Putin is not Hitler. His actions in Ukraine are horrific enough to need no exaggeration | Simon Jenkins
Keir Starmer has said we face the greatest threat to our national security since the cold war. Such hyperbole helps nobody
Is Vladimir Putin another Adolf Hitler? The western world seems to think so. In which case is Donald Trump another Neville Chamberlain and Ukraine another Czechoslovakia? Is history bunk, or is it a wise old man leaning on the gate as Europe storms into its latest crisis?
Godwin’s law holds that the longer a political argument continues, the nearer it gets to Hitler. This reductio ad Hitlerum distorts the issue under discussion and diminishes the exceptional horror of Hitler and the Holocaust. A variant of Godwin’s law goes further. It asserts that having to call Hitler in aid means that you have already lost the argument.
Simon Jenkins is a Guardian columnist
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
Continue reading...
Read more at The Guardian
-
US needs role in Ukraine to deter Putin, says PM
The PM stresses the importance of US help but Trump suggests responsibility lies with Europe.BBC News - 5d -
No matter how distasteful we find Trump and Vance over Europe, they speak a blunt truth | Simon Jenkins
The US has chosen the worst possible moment and the worst possible way to say it, but it is right to call for a realignment. It’s tough being rightwing these days. You have to find something nice ...The Guardian - Feb. 21 -
Trump says Putin would keep his word on a Ukraine peace deal
President claims presence of US workers in Ukraine would deter Russian aggression after talks with Keir Starmer. Donald Trump has insisted that Vladimir Putin would “keep his word” on a peace deal ...The Guardian - 4d -
Trump trusts Putin to 'keep his word' and more takeaways from Starmer meet on Ukraine
President Trump hosted United Kingdom Prime Minister Keir Starmer at the White House on Thursday for discussions focused on the Russia-Ukraine war.ABC News - 4d -
Speaker Johnson says ‘someone else needs to lead’ Ukraine if Zelenskyy doesn’t ‘come to his senses’
House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) on Meet the Press says Ukrainian President Volodymr Zelenskyy “needs to come to his senses and come back to the table in gratitude, or someone else needs to lead ...NBC News - 1d -
Administration channels Neville Chamberlain with actions on Ukraine
The Biden administration is reportedly seeking a peace deal in Ukraine that gives Russia control over certain territories, despite warnings from allies and critics that this would be appeasement ...The Hill - 2d -
From saviour to Judas… How Trump’s pivot on Russia also endangers his own country | Simon Tisdall
With a Putin-appeasing president at the helm, it is clear the transatlantic alliance is collapsing and European leaders must plot their own course. How do I betray thee? Let me count the ways… ...The Guardian - Feb. 22 -
Putin hopeful after US talks on Ukraine ceasefire
Russian president says the first round held in Saudi Arabia lays the ‘groundwork for future co-operation’Financial Times - 4d -
From ‘The Art of the Deal’ to giving away Ukraine to Putin
As Ukraine is discovering to its cost, the president’s very notion of a “deal” can be hazy.The Hill - 3d
More from The Guardian
-
Europe ‘ready to step up’ as Kremlin welcomes Donald Trump decision to pause aid for Ukraine – Europe live
EU ready to increase defence spending and military capabilities as Kremlin welcomes US ‘contribution’ to the cause of peace. New EU plans to strengthen Europe’s defence industry and increase ...The Guardian - 19m -
China and Canada retaliate after Trump trade tariffs come into effect
Markets tumble as US president’s levies against Canada, Mexico and China come into effect. China and Canada unveiled retaliatory measures against the US after Donald Trump imposed his sweeping ...The Guardian - 3h -
Trump to address Congress as policy decisions divide nation – US politics live
President expected to ask for more money for immigration crackdown as Democrats invite fired federal workers to speech. Trump to lay out second-term vision in key address to Congress . US ...The Guardian - 24m -
Australian ‘man with the golden arm’, whose rare blood saved 2.4m babies, dies at 88
James Harrison rolled up his sleeve more than 1,100 times to give his plasma, which was used in life-saving anti-D medication. James Harrison, the Australian known as “the man with the golden arm” ...The Guardian - 3h -
Largest wildfire in decades rages in Japan as authorities warn it could spread
Blaze in Ofunato has spread through 2,100 hectares of land, damaged dozens of homes and forced more than 1,000 to flee. Authorities in Japan have warned that the country’s biggest wildfire in ...The Guardian - 8h
More in World
-
Live Updates: China and Canada Retaliate Against New Trump Tariffs
The responses escalated the trade war that has rattled governments and international relations. The Trump administration’s latest tariffs also targeted Mexico.The New York Times - 10m -
India v Australia: Champions Trophy cricket semi-final – live
Over-by-over report: all the semi-final action from Dubai Sign up for our newsletter, The Spin | And mail Daniel G 1st over: Australia 2-0 (Head 1, Connolly 0) Shami was millimetres away ...The Guardian - 17m -
Worker protections to be toughened in UK employment bill amendments
Despite government vow to listen to business, changes to be published on Tuesday will favour employeesFinancial Times - 18m -
Europe ‘ready to step up’ as Kremlin welcomes Donald Trump decision to pause aid for Ukraine – Europe live
EU ready to increase defence spending and military capabilities as Kremlin welcomes US ‘contribution’ to the cause of peace. New EU plans to strengthen Europe’s defence industry and increase ...The Guardian - 19m -
Trump to address Congress as policy decisions divide nation – US politics live
President expected to ask for more money for immigration crackdown as Democrats invite fired federal workers to speech. Trump to lay out second-term vision in key address to Congress . US ...The Guardian - 24m