The UK was crying out for a new kind of budget. Labour has given it repackaged Tory ideas | David Edgerton
A fairer, happier and more equal country is possible – but only if the party in power actually wants to make it happen
Has Labour got a radical economic programme, on a par with 1945 or 1964? Has it stealthily snuck this past a hostile electorate? If you glanced at coverage of last week’s “historic” budget, you could be forgiven for thinking it had. At the election, the party promised minor increases in tax and spending, and now it is proposing major increases in borrowing, taxing and spending. But while this might seem like a screeching U-turn, it is nothing of the sort. Far from being radical, Labour’s programme shows deep continuities with failed Tory ideas and policies that do not meet the requirements of the hour, let alone offer any hope for the sort of transformation Labour once provided.
Public spending was planned to fall so catastrophically over the next few years that Labour had little choice but to increase it. Had they still been in power, the Tories would have been faced with the same necessity. That’s because the scale of public spending in Britain is determined mainly by the need to provide a health service, pensions and benefits (the last on a bare-minimum level, by political choice). Imagine, for a moment, what might have happened if Labour hadn’t committed to raising spending: we would have seen increasing NHS waiting lists, schools with fewer teachers, and public investment falling to only 1.7% of GDP. An already dysfunctional state would not see supposed productivity gains, but would instead cease functioning.
David Edgerton is Hans Rausing professor of the history of science and technology, professor of modern British history at King’s College London, and the author of The Rise and Fall of the British Nation
Continue reading...Topics
-
UK Budget: What to Know Before Labour’s Announcement
Top stories - The New York Times - October 28 -
Did Labour mislead UK public ahead of Budget?
World - Financial Times - 6 days ago -
UK Labour’s Budget borrows big, taxes more
World - Financial Times - 6 days ago -
UK Budget: Labour Party to Raise Taxes by 40 Billion Pounds
Business - The New York Times - 6 days ago -
UK's ultra-rich feel the pinch from Labour's tax-raising budget
Business - CNBC - 19 hours ago -
Cleverly rules out frontbench role under new Tory leader
Top stories - BBC News - 3 days ago -
Chancellor to announce five new UK freeports in the Budget
Business - Financial Times - October 25 -
UK’s Labour just unveiled its first budget in 14 years – what is in it and will it work?
World - The Guardian - 6 days ago
More from The Guardian
-
US election 2024 live: Donald Trump says ‘we made history’ as he closes in on victory with win in Pennsylvania
World - The Guardian - 19 minutes ago -
US election results 2024 live: Donald Trump edges close to victory over Kamala Harris
World - The Guardian - 3 hours ago -
US Senate, House and governor elections 2024: results from all 50 states as Republicans win Senate
World - The Guardian - 3 hours ago -
Promise and excitement turn to jitters and dread at Kamala Harris’s watch party
World - The Guardian - 1 hour ago -
Republicans retake control of US Senate after Democrats lose majority
World - The Guardian - 45 minutes ago
Latest in World
-
China woes weigh on profits at Toyota, Honda and BMW
World - Financial Times - 13 minutes ago -
Dollar surges and US bond yields jump as investors bet on Trump win
World - Financial Times - 15 minutes ago -
US election 2024 live: Donald Trump says ‘we made history’ as he closes in on victory with win in Pennsylvania
World - The Guardian - 19 minutes ago -
Middle East crisis live: protests in Israel after Netanyahu fires defence minister Gallant
World - The Guardian - 20 minutes ago -
The swing to Trump in maps and charts
World - Financial Times - 34 minutes ago