Blame modern decisions, not just ancient history, for economic inequality | Torsten Bell
Black Americans whose ancestors were enslaved were still suffering a century later because they lived in states where Jim Crow laws were enforced
Persistence studies are all the rage in economics – using clever maths to show that events in the distant past drive political or economic outcomes today. One well-known example argued that Britain’s superior growth to France as late as 1800 was shaped by… the collapse of the western Roman empire a millennium before. Here, the collapse saw the population de-urbanise, while in France they remained in Roman-era towns that lasted. So when Britain’s cities re-emerged they were in places better suited to growth in the run-up to the Industrial Revolution.
Interesting stuff. But persistence studies also breed something dangerous: determinism. If ancient history is so influential, what hope do we have to shape our destiny? Which is why I love a new paper by Lukas Althoff and Hugo Reichardt, examining the lasting economic impact of slavery. Their findings look like the normal persistence story: black Americans whose ancestors were enslaved before the civil war have had significantly worse economic outcomes ever since, compared with black Americans whose forefathers were free – even in 2023, descendants of enslaved people had incomes $11,620 lower than other black Americans.
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a letter of up to 250 words to be considered for publication, email it to us at observer.letters@observer.co.uk
Continue reading...Date: |
-
The Wall Street Journal - World
China's Economic Indicators Point to Slowdown
China’s economic momentum slowed across the board in August, according to official data released Saturday, underscoring the need for further stimulus measures.2 days ago - China -
The New York Times - Top stories
Trump, Outrage and the Modern Era of Political Violence
The latest apparent assassination attempt against the former president indicates how much the American political landscape has been shaped by anger stirred by him and against him.59 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Yahoo News - World
Egyptologists find ancient sword possibly wielded against the mysterious ‘Sea Peoples’
4 hours ago -
CBS News - Politics
The history of voting by mail
The first votes of the 2024 election will be cast in the coming weeks, with mail-in ballots set to go out shortly. While the practice has seen a massive rise in popularity in recent years, it's ...19 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
McClellan defends Democrats' opposition to SAVE Act, calls it a 'modern poll tax'
Rep. Jennifer McClellan (D-Va.) defended Democrats’ opposition to the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility (SAVE) Act, calling it a “modern poll tax” in an interview on NewsNation’s “The Hill ...Yesterday -
CNBC - Business
China's local government debt problems are a hidden drag on economic growth
China's persistent consumption slowdown traces back to the country's real estate slump, and its deep ties to local government finances — and debt.16 hours ago - China -
Financial Times - Business
Jay Powell faces milestone moment for the US economy
Fed chair expected to begin lowering interest rates this week as inflation fears fade14 hours ago -
Financial Times - Business
Suspected Trump gunman sought — and failed — to help Ukraine fight Russia
Ryan Routh had travelled to Kyiv to volunteer after Moscow’s full-scale invasion in 20221 hour ago - Ukraine -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Oil Markets Remain Cautious Ahead of Fed Decision
Despite production halts in the Gulf of Mexico and disruptions in Libyan supplies adding to supply-side risks, front-month WTI prices still remain below the key threshold of $70 per barrel, ...10 hours ago - Federal Reserve -
ESPN - Sports
Ancelotti blames fixture list for Madrid injury woes
Carlo Ancelotti has blamed Real Madrid's busy fixture list for the series of injuries the team has suffered so far this season, with forward Brahim Díaz the latest player to be sidelined.30 minutes ago
More from The Guardian
-
The Guardian - World
Sheriff’s office shares video of suspect arrest; FBI says suspect spent 12 hours in tree line of Trump golf club – live
Video posted to Facebook shows the arrest of the man suspected in the apparent assassination attempt of Donald Trump; FBI releases details on manhunt. Suspect charged as Trump accuses Biden and ...19 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Death toll reaches 16 as ‘dramatic’ flooding in central Europe continues
Czech Republic, Poland and Austria fear worst may yet be to come as thousands are evacuated to higher ground. The death toll from torrential rain and flooding in central and eastern Europe has ...1 hour ago -
The Guardian - World
At least 16 killed in Israeli airstrikes on Gaza, Palestinian officials say
Five women and four children said to be among dead with strike hitting residential building in crowded Nuseirat camp. Middle East crisis – latest news updates At least 16 people have been ...2 hours ago - Israel -
The Guardian - World
French rape trial to resume after Dominique Pélicot health issues
Trial of retired electrician, 71, and 50 other men had been adjourned while he was taken to hospitals for tests. The trial of Dominique Pélicot and 50 other men accused of rape will resume on ...42 minutes ago - France -
The Guardian - World
More than 200 inmates escape Nigerian prison in aftermath of flooding
Prisoners fled when the walls of their jail collapsed in the country’s worst flooding in two decades. More than 200 inmates escaped from a prison in north-east Nigeria in the aftermath of the ...1 hour ago