Is effective centre-left government possible? Starmer has yet to prove that – but prove it he must
The PM faces conflicting ideological demands. After the budget and Labour conference, we will see how adept he is at managing them
All governments disappoint us in the end. Some policies fail, divisions open up, ideological dead-ends are reached and national problems are left unsolved. The big question is at what point widespread disillusion sets in: after a few months, a few years, or longer. The answer has decisive consequences for a government’s sense of itself and for its electoral fate.
You might think this government, only seven weeks old, the first entirely new Labour administration for a quarter of a century, with a huge majority and ministers working hard while much of the country is on holiday, will be safe from voter disdain for quite a while. Yet that assumption may be optimistic. Not just because of Labour’s thin total vote at the election, or the immense national problems it has inherited, but for other, less examined reasons. Ruling from the centre-left is particularly difficult, as Labour governments have regularly demonstrated. And changes in the media and in how voters think have made that task even harder.
Andy Beckett is a Guardian columnist
Continue reading...Date: |
Topics
-
ABC News - Health
Congressional Democrats push resolution that says hospitals must provide emergency abortions
A resolution introduced by Congressional Democrats would make clear that U.S. emergency rooms need to provide emergency abortions when a woman’s health or life is at risk, despite strict state ...31 minutes ago - Abortion -
The Guardian - World
Rafael Nadal runs out of time to prove fitness for Europe’s Laver Cup tilt
Spaniard ‘disappointed’ to drop out Will ‘cheer Team Europe from afar’ Rafael Nadal has pulled out of next week’s Laver Cup as he battles to regain full fitness, the Spaniard said on Thursday. ...1 hour ago -
NBC News - Politics
JD Vance says GOP should threaten a shutdown
WASHINGTON — Sen. JD Vance suggested that it could be in Republicans' best interest to threaten a government shutdown ahead of an impending funding deadline, asking, “Why have a government if it’s ...1 hour ago -
ABC News - World
Conflict in South Africa's coalition government is 'not catastrophic,' says major party leader
The leader of South Africa's second biggest party says there will be conflict in the new coalition government, and it should not be viewed as "catastrophic."3 hours ago -
ABC News - Top stories
NYPD Commissioner Edward Caban resigns: 'My complete focus must be on the NYPD'
Edward Caban's resignation comes amid a federal investigation that last week saw authorities seize phones belonging to him and other NYPD officials, sources said.3 hours ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
Hall of Fame voter reveals main reason why Patriots owner Robert Kraft has yet to be inducted
One thing is keeping Kraft from his rightful place in Canton5 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Why Starmer’s NHS reforms may give you a sense of deja-vu
The PM is promising major change, but this is not the first time such ideas have been tried5 hours ago -
Politico - Politics
House Republicans unveil stopgap government funding plan
Ahead of the month-end deadline, House GOP leaders are tying a non-citizen voting bill to a six-month funding patch.5 days ago - Republican Party
More from The Guardian
-
The Guardian - World
Trump says he won’t participate in future debates as Harris says ‘we owe it to the voters to have another’ – live
Trump says he won’t debate Harris but claims he won the matchup; Harris tells North Carolina crowd that Americans should see another one. Harris heads to North Carolina as Trump says ‘there will ...12 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Putin: lifting Ukraine missile restrictions would put Nato ‘at war’ with Russia
Comments come after Antony Blinken hints US will lift restrictions on Kyiv’s use of weapons inside Russia. Vladimir Putin has said that a western move to let Kyiv use longer-range weapons against ...2 hours ago - Ukraine -
The Guardian - World
Israeli forces mischaracterised events leading to fatal shooting of US activist, says Washington Post
Protests in West Bank village had subsided half an hour before IDF shot Ayşenur Ezgi Eygi, says report. Israeli security forces mischaracterised the events that led up to the fatal shooting of a ...2 hours ago - Israel -
The Guardian - World
Entire Earth vibrated for nine days after climate-triggered mega-tsunami
Landslide in Greenland caused unprecedented seismic event that shows impact of global heating, say scientists. A landslide and mega-tsunami in Greenland in September 2023, triggered by the climate ...2 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Trial of French man for mass rape of wife could be postponed, judge says
Dominique Pélicot has been excused from court because of poor health and proceedings could be delayed if he remains ill for a long period. The trial of a French man accused of recruiting strangers ...4 hours ago