Steve Borthwick is here to stay – but issues need fixing for England to be World Cup contenders
Steve Borthwick, England’s head coach, will have mixed feelings about the almost-imminent British and Irish Lions tour to Australia. He will be pleased that his team’s second place in this year’s Six Nations will have bolstered the selection case for many of his charges. On the other hand, I am sure he would have preferred to have his entire squad available for England’s summer tour to Argentina.
In interviews after the 68–14, 10-try thrashing of a hapless Welsh side, Borthwick stressed that he had not been set a specific target by the RFU for the competition. A second-place finish, when viewed against a very difficult opening three rounds, would meet any reasonable benchmark, and this table position ensures Borthwick’s tenure to the World Cup. Results are sometimes seen as the only measure of success, but Borthwick can legitimately identify signs of improvement in several aspects of England’s performance.
Whilst acknowledging the tries left unscored against them by France and Scotland, England’s defence began to take shape during this tournament. The long periods in the second half against Scotland, where they successively drove the Scots away from the English tryline, were what ultimately enabled them to record the narrowest of victories. At times, they are still caught narrow off strike moves but their scramble defence never lacked in effort. Going forward, the challenge is to solidify the guard and bodyguard positions around the breakdown and make sure a sufficient number of players fold around rucks to ensure they are not left undermanned when they have to defend multiple-phase attacks.
England’s scrummaging has improved and that includes the crucial point of maintaining their performance when their front five are substituted. Fin Baxter and Joe Heyes deserve as much credit as the starting props, Ellis Genge and Will Stuart. The latter pair will now almost certainly be on the plane to Australia this summer.
Another conspicuous success over the contests has been their back row. There was no doubt, even before the start of the campaign, that England had sufficient depth here but what they showed was that the Curry twins can operate successfully as, effectively, twin opensides, without debilitating England’s ball-carrying threat up front. The challenge for the players and coaches is to match the periods where that option is best and when a larger player like Chandler Cunningham-South is preferable. Used properly, the flexibility to call on those alternatives and moving players like Ollie Chessum and George Martin back from the second row will pose different and difficult challenges for opposing teams and coaches.
Questions remain around England’s back three and centres, but the specific issues have changed and done so in Borthwick’s favour. Instead of struggling to identify prospective choices in the five positions, Borthwick has been able to see several new caps show that they deserve to be considered as possible longer-term selections.
When you consider that George Furbank, Immanuel Feyi-Waboso, Ollie Sleightholme, Ollie Lawrence and Henry Slade were not even in the England starting 23, you can see how Borthwick’s hand of cards has been improved. Tommy Freeman became the first England player to score tries in all five of the tournament’s games and the welcome decision for the coach is how does he make the most out of Freeman’s power and try-scoring instincts?
There are still two years before the 2027 World Cup in Australia, but that will go quickly, especially as Borthwick will not be able to experiment with some of the possible centre and back-three combinations this summer. It is always difficult to weigh the cases of longer-serving players like Slade and Lawrence against players who have only just arrived on the international stage, like Tom Roebuck and Fraser Dingwall.
It is better to have this conundrum than not; it would be a lot better to have four, rather than two, years to solve it. If you look at past World Cup-winning sides you will see that their various team units, and likely variations thereof, are nearly all settled about 18 months out from the start of the competition.
When it comes down to basics, little changes can make a big difference in Test-match rugby. Against decent teams there will be momentum swings, particularly when there are yellow cards. Each team has ebbs and flows in fortune and the key is simply to make more of your dominant periods. England still have to prove they are capable of doing that repeatedly at the very highest level.
This Six Nations showed they have resilience and the durability to score tries late in games. What they must now do is ensure that any negative spells do not last as long as the 35 minutes directly after half-time in the Ireland game during which they conceded 22 unanswered points.
