How Louisville and Kentucky basketball experience compare to recent NCAA Tournament teams
Since the transfer portal opened in October 2018, college basketball’s top teams have skewed older.
Former U of L and current St. John’s coach Rick Pitino said last month he does not plan to sign any freshmen this recruiting cycle, citing the changing landscape of college basketball. The compounding effects of NIL and the transfer portal remind him of his Euroleague days, where one-year contracts were a common occurrence. He aims to replace experience with experience.
“We’re not recruiting any high school basketball players,” Pitino said. “Because we’re losing Deivon (Smith), Kadary (Richmond) and Aaron (Smith). You can’t replace them with high school kids.”
While not quite as extreme, Pat Kelsey and Mark Pope have also modified their recruiting ideologies to reflect this trend.
They assembled rosters brimming with experience in hopes of immediate postseason success at Louisville and Kentucky. Both squads are top-10 in KenPom’s 2024-25 experience rankings (U of L No. 5 with a score of 3.17; UK No. 7 with a score of 3.09). In 2023-24, Louisville ranked 307th with a score of 1.07, while Kentucky ranked 196th with a score of 1.76.
Experience isn’t everything when it comes to making a deep NCAA Tournament run, of course. But it certainly doesn’t hurt.
Freshmen-led teams haven’t had a ton of success in March over the last decade or so. Duke did it in 2015 (and will look to do it again with Cooper Flagg). Kentucky made it happen with Anthony Davis, Michael Kidd-Gilchrist and Marquis Teague in 2012. Since then, COVID-19 super seniors and the transfer portal have changed the way coaches construct their rosters.
Here’s a look at how Louisville’s and Kentucky’s experienced squads compare with successful NCAA Tournament teams in recent years:
NCAA champions KenPom experience ratings
Because the NCAA Tournament was canceled in 2020, no teams from that season are listed below.
Transfer portal era (2019-24)
- 2018-19 Virginia - 1.74
- 2020-21 Baylor - 2.55
- 2021-2022 Kansas - 2.10
- 2022-23 UConn - 2.25
- 2023-24 UConn - 2.43
Pre transfer portal (2014-18)
- 2013-14 UConn - 2.49
- 2014-15 Duke - 1.28
- 2015-16 Villanova - 1.96
- 2016-17 North Carolina - 1.87
- 2017-18 Villanova - 1.80
Sweet 16 experience in transfer portal era compared to U of L, UK
Because the NCAA Tournament was canceled in 2020, no teams from that season are listed below.
2019
- Tennessee - 2.28 (15th)
- Gonzaga - 2.25 (20th)
- Louisville - 2.18 (29th), eliminated in first round
- Virginia Tech - 2.16 (34th)
- Auburn - 1.97 (65th)
- Florida State - 1.93 (76th)
- Texas Tech - 1.83 (90th)
- Virginia - 1.74 (107th)*
- Michigan State - 1.70 (119th)
- North Carolina - 1.65 (127th)
- Houston - 1.56 (151st)
- Oregon - 1.54 (158th)
- Purdue - 1.49 (176th)
- Michigan - 1.13 (265th)
- Kentucky - 1.03 (298th), eliminated in Elite Eight
- LSU - 0.99 (303rd)
- Duke - 0.33 (351st)
*NCAA champion
2021
- Creighton - 2.60 (5th)
- Baylor - 2.55 (7th)*
- Michigan - 2.44 (12th)
- Oregon - 2.42 (13th)
- Loyola Chicago - 2.26 (25th)
- Villanova - 2.09 (50th)
- Arkansas - 2.01 (70th)
- Gonzaga - 1.97 (75th)
- Alabama - 1.97 (77th)
- Southern Cal - 1.95 (80th)
- Houston - 1.95 (81st)
- Syracuse - 1.92 (86th)
- Oregon State - 1.86 (97th)
- UCLA - 1.56 (179th)
- Louisville - 1.42 (214th), did not make NCAA Tournament
- Florida State - 1.39 (219th)
- Oral Roberts - 1.27 (245th)
- Kentucky - 1.19 (264th), did not make NCAA Tournament
*NCAA champion
2022
- Providence - 2.75 (7th)
- Texas Tech - 2.48 (34th)
- Villanova - 2.42 (48th)
- Arkansas - 2.32 (70th)
- Houston - 2.25 (87th)
- Iowa State - 2.21 (95th)
- UCLA - 2.21 (96th)
- Louisville - 2.17 (107th), did not make NCAA Tournament
- Kansas - 2.10 (128th)*
- Miami - 2.03 (147th)
- Saint Peter’s - 1.89 (176th)
- Kentucky - 1.87 (186th), eliminated in first round
- Purdue - 1.78 (209th)
- North Carolina - 1.76 (212th)
- Gonzaga - 1.57 (259th)
- Michigan - 1.40 (296th)
- Arizona - 1.34 (306th)
- Duke - 0.96 (347th)
*NCAA champion
2023
- Texas - 3.36 (6th)
- Xavier - 2.99 (16th)
- San Diego State - 2.96 (21st)
- Miami - 2.90 (27th)
- Kansas State - 2.81 (30th)
- Gonzaga - 2.64 (44th)
- UCLA - 2.29 (106th)
- UConn - 2.25 (113th)*
- Kentucky - 2.23 (118th), eliminated in second round
- Tennessee - 2.19 (131st)
- Michigan State - 2.14 (138th)
- Florida Atlantic - 2.09 (148th)
- Creighton - 2.05 (155th)
- Alabama - 1.54 (257th)
- Houston - 1.54 (258th)
- Arkansas - 1.52 (263rd)
- Princeton - 1.13 (312th)
- Louisville - 0.90 (336th), did not make NCAA Tournament
*NCAA champion
2024
- North Carolina - 3.23 (6th)
- Creighton - 3.16 (8th)
- Illinois - 3.11 (11th)
- N.C. State - 3.05 (14th)
- Clemson - 2.81 (25th)
- Tennessee - 2.76 (29th)
- San Diego State - 2.57 (44th)
- Alabama - 2.49 (60th)
- Purdue - 2.44 (67th)
- UConn - 2.43 (68th)*
- Arizona - 2.36 (81st)
- Houston - 2.27 (92nd)
- Iowa State - 2.11 (123rd)
- Gonzaga - 2.06 (131st)
- Marquette - 2.04 (137th)
- Kentucky - 1.76 (196th), eliminated in first round
- Duke - 1.76 (197th)
- Louisville - 1.07 (307th), did not make NCAA Tournament
*NCAA champion
Reach college sports enterprise reporter Payton Titus at ptitus@gannett.com, and follow her on X @petitus25.
