West Virginia’s governor is latest politician to look deeply unserious after NCAA postseason snub
West Virginia was the biggest snub when it came to the 2025 men's NCAA basketball tournament. Despite being a staple of 220 out of 225 mock brackets across the college basketball pundit universe, the Mountaineers were left out of the 68-team tournament in favor of bubble teams like Texas and North Carolina.
This angered state lawmakers to no end, which created an opportunity. With a few performative press conferences, politicians could drum up support by railing against one of the easiest targets on the American landscape: the NCAA.
That's exactly what governor Patrick Morrisey and state attorney general JB McCuskey did Monday, less than 24 hours after West Virginia's frustrating exclusion.
West Virginia's governor Patrick Morrisey is now speaking.
— Pete Nakos (@PeteNakos_) March 17, 2025
The podium reads "National Corrupt Athletic Association" https://t.co/pFwtoS3y3cpic.twitter.com/WgzBUShZsb
This is weird, certainly, but not unpreceded. Let's talk about what we know so far.
Does West Virginia have a case?
About being included in the tournament? Yes. The Mountaineers were a staple of mock brackets after a 19-13 season. They won six games against Quadrant 1 competition, went 10-10 in Big 12 play and had three wins over AP Top 10 teams. ESPN expert Joe Lunardi had West Virginia included among the "Last Four Byes" in his final Bracketology post, slotting the team in as a 10 seed.
From a legal standpoint? Probably not. Good teams have been snubbed from the bracket in the past without threatening lawsuits. The most likely argument will be that the chairman of the selection committee, Bubba Cunningham, also serves as athletic director at the University of North Carolina. Even those Cunningham told CBS he'd recused himself from discussing the Tar Heels' bid when creating the final bracket, the crux of a West Virginia suit would revolve around proving bias and showing this was more than run-of-the-mill bad luck and mismanagement from the NCAA.
That will be difficult to definitively show. But given the NCAA's recent history of legal losses, it could be worth a shot.
Is West Virginia actually suing the NCAA?
So far, no. Morrisey and McCuskey's press conference threw around the word "corrupt" like an old time telegram uses the word "stop," but the pair didn't say they'd filed suit against the governing body of college athletics. Instead, the duo announced an investigation to “determine if any back room deals, corruption, bribes, or any nefarious activity occurred during the selection process.” That's all tough to prove, so the best case scenario here may be using public pressure to force the NCAA into a more transparent selection committee process.
Has anyone sued the NCAA over its selection practices before?
No, but Florida recently came close. Florida State was left out of 2023's four-team College Football Playoff despite a 13-0 record after starting quarterback Jordan Travis suffered a broken ankle at the end of the season. The university filed suit against its conference, the ACC, alleging mismanagement. Governor Ron DeSantis, pursuing the Republican nomination for U.S. President at the time, even proposed setting $1 million aside to cover the state's legal fees in case of a lawsuit against the NCAA. Nothing came of it.
Is this a problem for the NCAA?
Yes, but only in the way everything about the modern world is a problem for college sports' governing body. We've seen President Charlie Baker cave immediately to political pressure this year, following an executive order to exclude transgender athletes from competition. But that was on a federal level. West Virginia cannot force a similar amount of action, even with some specious lawsuits.
Furthermore, the NCAA's string of legal defeats have typically revolved around player eligibility and athlete compensation. West Virginia's complaint would have a tough time folding either into its overall case, even if Morrisey has taken on Baker's group before and won. Morrisey and McCuskey would have to prove demonstrable fraud here. Not even the NCAA is incompetent enough to take that risk.
Is this all a political stunt designed to bolster support behind West Virginia's elected officials?
I mean, we can't say for sure.
But yes.
