By showing Musk’s unruly X the red card, Brazil has scored a goal for all democracies | John Naughton
A Brazilian justice ordering the platform to be blocked until it complies with state laws is a first among non-autocratic nations
At 10 minutes past midnight on 31 August, Elon Musk’s X (nee Twitter) went dark in Brazil, a country of more than 200 million souls, many of them enthusiastic users of online services. The day before, a supreme court justice, Alexandre de Moraes, had done something hitherto unthinkable: ordered the country’s ISPs to block access to the platform, threatened a daily fine of 50,000 Brazilian reis (just under £6,800) for users who bypassed the ban by using virtual private networks (VPNs) and froze the finances of Elon Musk’s Starlink internet service provider in the country. The order would remain in force until the platform complied with the decisions of the supreme federal court, paid fines totalling 18.3m reis (nearly £2.5m) and appointed a representative in Brazil, a legal requirement for foreign companies operating there. Moraes had also instructed Apple and Google to remove the X app and VPN software from their stores, but later reversed that decision, citing concerns about potential “unnecessary” disruptions.
Cue shock, horror, incredulity, outrage and all the reactions in between. Musk – who has been sparring with Moraes for quite a while – tweeted: “Free speech is the bedrock of democracy and an unelected pseudo-judge in Brazil is destroying it for political purposes.” The animosity between the two goes back to 8 January 2023, after the defeat of Jair Bolsonaro in the 2022 Brazilian presidential election, when a mob of his supporters attacked federal government buildings in the capital, Brasília. The mob invaded and caused deliberate damage to the supreme federal court, the national congress and the Planalto presidential palace in an abortive attempt to overthrow the democratically elected president, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.
Continue reading...Date: |
-
BBC News - Top stories
Elon Musk deletes X post about Harris and Biden
The tech tycoon has deleted the post about assassination attempts on the president and vice-president, saying it was a joke.Yesterday - Joe Biden -
BBC News - Top stories
Toto Schillaci and the Italia 90 goal-scoring run that fans will never forget
Salvatore Schillachi has died aged 59. The Italian icon spoke to BBC Sport about his life back in 2014.7 hours ago -
ESPN - Sports
Endrick showed 'courage' on 1st Madrid UCL goal
Carlo Ancelotti said Endrick "has balls" after the Real Madrid forward, 18, scored his first Champions League goal from distance -- despite having Vinicius Junior and Kylian Mbappé as passing options.8 hours ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
2024 Week 3 NFL score predictions, odds, picks today: Expert shares exact scores for all 16 games
SportsLine expert Eric Cohen reveals his score predictions for all 16 games in Week 3 of the NFL season4 hours ago - NFL -
GameSpot - Tech
Avatar: The Last Airbender Now Has A Deckbuilding Card Game
Avatar: The Last Airbender fans can pass the time waiting for Season 2 of Netflix's live-action adaptation by playing the latest game based on the hit Nickelodeon animated series. Avatar: The ...17 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Referee 'didn't like' Rice red card in Brighton draw
Premier League referee Chris Kavanagh says he "didn't like" Declan Rice's red card during Arsenal's draw with Brighton last month.10 hours ago -
The New York Times - World
Israel’s Pager Attack Has No Clear Strategic Goal, Analysts Say
By targeting so many pagers at the same time, Israel demonstrated technical prowess. But its long-term intent is unclear.4 hours ago - Israel -
CBS Sports - Sports
WATCH: USMNT star Christian Pulisic scores stellar goal for Milan vs. Liverpool in Champions League opener
A darting run down the right saw him finish low and to the far post against the Reds17 hours ago - UEFA Champions League -
ABC News - Sports
Harry Kane scores 4 goals in Bayern's 9-2 rout of Zagreb and breaks a record that Wayne Rooney held
Harry Kane has scored four goals as he broke a record set by Wayne Rooney for the most goals by an English player in the Champions League18 hours ago
More from The Guardian
-
The Guardian - World
Nine killed and hundreds injured in latest Lebanon blasts; Israel declares ‘new phase’ of war – Middle East live
Health ministry says at least 300 injured after walkie-talkies explode; Yoav Gallant does not mention explosions but praises Israel’s army and security agencies for ‘very impressive’ results. Local ...18 minutes ago -
The Guardian - World
‘Sophisticated evil’: Beirut medics and civilians horrified by pager attacks
People describe panic when explosions started and ‘apocalyptic’ scenes inside hospitals overwhelmed by injured patients. Middle East crisis – latest news updates Two beeps and a pause was the ...1 hour ago -
The Guardian - World
Hezbollah pagers: what do we know about how the attack happened?
What sources are saying about the techniques behind the simultaneous explosion of thousands of devices. Analysis: Exploding pager attack in Lebanon is another blow for US peace hopes In an ...3 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira: murder charge dropped against one of three suspects
Activists greet decision over killings of British journalist and Brazilian Indigenous expert with ‘indignation’. Appeal judges in Brazil yesterday upheld charges against only two of the three men ...2 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
More than 100 ex-Republican officials call Trump ‘unfit to serve’ and endorse Harris
In recent weeks, a handful of Republicans have crossed party lines to endorse Democratic presidential candidate. More than 100 Republican former national security and foreign policy officials on ...40 minutes ago - Donald Trump