March Madness 2025: Chalk has ruled the NCAA tournament so far. Is that a blip or a sign of the times?
So far, March hasn’t been mad at all.
The underdogs have underachieved. The longshots have misfired. The giant killers have been swatted aside.
Top-four seeds clinched a perfect 16-0 record in the first round of the men’s NCAA tournament this year when Michigan State routed Bryant late Friday night. This is only the sixth time that’s happened since the NCAA tournament expanded to 64 teams, joining 1994, 2000, 2004, 2007 and most recently 2017.
The average margin of victory for top-four seeds on Thursday and Friday was a ridiculous 22.6 points. More than half the No. 13, 14, 15 and 16 seeds in the field lost by 20-plus points. None came within closer than nine points of pulling an upset.
Norfolk State coach Robert Jones insisted he was “angry” oddsmakers anointed his team a 28.5-point underdog against top-seeded Florida. The Spartans trailed by as many as 32 points before halftime.
Akron guard Seth Wilson emphasized that the Zips would play with “no fear” against Arizona because they “can compete with anybody.” The fourth-seeded Wildcats cruised to a 28-point victory.
High Point, Yale and Grand Canyon were each popular 13-versus-4 upset picks. None led after the opening 10 minutes.
That college basketball’s top tier has been dominant is not a total shock to those who pay close attention to predictive metrics. Based on pre-NCAA tournament adjusted efficiency margins, the 2025 NCAA tournament has maybe the strongest quartet of No. 1 seeds in recent history. That same metric suggested that the gap between teams seeded on the top four lines and teams seeded 13 or worse was among the largest ever.
Why have this year’s top-four seeds been so dominant? The knee-jerk answer is to point to college basketball’s changing landscape.
The proliferation of NIL money and the lack of penalty for transferring are funneling mid-major stars to high-major programs. Last offseason, the most coveted transfers were receiving pay-to-play NIL deals in the high six figures and low seven figures. The money flying around this spring could be even more lucrative.
There’s also the fact that most mid-majors don’t have the advantage of being older than high-majors anymore. With the exception of Duke, high-majors are building around upperclassmen and grad transfers far more than one-and-done freshmen.
And yet blaming the changing landscape ignores that the transfer portal works both ways. There’s no shortage of mid-major programs who have benefited by identifying high-major talent in search of more playing time or a fresh start.
Scan Will Wade’s roster at McNeese to see how an opportunistic mid-major can flourish under the current rules. The Cowboys' two leading scorers in their upset victory over Clemson on Thursday were transfers from Syracuse and Ole Miss, respectively.
The truth is we don’t know why college basketball’s upper echelon has been dominant during the regular season and so far in the NCAA tournament.
It might be a one-year blip. It might be the start of a trend.
All we know for sure is the impact it’s had so far on this NCAA tournament: March Madness has been March Mehness.
Half the remaining teams in the field are from the Big Ten or the SEC. Ten more are from the remaining power conferences.
Let’s hope a dull first round gives way to fireworks over the weekend.
Topics
-
No. 16 seed William & Mary beats High Point, makes history with first NCAA tournament win
William & Mary has a losing record, has never been in the NCAA tournament - men's or women's - and just won its first March madness game.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
NCAA Tournament 2025 bracket picks, Cinderella teams, top upsets: Model simulates March Madness 10K times
SportsLine's college basketball model has called 24 first-round NCAA Tournament upsets by double-digit seedsCBS Sports - 1d -
March Madness bracket 2025: NCAA tournament first round schedule
The 68-team NCAA tournament field is set. Here's the 2025 March Madness first round schedule, including First Four and all four regions.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
March Madness bracket revealed for 2025 NCAA women's tournament: UCLA takes top seed over South Carolina
The Bruins are the top seed in the NCAA tournament for the first time in history.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
Here are the teams moving on into the round of 32 so far at the NCAA men’s basketball tournament
March Madness is well and truly under way.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Men's March Madness by the numbers: No. 16 seeds are 2-154. So, yes, we're saying there's a chance
The first two days of the NCAA Tournament are for the little guys. Teams from under-the-radar conferences that have rarely, if ever, experienced March Madness get to test themselves against the ...Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Men's March Madness second round schedule: NCAA Tournament times, TV for Sunday
The final half of the men's NCAA Tournament second round schedule is set as the first weekend of March Madness wraps up.Yahoo Sports - 6h -
March Madness upsets continue as Colorado State tops Memphis in men's NCAA Tournament
Another double-digit seed has advanced in the NCAA men's tournament. No. 12 Colorado State knocked off Memphis in their first-round game in Seattle.Yahoo Sports - 15h -
March Madness first round predictions: NCAA bracket picks for every men’s game
Who will win 2025 NCAA Tournament bracket? Our best men’s March Madness first round predictions are in.Yahoo Sports - 1d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
Lewis Hamilton wins Chinese GP sprint and hits out at ‘yapping’ critics
Lewis Hamilton hit out at “yapping critics” after claiming the first win of his Ferrari career in Saturday’s sprint race in China.Yahoo Sports - 15m -
Brotherly Bond: The Duprey’s have a legacy that continues today
PERU — When you come into Peru Central School, you see the faces of many former athletes who were elected to the school’s Hall of Fame. A common name you’ll see is Duprey, with eight brothers ...Yahoo Sports - 23m -
Brotherly Bond: The Duprey’s have a legacy that continues today
PERU — When you come into Peru Central School, you see the faces of many former athletes who were elected to the school’s Hall of Fame. A common name you’ll see is Duprey, with eight brothers ...Yahoo Sports - 23m -
Breaking down Colts picks in latest 4-round 2025 NFL mock draft
Let's break down the Colts' picks in Chad Reuter's latest four-round 2025 NFL mock draft.Yahoo Sports - 23m -
Breaking down Colts picks in latest 4-round 2025 NFL mock draft
Let's break down the Colts' picks in Chad Reuter's latest four-round 2025 NFL mock draft.Yahoo Sports - 23m
More in Sports
-
NHL playoff watch: What's at stake in all 14 games on Showdown Saturday
Here's what to watch in every matchup. Plus, full playoff projections, draft lottery standings and more.ESPN - 8m -
NHL playoff watch: What's at stake in all 14 games on Showdown Saturday
Here's what to watch in every matchup. Plus, full playoff projections, draft lottery standings and more.ESPN - 8m -
It wasn't his behavior, but this Stanford program belongs to Andrew Luck
Right now, all of Stanford's trust is in Luck. It's his program now, and that means Troy Taylor is his coach.ESPN - 9m -
It wasn't his behavior, but this Stanford program belongs to Andrew Luck
Right now, all of Stanford's trust is in Luck. It's his program now, and that means Troy Taylor is his coach.ESPN - 9m -
All-Star to architect: Buster Posey's plan to rebuild the Giants
The future Hall of Fame catcher turned president of baseball operations has a vision.ESPN - 14m