English cricket has fallen out of love with the IPL

Harry Brook in action for Sunrisers Hyderabad in 2023 — Harry Brook has been handed a two-year ban from the IPL - AFP/Dibyangshu Sarkar

When the Indian Premier League begins on Saturday, the competition will lack a hallmark of recent years: a conspicuous English flavour. While 10 England players will still feature in the competition, this is the smallest number for eight years. For various reasons, Joe Root, Ben Stokes, Mark Wood and Ben Duckett are all absent from this year’s IPL.

Harry Brook will be missing too, and not only this year. Earlier this month, Brook withdrew from his £590,000-a-year contract with Delhi Capitals. He has been met with a two-year ban from the IPL for the withdrawal, meaning that Brook cannot play in the competition until 2028.

The Brook affair embodies how English cricket’s dealings with the IPL are now in a new era. This relationship has now entered a distinct third phase – each doubling as a snapshot of English cricket’s wider priorities and attitudes to India at the time.

2008-2014: English exceptionalism

When it was launched in 2008, the IPL instantly destroyed English cricket’s traditional dominance of the northern hemisphere summer months. England’s first Tests of the summer now routinely clashed with the IPL. International players who had once considered county cricket could now earn far more money for far less work in the IPL instead.

While other Test nations allowed their players to enjoy the financial and sporting benefits of appearing in the IPL, England took a more draconian approach. In 2008, the the England & Wales Cricket Board did not permit centrally contracted players to appear in the IPL. Only one Englishman, limited-overs specialist Dimitri Mascarenhas, appeared in the first season; even then, his county only allowed him to go for two weeks.

Distrust for the IPL also led to one of English cricket’s most humiliating affairs. Less than two months after the IPL began, Giles Clarke welcomed Allen Stanford and his helicopter – stuffed with counterfeit dollar bills – onto the Lord’s outfield.

Allen Stanford lands his helicopter on the hallowed Lord's outfield — Allen Stanford landed his helicopter on the hallowed Lord’s outfield - Action Images/John Marsh

Stanford promised an annual $20 million winner-takes-all match against England. The ECB saw this offer as a way to allow centrally contracted cricketers to enjoy IPL-level riches without actually playing in the tournament. Instead, England were thrashed by 10 wickets in the 20/20 for 20 match at Stanford’s private ground in Antigua in November 2008. Three months later, Stanford was sentenced to 110 years imprisonment for fraud in the US.

Allen Stanford stands in front of a box containing €20 million — Stanford (centre) promised an annual $20 million winner-takes-all match against England - AP/Lefteris Pitarakis

The Stanford affair intensified English debates about the IPL. In 2009, the ECB allowed centrally contracted players to appear in the first three weeks of the tournament. Kevin Pietersen was injured midway through the 2009 Ashes summer; his achilles problem was in part blamed on his IPL involvement.

In 2010, England briefly changed their approach to the IPL, viewing it as preparation for the T20 World Cup. Captain Paul Collingwood, one of eight Englishmen in that season’s tournament, credited the IPL as vital to England winning the T20 World Cup.

Yet England’s haughty attitude to the IPL swiftly returned. When he tried to convince Test captain Andrew Strauss of the merits of playing in the IPL, Pietersen likened the experience to “speaking to the vicar about gangster rap”.

England’s refusal to allow Pietersen to play a full part in the IPL led to the internecine conflict between cricketer and country. The upshot was first Pietersen’s estrangement from the side, then his sacking in 2014. Eoin Morgan, one of England’s few IPL regulars, observed a “taboo” around playing in the tournament. Pietersen was the lone Englishman to play in the 2014 IPL.

Kevin Pietersen with Royal Challengers Bangalore — Kevin Pietersen’s decision to play in the IPL led to his estrangement from the England side - Getty Images/Tom Shaw

England didn’t merely discourage players from appearing in the IPL. They were also contemptuous about performances in the competition, seeing no relevance for international selection, ignoring how the IPL was the highest-standard domestic league in the world. Owais Shah enjoyed a fine 2012 season for Delhi, scoring 340 runs – the most by any Englishmen in the IPL’s first five seasons – at an average of 37.8. Even with a T20 World Cup in Sri Lanka later that year, Shah was still not recalled by England.

