An excess of billionaires is destabilising politics – just as academics predicted

Politicians have always courted the wealthy, but Elon Musk and co represent a new kind of donor, and an unprecedented danger to democracy

The concept of “elite overproduction” was developed by social scientist Peter Turchin around the turn of this century to describe something specific: too many rich people for not enough rich-person jobs. It’s a byproduct of inequality: a ton of poor people, sure, but also a superfluity of the wealthy, without enough positions to house them in the influence and status to which they think themselves entitled. In a modern context, that would mean senior positions in the government and civil service, along with the top tier of finance and law, but Turchin tested the hypothesis from ancient Rome to 19th-century Britain. The names and nature of the contested jobs and titles changed; the pattern remained. Turchin predicted in 2010 that by the 2020s it would be destabilising US politics.

In the UK in recent years the phrase has been repurposed in the wildest ways – to mean an excess of people at university creates unwanted activism (my précis); or, in the Economist (paraphrasing again), landslides create too many mediocre backbench MPs, who can’t hope for preferment so make trouble instead. And while the second proposition might be true, the first is basic anti-intellectualism. Turchin didn’t specify exactly how much wealth puts you in a situation with an overproduced elite, but he didn’t mean debt-laden students; he didn’t mean MPs; he meant, for brevity, billionaires or the top 1%. When a lot of your media are billionaire-owned, those media sources become endlessly inventive in taking the heat off billionaires, nipping criticism in the bud by pilfering its vocabulary and throwing it back at everyone.

Zoe Williams is a Guardian columnist

Topics

For billionaire Mark Cuban, luxury real estate in a prime location trumps politics
Business - MarketWatch - November 11
Steve Ballmer: the tech billionaire asking if voters want ‘just the facts’
World - Financial Times - November 2
Billionaires like Elon Musk don’t just think they’re better than the rest of us – they hate us | Zoe Williams
World - The Guardian - November 11
Here's how much Kamala Harris is worth — it isn't just from politics
Top stories - CBS News - November 4
JD Vance: 'We just witnessed the greatest political comeback in the history of the USA'
Top stories - NBC News - November 6
Nevada politics expert predicts Harris will eke out a win in the state
Politics - The Hill - November 5
Professors in Trouble Over Protests Wonder if Academic Freedom Is Dying
Top stories - The New York Times - October 23
American Catholic voters present complex opportunities for Trump, Harris: Academics
Top stories - ABC News - October 27
Trump just realigned the entire political map. Democrats have 'no easy path' to fix it.
Politics - NBC News - November 12

An excess of billionaires is destabilising politics – just as academics predicted

Topics

Related

For billionaire Mark Cuban, luxury real estate in a prime location trumps politics

Steve Ballmer: the tech billionaire asking if voters want ‘just the facts’

Billionaires like Elon Musk don’t just think they’re better than the rest of us – they hate us | Zoe Williams

Here's how much Kamala Harris is worth — it isn't just from politics

JD Vance: 'We just witnessed the greatest political comeback in the history of the USA'

Nevada politics expert predicts Harris will eke out a win in the state

Professors in Trouble Over Protests Wonder if Academic Freedom Is Dying

American Catholic voters present complex opportunities for Trump, Harris: Academics

Trump just realigned the entire political map. Democrats have 'no easy path' to fix it.

More from The Guardian

US and Israel reject ICC warrant for Netanyahu’s arrest – Middle East live

Police report details sexual assault allegations against Pete Hegseth

Ukraine claims Russia fired intercontinental ballistic missile at Dnipro

First close-up image of a star outside Milky Way shows supergiant in ‘cocoon’

British lawyer is fifth person to die in suspected methanol poisoning in Laos