-
Borthwick backs England players for Lions squad after rout of Wales
Coach believes many have boosted chances for Australia Borthwick says Maro Itoje is potential Lions captain Steve Borthwick believes several of his England players have enhanced their chances of ...The Guardian - 1d -
Farrell looks likely to overlook England coaches for his British Lions staff
Borthwick said backroom team not been approached Coaches set to miss out for second straight Lions tour Andy Farrell looks likely to overlook England’s assistants when selecting his British & ...The Guardian - 17h -
Steve Borthwick may use three fly-halves for Six Nations finale in Wales
England’s Fin Smith, Marcus Smith and Ford all in squad ‘Our aspiration is to win the tournament,’ says Borthwick Steve Borthwick is prepared to unleash his triple threat of No 10s ...The Guardian - 4d -
Steve Borthwick deserves huge credit for reacting to boos from England fans
You have to give Steve Borthwick credit for the way England have evolved during this Six Nations. Controlling contact is key and if you are on the front foot then it is a different ball game, and ...Yahoo Sports - 1d -
British and Irish Lions tour 2025: Team news, fixtures and venues
Every four years, a British and Irish Lions tour is still seen by many as the peak of professional rugby, with the finest players from England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland joining forces.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Wales v England, Six Nations 2025: What time is today’s kick-off and what TV channel is it on?
England play Wales at the Principality Stadium in their final game of the 2025 Six Nations Championship. Steve Borthwick’s team have an outside chance of winning the tournament.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Andy Farrell to take Simon Easterby on Lions tour as part of Irish-dominated coaching team
Andy Farrell is set to appoint Simon Easterby to an Ireland-dominated Lions coaching team, Telegraph Sport understands, with no England assistants likely to make the tour to Australia.Yahoo Sports - 14h -
Six Nations review: France saves Galthié, England has mojo back and aging Ireland squad
The debrief: Murmurings about whether Fabien Galthié was the right coach to lead the team to the 2027 Rugby World Cup have been silenced after he delivered the second Six Nations title on his ...Yahoo Sports - 6h -
'I have not seen that complete an England performance for years'
In his BBC Sport column, World Cup winner Matt Dawson reflects on England's huge Six Nations win over Wales, their entire Six Nations campaign and why Maro Itoje is a Lions captain in waiting.BBC News - 21h
More from Yahoo Sports
-
Power rankings Big Ten basketball teams entering March Madness: Who is set for a deep run?
After Sunday's conclusion of the conference tournament, here are the Big Ten teams in the best shape entering March MadnessYahoo Sports - 13m -
Power rankings Big Ten basketball teams entering March Madness: Who is set for a deep run?
After Sunday's conclusion of the conference tournament, here are the Big Ten teams in the best shape entering March MadnessYahoo Sports - 13m -
Kyler Murray: I know we're headed in the right direction
Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray has taken some time to connect with his heritage this offseason, but his life in the NFL was never far from his mind.Yahoo Sports - 13m -
Kyler Murray: I know we're headed in the right direction
Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray has taken some time to connect with his heritage this offseason, but his life in the NFL was never far from his mind.Yahoo Sports - 13m -
Former LSU football star Ja'Marr Chase signs historic contract extension
Ja'Marr Chase signed a record-setting contract extension with the Cincinnati Bengals, keeping him with former LSU teammate Joe BurrowYahoo Sports - 14m
More in Sports
-
Power rankings Big Ten basketball teams entering March Madness: Who is set for a deep run?
After Sunday's conclusion of the conference tournament, here are the Big Ten teams in the best shape entering March MadnessYahoo Sports - 13m -
Power rankings Big Ten basketball teams entering March Madness: Who is set for a deep run?
After Sunday's conclusion of the conference tournament, here are the Big Ten teams in the best shape entering March MadnessYahoo Sports - 13m -
Kyler Murray: I know we're headed in the right direction
Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray has taken some time to connect with his heritage this offseason, but his life in the NFL was never far from his mind.Yahoo Sports - 13m -
Kyler Murray: I know we're headed in the right direction
Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray has taken some time to connect with his heritage this offseason, but his life in the NFL was never far from his mind.Yahoo Sports - 13m -
Former LSU football star Ja'Marr Chase signs historic contract extension
Ja'Marr Chase signed a record-setting contract extension with the Cincinnati Bengals, keeping him with former LSU teammate Joe BurrowYahoo Sports - 14m