2015-23: The warm embrace

When England played their first game after the 2015 World Cup, in Dublin, their captain, Morgan, was 5,000 miles away. Morgan was playing for Sunrisers Hyderabad instead. Strauss, now England’s director of cricket, gave Morgan permission to miss the game to play in the IPL, recognising the value of the competition. In the 2015 ODI World Cup, 38 out of the 44 players to appear in the semi-finals had IPL experience. England’s squad during that abject campaign had just two.

As England targeted the 2019 ODI World Cup, the IPL moved from inconvenience to indispensable. Where once the ECB had dissuaded players from appearing in the competition, now England actively paid players to do so. In 2016, Sam Billings was signed by Delhi, but, when taking into account the payments he made Kent for missing county cricket, Billings was losing money. Strauss decided to use the ECB’s cash to reimburse Billings.

After England’s surprise run to the 2016 T20 World Cup final, franchises courted Englishmen. From just four English players appearing in the 2015 IPL, eight were signed in 2017, and 13 in 2018. Jofra Archer’s IPL pedigree led England to fast-track him into the side for the 2019 World Cup. The triumph vindicated England’s warm IPL embrace.

Jofra Archer celebrates taking a wicket for Rajasthan Royals — England benefitted from Jofra Archer playing in the IPL - Ron Gaunt

England even changed their schedule to be more welcoming to the IPL, shifting the first Test of the summer from May to June. Freeing players to play most, or all, of an IPL season – the same request that had led to Pietersen being ostracised – ensured that English players were as attractive as possible to franchises. The ECB’s attitude contrasted with that of individual counties, who often attempted to stop players from signing late IPL deals and missing domestic games. Financial realities meant that such resistance had little effect.

In 2023, a record 17 Englishmen played in the IPL, with the competition doubling as Ashes preparation. The ECB even spoke of working with Mumbai Indians’ sports science team to help Archer make a full return to fitness. After running the drinks for Rajasthan Royals, rather than playing in the County Championship, Root scored a sparkling hundred on the first day of the Ashes series.

2024 – present: A new cooling

Brook’s withdrawal, to Delhi’s great chagrin, leaves the English contingent in this season’s IPL as the smallest since 2017. This new phase in England’s relationship with the IPL is not a return to the early years of distrust, but it is also distinct from the 2015-23 embrace. England’s new attitude falls roughly between these positions.

Where the ECB once encouraged players to appear in the IPL, now they are more agnostic. Under Stokes and Brendon McCullum, the Test side has emphatically regained its position of primacy within English cricket. There is also a sense that the IPL’s relevance to ODI cricket has diminished. Changes since the 2019 World Cup – the new white balls swinging more, and the increase in run rates in Test cricket – mean that ODIs now resemble Test matches more closely than T20s.

The introduction of multi-year central contracts, beginning in 2023, has given English stars greater financial security and encouraged more long-term thinking. The three major leagues that launched in 2023 – in South Africa, the UAE and the USA – give players alternatives to the IPL that, while not quite as lucrative, entail spending less time away from home. The Hundred now pays more too: Brook will earn £207,000 for captaining Northern Superchargers this summer. And, while they would be loath to admit it publicly, some players have tired of India, after three England visits to the country in 18 months.

The recent convergence between England’s red and white-ball sides has rendered the international schedule even more relentless for leading players. The chance to recuperate, rather than play in the IPL, is increasingly attractive. Of the 10 Englishmen in this year’s IPL, only two – Jacob Bethell and Archer – are strong candidates to play Test cricket in the coming year. England players who still crave IPL contracts are victims of the national team’s dwindling white-ball performances, rendering them less attractive to franchises.

And so, for now, England’s approach to the IPL has rebalanced. While most fans will welcome the change, which reflects how international cricket has been re-prioritised, this new equilibrium might not endure.

IPL salaries are certain to hike in time, with players still earning a far lower percentage of revenue than in other major sports leagues. Indian investors in Hundred teams might pressurise English players to be available for the IPL. If the national team flounder in next year’s T20 World Cup, in India and Sri Lanka, then an old argument will also return: that England need more exposure to the world’s best domestic league.

Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.

