as Tory leader worse than Sunak and Johnson

Latest in World

Russia grinds deeper into Ukraine after 1,000 days of grueling war

Israeli police make arrests after flares fired at prime minister's private residence

‘Have your bot speak to my bot’: can AI productivity apps turbocharge my life?

‘I’ve had a wild, chaotic, beautiful life’: Rebecca Hall on race, regrets and learning to be herself

Didion & Babitz by Lili Anolik review –the seductress and the sphinx