This article originally appeared on Louisville Courier Journal: Louisville basketball, Kentucky: NCAA Tournament transfer portal era
Topics
-
How Louisville, Kentucky baseball spending compares with national powers, CWS teams
How does Louisville, UK baseball spending compare with other top programs? How much do they spend on their teams? How much do they pay head coaches?Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Kentucky good with NCAA draw, Louisville not so much
Selection Sunday left the teams-coaches of greatest interest to us here in the Bluegrass with some mixed feelings as the NCAA Tournament draw was revealed. Kentucky as a three seed has a path in ...Yahoo Sports - 5h -
Comparing the West Virginia resume to the bubble
As of today West Virginia is still included in the NCAA Tournament field and perched around 10-12 depending on the bracket.We examine some of the other teams on the bubble to see how the resumes ...Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Nebraska to play Louisville in NCAA Tournament
The Nebraska women's basketball team is taking part in March Madness. The Cornhuskers will play the Louisville Cardinals in Friday's first round.Yahoo Sports - 5h -
Mark Pope's first season with Kentucky basketball will be defined by 1 thing: NCAA success
Mark Pope's first season guiding Kentucky, his alma mater, always will be viewed through the prism of how the Wildcats fare in the NCAA Tournament.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
How does Louisville basketball stack up vs Duke in ACC Tournament championship?
How do Louisville and Duke stack up in the ACC Tournament championship? Both teams have changed a lot since they last met back in December.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
How to buy Kentucky women’s basketball tickets for 2025 March Madness
Want to buy tickets for the Kentucky women’s basketball NCAA Tournament 2025 opener vs. Liberty? Here’s how, including prices for March Madness.Yahoo Sports - 13h -
Why was Kentucky basketball freshman Trent Noah missing from NCAA Tournament watch party?
Kentucky basketball freshman forward Trent Noah wasn't in attendance for the team's NCAA Tournament watch party Sunday. Why was Noah absent from it?Yahoo Sports - 14h -
Kentucky basketball can't hang with Alabama in SEC Tournament quarterfinal, awaits NCAA bid
Mark Pope's short-handed Kentucky basketball team was routed by Alabama on Friday in an SEC Tournament quarterfinal in Nashville.Yahoo Sports - 2d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
Yahoo Fantasy Plus identifies 3 of 2025's safest starting pitchers — should you draft them at ADP?
The Fantasy Plus Experts Consensus model has identified three of the safest starting pitchers to project. Scott Pianowski reveals if he’s in or out on each player at ADP.Yahoo Sports - 8m -
Players Championship three-hole playoff: How Rory McIlroy beat J.J. Spaun, shot-by-shot
The three-hole playoff in The Players Championship, shot-by-shot, won by Rory McIlroy.Yahoo Sports - 8m -
Argentina Superstar ‘Carries’ Inter Milan On His Shoulders In Precious Atalanta Win
Lautaro Martinez led by example in Inter Milan’s dominant 2-0 away Serie A win against fellow title rivals Atalanta.According to Tuttosport via TWM, the goal in the dying moments put the icing on ...Yahoo Sports - 9m -
3 Patriots free agents still remain unsigned
The New England Patriots have three in-house free agents that have yet to be signed by another team.Yahoo Sports - 9m -
Did Xavier make March Madness? Musketeers in First Four games of 2025 NCAA Tournament
Did Xavier basketball get into March Madness on Sunday during the NCAA Tournament Selection Sunday bracket reveal show? Here's what to know:Yahoo Sports - 10m
More in Sports
-
2025 NFL free agency: Giants, Jameis Winston to meet Tuesday as team awaits Aaron Rodgers decision, per report
The Giants are visiting with multiple signal-callers as the Rodgers wait continuesCBS Sports - 2m -
2025 NFL Draft: Ranking every position group with defensive tackles at the top
What position is the deepest in the 2025 draft?CBS Sports - 5m -
Colleges with best football, men's basketball coach tandems: Kansas, Alabama in tight race for No. 1 spot
Kalen DeBoer, Nate Oats and the Crimson Tide are rising fast as the Jayhawks aim to secure their top billingCBS Sports - 5m -
Boston NWSL expansion team to change name, months after revealing Bos Nation FC branding
The Boston NWSL team is expected to begin play in 2026CBS Sports - 5m -
Yahoo Fantasy Plus identifies 3 of 2025's safest starting pitchers — should you draft them at ADP?
The Fantasy Plus Experts Consensus model has identified three of the safest starting pitchers to project. Scott Pianowski reveals if he’s in or out on each player at ADP.Yahoo Sports - 8m