Topics

Cricketer 'victimised' for speaking out on racism, report says

Majid Haq says he has faced abuse in the three years since speaking out about racism in cricket.
BBC News - Mar. 13
Wetzel: Why the sky has not fallen in NCAA hoops

Amid changes and dire predictions about college hoops, top coaches in the game seem to have figured it out.
ESPN - 21h
Warner tells English fans to 'boo me' this summer

Former Australia batter David Warner says he would welcome English cricket fans booing him during The Hundred this summer.
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 14
Derbyshire people fight to save ruined manor that held Mary, Queen of Scots

Wingfield Manor is part-managed by English Heritage, but has fallen into a state of disrepair. At various points in history it has been a prison for Mary, Queen of Scots, a battleground in the ...
The Guardian - Mar. 9
‘It’s so exciting to be in on this’: why Chelsea owners bought into the Hundred

Jonathan Goldstein, who with Todd Boehly spent £40m to buy half of Trent Rockets, says English cricket has been ‘significantly underexploited’ until now. As a man who has negotiated with Roman ...
The Guardian - Mar. 8
Court convicts thief who stole golden toilet from English palace

A thief who swiped a golden toilet from an English palace has been convicted along with an accomplice who helped cash in on the spoils of the 18-carat work of art valued at more than $6 million
ABC News - 2d
Man who stole 18-carat golden toilet from English palace convicted

A thief who stole a golden toilet worth over $6 million from an English palace has been convicted, along with an accomplice in the 2019 heist.
CBS News - 1d
Goodwin loving life at 'overachieving' United

Dundee United manager Jim Goodwin says he has "loved every minute" of his two years at Tannadice and believes his team are overachieving at present. United host neighbours Dundee on Sunday and ...
Yahoo Sports - 6d
Caleb Love has seen plenty of Duke. And there's the potential for 1 more NCAA meeting

Caleb Love has already seen plenty of Duke in a five-year college career, even after transferring across the country from North Carolina to Arizona. “We’ve overcome so much adversity and hardship, ...
Yahoo Sports - 4d
Caleb Love has seen plenty of Duke. And there’s the potential for 1 more NCAA meeting

Caleb Love already has seen plenty of Duke in a five-year college career, even after transferring across the country from North Carolina to Arizona. He might not be done, either.
Yahoo Sports - 3d
Detroit Lions' NFL draft: 'Polarizing' Tennessee edge rusher James Pearce Jr. could fit

James Pearce Jr., a two-time all-SEC selection, had 19.5 sacks in his three-year career but has fallen out of the first round in some mock drafts
Yahoo Sports - 1d
RCB aim for first IPL title with 'more balanced' squad

Royal Challengers Bengaluru head coach Andy Flower says his squad is "more balanced" than previous editions of the Indian Premier League (IPL), which he hopes will deliver the franchise's first ...
Yahoo Sports - 3d
Family members of migrants deported to El Salvador mega prison speak out

Family members who suspect their loved ones were sent to El Salvador's mega prison fear they are wrongly being accused of being members of a Venezuelan gang. NBC News' Julia Ainsley has the details ...
NBC News - 2d
Eddie Howe could have been in Liverpool dugout if the pieces had fallen differently

Could Eddie Howe ever be Liverpool manager? Perhaps the moment has passed forever, and this job is now Arne Slot’s for the life cycle of this current team and beyond. Maybe Howe is bound to ...
Yahoo Sports - 5d
Young Americans lose trust in the state

Gallup poll highlights that confidence in the apparatus of government has fallen dramatically
Financial Times - 4d
Ex-Rams star has some advice for new WR Davante Adams

Jalen Ramsey apparently loved his time with the Rams.
Yahoo Sports - 5d
Does cricket risk apathy if status quo continues?

The Champions Trophy had its moments but familiar issues leave apathy as the biggest threat to international cricket's future, writes BBC Sport's Matthew Henry.
BBC News - Mar. 9
Why U.S. Conservatives Should Fall in Love With France

Turns out Charles de Gaulle was right.
The New York Times - Mar. 8
Watchdog investigating whether Defra breaking laws on cleaning up English rivers

Office for Environmental Protection says targets for water quality likely to be missed, and clarifying rules may help. The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) watchdog has launched an ...
The Guardian - 22h
Caleb Grill has brought his walls down

Dennis Gates describes himself as coaching through love first and that has helped Caleb Grill become his best self.
Yahoo Sports - 5d
The centuries that changed cricket (and a few that changed the world)

