Lady Gaga: Disease review – a return to form, and to her classic sound
After a run of power ballads and jazz standards – plus the mega-flop Joker sequel – this synthpop single is a reminder of the Gaga of old, while still fitting into today’s Brat era
Thus far, 2024 has proved a decidedly mixed bag for Lady Gaga. On the plus side, her duet with Bruno Mars, Die With a Smile was a huge global hit: nine weeks after its release, it is still resident in the UK Top 3 and is the second most-streamed song in the world on Spotify. But then there was the debacle of Joker: Folie à Deux, and her accompanying album Harlequin was released to a very muted critical and commercial response. Gaga has done an impressive job of carrying her audience along with her throughout an eclectic approach to pop in which arty synthpop coexists alongside stadium-sized soft-rock, country-infused Americana and vocal jazz – but she seemed finally to have lost them: a third album of standards, this time without her late duet partner Tony Bennett, and allied to one of the year’s biggest box office bombs, apparently proved a step too far.
Perhaps she can rectify things with Disease, a song that that ignores the fact that her biggest successes in recent years have been power ballads – not just Die With a Smile but the 10m-selling Shallow – and returns her to old-fashioned Gaga territory. Certainly, her stans seem to think she can. Within hours of the single appearing, one of them had worked up such a froth they posted a 1,500-word online essay comparing its lyrics to Sylvia Plath, Baudelaire and the sonnets of John Donne, which even those impressed with the sexually forthright thrust of its chorus – “lay you down like one-two-three, your eyes roll back in ecstasy” – might think amounts to gilding the lily a little.
Continue reading...Date: |
Topics
-
World - The Guardian
Beyond Black Beauty review – this reboot of a classic is clumsy, insipid … and hard to hate
October 16 -
Tech - Wired
Ultimate Ears Boom 4 Review: Same Great Sound, Now Easier to Charge
October 18 -
Entertainment - ABC News
Book Review: Single mother in her 50s falls hard for much younger man in Susan Minot’s latest novel
October 15 -
Entertainment - Los Angeles Times
Review: Charli XCX broke through with 'Brat' memes. At the Forum, she proved her staying power
October 16 -
Entertainment - ABC News
Music Review: Muna frontwoman Katie Gavin makes her solo debut with folky, evocative 'What A Relief'
23 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Hurricane Oscar forms in the Caribbean
5 days ago - Oscars -
World - The Guardian
‘I will be hunted down for my Taylor Swift jokes!’ Rose Matafeo on her scary return to standup
October 15 -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Wildlife conservationists form new alliance
October 18 -
Top stories - The New York Times
Tropical Storm Nadine Forms in the Caribbean
6 days ago
More from The Guardian
-
World - The Guardian
US election live updates: Harris heads to Texas as poll shows her tied with Trump at 48%
16 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
World - The Guardian
Stacey Williams says Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein ‘coordinated’ groping incident
3 hours ago - Donald Trump -
World - The Guardian
Middle East crisis live: UN rights chief says ‘darkest moment’ of Israel’s war on Gaza is unfolding in the north
33 minutes ago - Israel -
World - The Guardian
Elon Musk has been in regular contact with Putin for two years, says report
1 hour ago - Elon Musk -
World - The Guardian
Northern Irish man jailed for life after abusing at least 70 children online
2 hours ago
Latest in World
-
World - ABC News
An Israeli airstrike killed journalists covering the war in Lebanon as they slept
1 minute ago - Israel -
World - ABC News
EU leader praises Serbia for its advances in EU membership bid despite growing Russian influence
1 minute ago - European Union -
World - The New York Times
Live Updates: Deadly Israeli Strikes Hit Southern Gaza, Health Officials Say
2 minutes ago - Israel -
World - ABC News
Ex-commander of a Ugandan rebel group has been sentenced to 40 years in prison
9 minutes ago -
World - The Guardian
US election live updates: Harris heads to Texas as poll shows her tied with Trump at 48%
16 minutes ago - Donald Trump