This article originally appeared on For The Win: West Virginia's legal threat over March Madness snub, explained
-
West Virginia governor threatens legal action against NCAA after Mountaineers’ tournament snub
Governor Patrick Morrisey called the decision a 'miscarriage of justice.'Yahoo Sports - 10h -
West Virginia governor says he'll take legal action against NCAA over tournament snub
West Virginia Gov. Patrick Morrisey (R) on Monday said he will take legal action against the NCAA over West Virginia University’s (WVU) snub from the March Madness tournament. “I've asked Attorney ...The Hill - 8h -
West Virginia governor attacks NCAA ‘robbery’ after WVU excluded from March Madness
Patrick Morrisey orders state investigation into matter North Carolina selected over West Virginia West Virginia’s governor, Patrick Morrisey, said on Monday that the state will launch an ...The Guardian - 8h -
West Virginia governor calls for investigation over NCAA Tournament snub: 'Robbery at the highest levels'
West Virginia's political leadership says it wants answers and transparency after WVU missed the tourneyCBS Sports - 9h -
WVU snub 'robbery' at highest level, gov. says
West Virginia Gov. Patrick Morrisey wants his attorney general to investigate and work closely with the NCAA to ensure the men's tournament selection process is transparent and fair.ESPN - 24m -
Big 12 Commissioner Yormark offers statement on West Virginia snub
Brett Yormark is the latest that has offered up a statement on West Virginia being snubbed for the NCAA Tournament.Yahoo Sports - 12h -
NCAA Snapshot for the West Virginia basketball team
Looking at where the West Virginia basketball program sits in regards to a trip to the NCAA Tournament.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Rodriguez doesn't want soft in his West Virginia program
West Virginia head coach Rich Rodriguez believes that one of the worst four-letter words is soft. The head man demands toughness out of his players and it’s something that is instructed from the ...Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Darian DeVries releases statement following WVU's NCAA Tournament snub
West Virginia head coach Darian DeVries released a statement following his team being left out of the NCAA Tournament field on Sunday. The Mountaineers were the first team out of the NCAA ...Yahoo Sports - 1d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
Twins’ Royce Lewis will miss start of season after hurting his hamstring
Lewis is coming off a 2024 season that saw him appear in just 82 games due to quadriceps and adductor issues.Yahoo Sports - 6h -
Texans to pick up Derek Stingley's Jr.'s fifth-year option ahead of extension
The Houston Texans will have Derek Stingley Jr. under contract through 2029 after agreeing to pick up one final year on his rookie deal.Yahoo Sports - 9h -
MLB hyped up a video game-like replay view from the Tokyo Dome and fans justifiably hated it
The on-field replay did not go over how MLB expected.Yahoo Sports - 11h -
The Players Championship 2025 prize money: Full payout from the $25 million purse
Here's how the $25 million purse will be paid out this week at TPC Sawgrass in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Auburn basketball’s first round opponent revealed ahead of 2025 NCAA Tournament
Auburn basketball will face either Alabama State or St. Francis in March Madness to open its 2025 NCAA Tournament men’s bracket.Yahoo Sports - 1d
More in Sports
-
WVU snub 'robbery' at highest level, gov. says
West Virginia Gov. Patrick Morrisey wants his attorney general to investigate and work closely with the NCAA to ensure the men's tournament selection process is transparent and fair.ESPN - 24m -
NCAA Tournament 2025 bracket: Computer simulation predicts surprising upsets, March Madness picks, sleepers
When does the March Madness 2025 schedule start, and when are 2025 NCAA Tournament brackets due? The 2025 March Madness bracket begins on Thursday, March 20CBS Sports - 44m -
MLB's villains or its gold standard? How the Los Angeles Dodgers got here
Love them or loathe them, the defending champs built a new evil empire with a series of monumental moves.ESPN - 59m -
With Paul George out for the year, 76ers look ahead to NBA draft lottery with immense stakes for franchise
It all comes down to the ping pong balls now for Philadelphia, and the stakes have never been higherCBS Sports - 1h -
S. Alabama has NIT invite nixed: 'Unacceptable'
South Alabama had its invitation to the NIT rescinded after the Jaguars were informed they would be playing, a decision the coach called "unacceptable."ESPN - 1h