How do we introduce assisted dying? Experts and politicians hope someone else has the answer | Gaby Hinsliff
Such a profound social change needs consensus and leadership. Those tasked with seeing this through are offering neither
There is something about the sound of Prof Sir Chris Whitty’s voice that inexorably takes me back. Whenever he speaks it’s hard not to think about R numbers and social distancing, masks and variants. His was the judgment we learned to trust in the days when the only certainty was that thousands were going to die; his the not-quite-inscrutable face we studied for clues that some politician had just said something stupid. For those reasons and more, I would very much like to know what the chief medical officer thinks about assisted dying for terminally ill people. But when he came before the committee scrutinising this most sensitive of issues on Wednesday, he wouldn’t say.
Whitty answered all questions posed about the proposed new law, including how accurately doctors can predict that someone has only six months left. (Not entirely, though he explained that they’re better at predicting that death will come in the foreseeable future – which seems more important here than whether it’s five, six or seven months exactly, though Whitty didn’t say the last part.) He wasn’t asked how well doctors can predict what that death might be like: how much pain or indignity it’s likely to involve, which might be equally hard to say but is what I’d want to know. (Some apply for assisted death without ever using the option, just to know it is there if needed.)
Gaby Hinsliff is a Guardian columnist
Continue reading...Topics
-
Here’s the Best Way to Tell If Someone Is Lying, According to 50 Experts
Listen carefully to what they actually say.Inc. - 22h -
Keep assisted dying laws simple, says Whitty
England's chief medical officer warns of "bureaucratic thicket" if safeguards made too complicated.BBC News - 2d -
Axel Rudakubana walked a long path to murder. At what point could he have been stopped? | Gaby Hinsliff
Arguments about evil risk distracting us from practical questions that could save lives in the future. Why? Why us, why here, why that day of all days; but most of all why our girls, our tiny ...The Guardian - Jan. 24 -
The nightmare begins. But by holding its nerve, the world can weather President Trump | Gaby Hinsliff
Globally, rightwing populists seem to be walking in his footsteps – but the UK is proof that that’s not inevitable. . The snow lay in drifts over the railway lines at Auschwitz, when Keir Starmer ...The Guardian - Jan. 20 -
An interesting speech full of hard truths? Kemi Badenoch is clearly rattled | Gaby Hinsliff
The Tory leader gave an address that was full of candour about her party’s failures. You can sense Nigel Farage’s delight. Well, finally. Only eight years on from kneecapping the economy and ...The Guardian - Jan. 17 -
AI Agents Are Here. How Much Should We Let Them Do?
WIRED’s advice columnist cracks open the publication’s archive to consider past promises about AI agents, and to get some advice on how we can use automation while retaining our humanity.Wired - Jan. 15 -
Loved ones mourn Kelyan Bokassa, the 14-year-old boy killed on a London bus. And we all have some thinking to do | Gaby Hinsliff
His mother says he was groomed by drug gangsters despite her attempts to get help. Let his death spark fresh debate about how we care for vulnerable people. The last time Mary Bokassa saw her ...The Guardian - Jan. 10 -
This is how we do it: ‘We don’t share the intimate details of the sex we have with other people’
Lachlan and Agnes are in an ethical non-monogamous relationship but get frustrated when couples exploit the concept as a tool for bad behaviour. How do you do it? Share the story of your sex ...The Guardian - Jan. 4 -
How do we tell our young daughter that she has a half-brother? | Ask Annalisa
You are right to bring this out into the open. Learning of a secret sibling is big news, so agree with your ex-partner on exactly what to share. • Every week Annalisa Barbieri addresses a problem ...The Guardian - Jan. 3
More from The Guardian
-
Washington DC plane crash live: flight data and cockpit voice recorders recovered, officials say
National Transportation Safety Board announces recorders are now at a lab for evaluation; operation to recover bodies continues. Full report: cockpit voice and flight data recorders ...The Guardian - 7m -
UN chief urges evacuation of 2,500 children from Gaza as doctors warn of ‘imminent risk’ of death
António Guterres issues call after saying he was ‘deeply moved’ by meeting with US doctors who worked in Gaza. See all our Middle East coverage UN secretary-general António Guterres has called ...The Guardian - 6h -
Nearly half of Danes see US as threat and 78% oppose Greenland sale, poll shows
Exclusive: More Danish people regard US as a threat than see North Korea or Iran as danger . Almost half of Danish people now consider the US to be a considerable threat to their country and the ...The Guardian - 4h -
‘A neural fossil’: human ears try to move when listening, scientists say
Researchers found that muscles move to orient ears toward sound source in vestigial reaction. Wiggling your ears might be more of a pub party piece than a survival skill, but humans still try to ...The Guardian - 4h -
Middle East crisis live: Israeli military hits Hezbollah targets in Bekaa Valley and on Syria-Lebanon border
Israel says it has hit targets including a facility used for weapons development and another related to arms smuggling. The US military says it killed a senior terrorist in Al-Qaeda’s Syria branch ...The Guardian - 12m
More in World
-
Washington DC plane crash live: flight data and cockpit voice recorders recovered, officials say
National Transportation Safety Board announces recorders are now at a lab for evaluation; operation to recover bodies continues. Full report: cockpit voice and flight data recorders ...The Guardian - 7m -
Women’s Ashes: Australia v England one-off cricket Test, day two – live
Updates as Australia build a strong lead at the MCG Any thoughts? Email James Sri Lanka v Australia: first men’s Test, day three – live 26th over: Australia 62-1 (Litchfield 21, Sutherland ...The Guardian - 7m -
Sri Lanka v Australia: first men’s cricket Test, day three – live
Updates from the third day of the first Test in Galle Any thoughts? Email Rob Australia v England: Women’s Ashes Test, day two – live 20th over: Sri Lanka 66-3 (Chandimal 26, Mendis 15) ...The Guardian - 9m -
Canada and Mexico brace for Trump tariffs on Saturday; UK house price growth slows – business live
Live, rolling coverage of business, economics and financial markets as US president said he would impose first tariffs of new administration on 1 February. Engine Capital’s lead investors, Arnaud ...The Guardian - 11m -
Middle East crisis live: Israeli military hits Hezbollah targets in Bekaa Valley and on Syria-Lebanon border
Israel says it has hit targets including a facility used for weapons development and another related to arms smuggling. The US military says it killed a senior terrorist in Al-Qaeda’s Syria branch ...The Guardian - 12m