Wisden Cricket Monthly have selected the 100 hundreds that changed the game. Here’s a taster of the list. 107 Duke of Dorset’s XI v Wrotham The Vine, Sevenoaks August 1769 Continue ...
The Guardian - Mar. 13
Ian McKellen encourages fellow actors to come out: 'Being in the closet is silly'

English actor Ian McKellen called on closeted gay actors to “come out” and “get into the sunshine” in an interview published Sunday in The Times of London.
NBC News - Mar. 10
‘Modern Love’ Podcast: Natasha Rothwell on Figuring Out What She Wants In a Relationship

Natasha Rothwell, a star of “The White Lotus,” on what it took to figure out what she wanted in a relationship.
The New York Times - 1d
'Scotland's great survivor Hanley basks in battle'

Grant Hanley has been written off, left out and cast aside. But the 33-year-old was there again when Scotland needed him, writes Tom English.
Yahoo Sports - 10h
'Scotland's great survivor Hanley basks in battle'

Grant Hanley has been written off, left out and cast aside. But the 33-year-old was there again when Scotland needed him, writes Tom English.
BBC News - 11h
Ukrainian Svitolina has had 'massive support' in US

Ukrainian Elina Svitolina says she has received "love and support" from the US public during her run to the Indian Wells last eight.
BBC News - Mar. 12
Hojlund “fell in love with football” because of ex-Man Utd star who is everything to him

Rasmus Hojlund has said that he “fell in love with football” because of former Manchester United star Cristiano Ronaldo.The Red Devils’ young striker went 21 games without a goal in all competit...
Yahoo Sports - 2d
'The secret about how to play us is out'

Dons fans, we asked for your views on Saturday's goalless draw against St Johnstone. St Johnstone are one of those teams who seem to love zapping the energy out of games. The Dons were very poor ...
Yahoo Sports - 4d
Many young people find safety in the soothing world of ASMR – imagine if we could give them that in the real world | Emma Beddington

ASMR videos can mimic the feeling of physical touch, which a study has found is popular with young consumers. But how many intimate gestures of love, care and connection are they missing out on? . ...
The Guardian - 4d
NHL has met with Dan Friedkin's group about interest in bringing an expansion team to Houston

Friedkin, who has a net worth of $6.4 billion, according to Forbes, recently bought 98.8% interest in English Premier League club Everton.
Yahoo Sports - 9h
It's not a competition! The collaborative video game loved by players

Josef Fares has found big success with co-operative two player games. Why aren't others doing the same?
BBC News - 6d
English Champions Cup win would be 'miraculous' - Care

Harlequins scrum-half Danny Care says it would be "miraculous" if an English team won the Investec Champions Cup this season.
Yahoo Sports - 2d
Mets' Edwin Diaz has 'better' spring outing against Red Sox: 'From the first pitch, there was conviction'

Mets closer Edwin Diaz had his best outing this spring, throwing just 18 pitches to get three outs on Thursday against the Boston Red Sox.
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 13
'The Bondsman' star Kevin Bacon on the role he has no interest in resurrecting

In the L.A. Times studio at the 2025 SXSW Film and TV Festival, Bacon talked about 'The Bondsman,' 'Tremors' and his love for the Philadelphia Eagles.
Los Angeles Times - Mar. 7
REPO Has Come Out Of Nowhere On Steam, Topping 145,000 Concurrent Players

In less than two weeks, a new cooperative horror game called REPO on Steam has gone from 7,000 concurrent players to hitting over 145,000 users on Valve's platform (per SteamDB ). To call the ...
GameSpot - Mar. 11
What Is a Stock Market Correction?

The S&P 500 has fallen 10.1 percent from its recent high, crossing a threshold that signals investors have turned pessimistic about stocks.
The New York Times - Mar. 13
U.S. stock market loses $5 trillion in value in three weeks

The S&P 500 has fallen more than 10% from its record high, entering a correction and shedding trillions of dollars in market value.
CNBC - 6d
'Not a positive sign': Top Tesla officials sell shares in recent weeks

As Tesla stock has fallen in recent weeks, members of the board and an executive at Elon Musk's company have sold off millions of dollars in stock, according to filings.
ABC News - 2d
Can English teams win all three European competitions?

With five teams in the quarter-finals, can English sides win all three European competitions this season?
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 14