MPs will vote, but there is a better way to decide who has the right to die | Rafael Behr
In an age of cynicism and mistrust, politicians must work harder to involve the public in difficult decisions
When MPs vote this Friday on assisted dying, they will be trying to answer two questions folded into one. First comes the ethical choice. Is it ever permissible for one person to help someone else take their own life? Then comes the regulatory challenge. Under what conditions might that permission be granted in law?
It isn’t easy to separate those considerations. Sometimes you have to work through scenarios of implementation before arriving at a view on the prior principle. But when legislation is being drafted, the two questions must logically be answered in sequence, not in parallel. When and how are only relevant debates if the answer to the question of whether assisted dying can ever be allowed is yes.
Rafael Behr is a Guardian columnist
Continue reading...Topics
-
Left, right, Harris, Trump: all prisoners of political nostalgia in an era few understand | Rafael Behr
World - The Guardian - November 5 -
Trump’s victory has fractured the western order – leaving Brexit Britain badly exposed | Rafael Behr
World - The Guardian - November 13 -
The delicate task of granting the right to die
Business - Financial Times - November 11 -
‘To Die on the Court’: Rafael Nadal and the Battle With His Own Body
Sports - The New York Times - 6 days ago -
Is it better to vote early or on Election Day?
Politics - The Hill - November 5 -
‘This election season has worn me out’: I love this country, but I’m no better off financially than I was 10 years ago. Why vote?
Business - MarketWatch - November 5 -
MP mugged by gang who snatched mobile phone
Top stories - BBC News - November 5 -
Looking forward on voting rights
Politics - The Hill - 5 days ago -
Voters decide on abortion rights in 10 states
Top stories - CBS News - November 6
More from The Guardian
-
Displaced residents return to southern Lebanon as Israel-Hezbollah ceasefire appears to hold – Middle East crisis live
World - The Guardian - 17 minutes ago -
Trump announces more picks including US trade chief and health deputy
World - The Guardian - 7 hours ago -
British mother of Egyptian political prisoner to press Lammy to take action
World - The Guardian - 4 hours ago -
Seoul slows down under blanket of heaviest November snow in 100 years
World - The Guardian - 3 hours ago -
Bolsonaro allies nearly launched military coup in 2022, police report says
World - The Guardian - 12 hours ago