If AI can provide a better diagnosis than a doctor, what’s the prognosis for medics? | John Naughton

Studies in which ChatGPT outperformed scientists and GPs raise troubling questions for the future of professional work

AI means too many (different) things to too many people. We need better ways of talking – and thinking – about it. Cue, Drew Breunig, a gifted geek and cultural anthropologist, who has come up with a neat categorisation of the technology into three use cases: gods, interns and cogs.

“Gods”, in this sense, would be “super-intelligent, artificial entities that do things autonomously”. In other words, the AGI (artificial general intelligence) that OpenAI’s Sam Altman and his crowd are trying to build (at unconscionable expense), while at the same time warning that it could be an existential threat to humanity. AI gods are, Breunig says, the “human replacement use cases”. They require gigantic models and stupendous amounts of “compute”, water and electricity (not to mention the associated CO₂ emissions).

Topics

Better, faster, stronger? Tech titans’ obsession with turbocharged computer power could be our downfall | John Naughton

First there was Moore’s law, now the Nvidia boss has upped the ante. It’s all fuelling a dangerous conviction that everything can be solved by technology. In 2001 I interviewed the late Gordon ...
World - The Guardian - November 2
AI Will Understand Humans Better Than Humans Do

Or so says a controversial Stanford researcher, who finds that the latest systems have, against all odds, mastered a high-level cognitive skill.
Tech - Wired - November 1
Is AI better at planning and booking a vacation than you are?

Two CBS News correspondents conducted an experiment to see which was better at planning a trip — AI or a person. Here's what they found.
Top stories - CBS News - 5 days ago
China’s radar killer drone shoots better than AI, humans with new ChatGPT-like brain

World - Yahoo News - November 1
Tencent posts better-than-expected 47% profit surge as games, AI tools shine

Chinese gaming and social media giant Tencent on Wednesday reported profit above analysts' expectations, while revenue missed slightly.
Business - CNBC - November 13
What is ADHD, how do you get a diagnosis and can you only treat it with drugs? All your questions, answered by experts

Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder affects about 2.6 million people in the UK, yet misinformation about the condition is rife. Here we separate scientific fact from TikTok-fuelled fiction. ‘I ...
World - The Guardian - Yesterday
Elon Musk is not America’s new king. But he might be its new Thomas Cromwell | John Naughton

The billionaire was indispensable to Trump’s campaign and now has a senior job. He is about to become dangerously useful. Picture, if you will, the scene in Mar-a-Lago on election night at the ...
World - The Guardian - November 16
I’ve joined Bluesky and it feels like a breath of fresh air – in some ways… | John Naughton

The flourishing new platform may be like Twitter once was. The problem is the limited algorithmic scope of all social media. As I write, there’s a window on my laptop screen that is providing a ...
World - The Guardian - November 23
‘What can we do to make this better?’ Alec Baldwin film Rust finally premieres in Poland

First screening for troubled western whose cinematographer Halyna Hutchins was fatally shot on set takes place at niche film festival, boycotted by high-profile figures over a separate sexism row. ...
World - The Guardian - November 20

If AI can provide a better diagnosis than a doctor, what’s the prognosis for medics? | John Naughton

Topics

Related

Better, faster, stronger? Tech titans’ obsession with turbocharged computer power could be our downfall | John Naughton

AI Will Understand Humans Better Than Humans Do

Is AI better at planning and booking a vacation than you are?

China’s radar killer drone shoots better than AI, humans with new ChatGPT-like brain

Tencent posts better-than-expected 47% profit surge as games, AI tools shine

What is ADHD, how do you get a diagnosis and can you only treat it with drugs? All your questions, answered by experts

Elon Musk is not America’s new king. But he might be its new Thomas Cromwell | John Naughton

I’ve joined Bluesky and it feels like a breath of fresh air – in some ways… | John Naughton

‘What can we do to make this better?’ Alec Baldwin film Rust finally premieres in Poland

More from The Guardian

Syrian militants reach central Aleppo as government forces appear to retreat

Trump maintains hard line on Canada after meeting with Trudeau

‘We will fix our homes’: clean-up begins as Lebanon faces uncertain future

Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael in pole position to form new Irish government

Georgian president calls government illegitimate, claiming rigged election