The Pitt review – real-time medical drama puts Noah Wyle back in ER
There are interestingly knotty issues covered in the series, set over one hellish shift, but soapy acting and thinly written characters ultimately derail
The reunion of ER showrunner John Wells, writer R Scott Gemmill and longtime star Noah Wyle for The Pitt, a new drama also set in the heart of a hectic hospital, was enough to irk the estate of the hit show’s original creator, Michael Crichton. In an aggrieved lawsuit, his widow, Sherri Crichton, labelled it a “personal betrayal” and one that only happened when discussions between the two parties for an authorised ER reboot fell apart. The new series airing on HBO’s often substandard streamer Max (which is part of the same Warners empire that birthed ER) has a similarly chaotic energy, just relocated to a different city (this time it’s, title clue, Pittsburgh, rather than Chicago). Despite protestations from defensive execs, one can understand the furore.
But as a viewer, especially one who keenly followed the long-running drama for the majority of its 15 seasons, the main cause of bother is that The Pitt just isn’t anywhere near as effective. Since ER premiered – a near perfect modulation of personal and professional conflict – many, many other hospital-set shows followed, all of them failing to manage that balance quite as well. Grey’s Anatomy might have lasted longer – at 21 seasons, it’s starting to outlast most things on television – but its best days were long, long ago and its tendency to lean on sappy, Starbucks-soundtracked melodrama made it more of an acquired taste.
Continue reading...-
Enron Is Back. Could This Possibly Be Real?
One of the pranksters behind “Birds Aren’t Real” is back to revive a company synonymous with corporate malfeasance — it has merch and what it’s claiming is an at-home nuclear reactor.The New York Times - 9h -
Review: 'The Pitt' offers hyperrealism, whereas 'Doc' leans into melodrama
"The Pitt" on Max, starring Noah Wyle, and "Doc" on Fox, starring Molly Parker, offer different takes on hospital-set drama.Los Angeles Times - 11h -
South Korea’s real-life political drama
Attempted coup throws spotlight on deep-rooted problemsFinancial Times - 1d -
A Real Pain review – Jesse Eisenberg’s sauntering Holocaust tour comedy is a masterpiece
The writer, director and actor effortlessly walks a tonal tightrope in this film about Jewish American cousins on a Holocaust tour in Poland. But Kieran Culkin steals the show as the more ...The Guardian - 1d -
Review: As Golden Globes host, Nikki Glaser delivered a good time at Hollywood's party night
Despite a long ceremony chock full of awards, emcee Nikki Glaser kept the show moving along with lightly cutting and relatively inoffensive jokes.Los Angeles Times - 3d -
We Live in Time review – Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield star in soggy tearjerker
The chemistry between the leads can’t quite save this ill-fated romance let down by an anodyne score and jarring product placement. For a film that strives as desperately as this one does to jazz ...The Guardian - 4d -
'He doesn't get the love that he should': How Quinn Ewers put Texas back in the spotlight
Ewers, about to face former school Ohio State, wants to be the QB to deliver Texas' first national title since 2005.ESPN - 5d -
Marjorie Taylor Greene backs Johnson: 'Let's put aside the infighting'
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) announced Tuesday that she would be endorsing Rep. Mike Johnson (R-La.) for House Speaker, a notable win for the Louisiana Republican given Greene has at times ...The Hill - 6d -
We Live in Time review – romance blossoms for Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield
This sensitive if contrived romantic drama has shades of Richard Curtis and is carried along by the strength of its lead performances. There are endearing, intelligent and forthright performances ...The Guardian - Jan. 1
More from The Guardian
-
Hottest year on record sent planet past 1.5C of heating for first time in 2024
Highest recorded temperatures supercharged extreme weather – with worse to come, EU data shows . Climate breakdown drove the annual global temperature above the internationally agreed 1.5C target ...The Guardian - 3h -
Biden hails Jimmy Carter’s strength of character in eulogy at state funeral
Service marks end of 39th president’s lying in state at ceremony attended by all five living presidents. Jimmy Carter funeral – latest news Jimmy Carter’s six-day farewell to the nation ...The Guardian - 12h -
LA fires live updates: death toll rises to 10 as California wildfires rage and crews battle new fire
Palisades, Kenneth and Eaton fires remain uncontrolled as Los Angeles officials say ‘historic winds’ and extensive droughts have created the ‘perfect storm’. Full report: Los Angeles fires burn ...The Guardian - 21m -
Trudeau: Trump threatened to annex Canada to distract from tariffs impact
Canadian PM says ‘skilful negotiator’ Trump is trying to distract from rise in prices that would follow his proposed tariffs. The Canadian prime minister, Justin Trudeau , has described Donald ...The Guardian - 7h -
Venezuelan opposition leader María Corina Machado ‘kidnapped’, allies say
Leader reportedly freed after being ‘violently intercepted’ having left hideout to lead protest against Nicolás Maduro. Allies of Venezuela’s most influential opposition leader, María Corina ...The Guardian - 8h
More in World
-
LA fires live updates: death toll rises to 10 as California wildfires rage and crews battle new fire
Palisades, Kenneth and Eaton fires remain uncontrolled as Los Angeles officials say ‘historic winds’ and extensive droughts have created the ‘perfect storm’. Full report: Los Angeles fires burn ...The Guardian - 21m -
Loved ones mourn Kelyan Bokassa, the 14-year-old boy killed on a London bus. And we all have some thinking to do | Gaby Hinsliff
His mother says he was groomed by drug gangsters despite her attempts to get help. Let his death spark fresh debate about how we care for vulnerable people. The last time Mary Bokassa saw her ...The Guardian - 23m -
Libya expels 600 Nigeriens in ‘dangerous and traumatising’ desert journey
Largest known deportation of people back to Niger to date comes as EU is accused of outsourcing cruelty to reduce Mediterranean crossings. . More than 600 people have been forcibly deported from ...The Guardian - 23m -
Making moves: what to wear for your work out
From parkruns to pilates classes, here is the kit that will make getting out of bed to work out on a cold morning a little easier Continue reading...The Guardian - 23m -
Warmer homes and healthier people: what’s not to like about a low-carbon future?
Challenges of hitting net zero emissions are often discussed, but little focus is given to the gains of living in a low-carbon world. The challenges of reaching net zero emissions are often ...The Guardian - 23m