The Cass review of gender identity services marks a return to reason and evidence – it must be defended
Its author has had to fend off criticism and misinformation, but the report offers hope for a realistic conversation
As the dust settles around Hilary Cass’s report – the most extensive and thoroughgoing evidence-based review of treatment for children experiencing gender distress ever undertaken – it is clear her findings support the grave concerns I and many others have raised. Central here was the lack of an evidential base of good quality that could back claims for the effectiveness of young people being prescribed puberty blockers or proceeding on a medical pathway to transition. I and many other clinicians were concerned about the risks of long-term damaging consequences of early medical intervention. Cass has already had to speak out against misinformation being spread about her review, and a Labour MP has admitted she “may have misled” Parliament when referring to it. The review should be defended from misrepresentation.
The policy of “affirmation” – that is, speedily agreeing with a child that they are of the wrong gender – was an inappropriate clinical stance brought about by influential activist groups and some senior gender identity development service (Gids) staff, resulting in a distortion of the clinical domain. Studies indicate that a majority of children in the absence of medical intervention will desist – that is, change their minds.
David Bell is a retired psychiatrist and former president of the British Psychoanalytic Society
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
Continue reading...Date: |
Filter
-
Nuggets vs. Timberwolves: Three reasons why Anthony Edwards, Minnesota could upset the defending champions
From size to star power, the Wolves have what it takes to dethrone DenverCBS Sports - Sports - NBA
More from The Guardian
-
Israeli airstrikes on Rafah begin despite mounting ceasefire pressure
Palestinians in Gaza thrown into confusion by Hamas’s acceptance of a deal, followed by Israel’s sceptical response and bomb attacks. Rafah’s fate hung in the balance on Monday after Hamas said it had accepted a ceasefire-for-hostage deal but ...The Guardian - World - Israel -
Accused Canadian serial murderer admits killing four Indigenous women
Jeremy Skibicki, charged with four counts of first-degree murder, is believed to have left bodies of at least two victims in a landfill. An accused serial killer in Canada, who police believed disposed of his victims by dumping some of them in ...The Guardian - World -
Met Gala 2024 live updates: Zendaya stuns in second outfit; Cardi B and Lana Del Rey among stars at fashion’s biggest night
Stars turn up for annual fundraiser at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York amid protests against Israel-Gaza war nearby. Dozens of anti-Israel protesters near Met Gala aim to disrupt eventCo-chair and absolute queen of meta-dressing – see ...The Guardian - World -
Judge threatens Trump with jail time for gag order violations in hush-money trial
Judge holds Trump in criminal contempt for the 10th time in response to former president’s comments on the jury. The judge overseeing Donald Trump’s criminal hush-money trial on Monday held him in criminal contempt for the 10th time and warned he ...The Guardian - World - Donald Trump -
Ukraine war briefing: US and most EU countries to boycott Putin swearing-in ceremony
US spokesperson says no envoy will attend because Russian president’s election was not ‘free and fair’. What we know on day 804. The US and most EU nations will boycott a Kremlin ceremony to swear in Vladimir Putin for a new six-year term as ...The Guardian - World - Ukraine