'Word salad' no more: Let go of the words and phrases dividing America
George Bernard Shaw was once quoted stating that "England and America are two nations divided by a common language." Today, America itself is divided by a common language. Reducing the division may help to close the vast gaps and polarization of the nation.
I have previously argued that dropping the adjective hyphen used to classify Americans by race, religion or nationality is essential. We are not white, Black or green Americans. We are plainly Americans. The sooner the nation can grasp that reality, the better off we will be.
That does not mean Americans cannot be proud of their ethnicity or background. But we need to be prouder of being Americans.
Unfortunately, this idea will be opposed on the grounds of insensitivity to identity politics. Identity in this case dominates unity and a sense of national pride. As long as emotion overrides rationality and common sense, the polarization of the nation will persist. And the national motto of “e pluribus unum” (one from many) is reversed to “ex uno plures” (many from one).
Two other phrases need to be exorcised from the political lexicon. The first is “word salad.” The second is “policy.”
"Word salad" is meant to describe incoherent and inchoate speech. The phrase, originally used by psychiatrists to describe babbling by mentally ill people, has gradually migrated into our political vocabulary.
If someone cannot speak basic English, why deny reality and slough off the comment as a word salad? Let’s call balls and strikes.
In last week’s debate, Donald Trump may have done a Biden and knocked himself out of contention. Although his MAGA supporters blindly agree with Trump that this was his “best debate,” he absurdly Hungary’s strong man Viktor Orbán as a reference and wrongly claiming Haitian immigrants were dining on pet dogs.
Trump, however, did coin an imaginative variant of word salad. He calls it a “weave.” In his weave, Trump zigs and zags to whatever crosses his mind in the course of answering even the simplest questions. And then he often fails to answer the question in the end.
The term “policy” likewise must go in the context of elections. Those who argue that debates should be about policy, what does that mean? Policy is not an aspiration, an idea or a wishful thought. It is a well-argued plan that matches aims with action. Lacking that, policy is a delusion.
“Close the border,” “end inflation,” “stop the wars in Gaza and Ukraine, “cure cancer” and similar phrases are statements of intent that cannot be seen as policy.
For example, how are the wars in Gaza and Ukraine going to be stopped? One historical analogy is the Korean War. Once United Nations forces were forced back from the Yalu River that divided Korea from China back to the 38th parallel separating North and South Korea, negotiations between China and U.N. forces began.
China was recalcitrant. It took months and much loss of life and bloodshed before a truce was put into place. Gaza and Ukraine have similar characteristics in terms of recalcitrant participants unwilling to negotiate.
In Gaza, it is not in the current interests of Hamas or Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to reach a truce or cease-fire. As long as Israel continues the war and Palestinian casualties mount, greater international condemnation will mount. The U.N. may attempt to pass a resolution calling for Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank. That favors Hamas.
Netanyahu faces an existential political threat to his leadership. His only option is to continue the war until Hamas is destroyed. Hence, the policy to end the war is vacuous until it establishes how Hamas and Netanyahu can come to terms.
In Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelensky and Vladimir Putin show no interest in negotiations. Ukraine wants its territory, particularly Crimea, returned. Putin wants to increase its influence and control over Ukraine. How are both parties going to be coerced or convinced that negotiations are of mutual interest?
To repeat, words count. Hyphenated adjectives, “word salad” and “policy” have become terms of division and dissension and not unity.
This may seem a secondary matter. After all, if these words were dropped from the lexicon would the divisions in the U.S. be lessened? Possibly not.
But it is a start. Correct use of language is crucial to a healthy democracy and to the telling of truth and fact. Without either, any nation is in trouble.
Harlan Ullman, Ph.D., is a senior adviser at the Atlantic Council and the prime author of the “shock and awe” military doctrine. His 12th book is “The Fifth Horseman and the New MAD: How Massive Attacks of Disruption Became the Looming Existential Danger to a Divided Nation and the World at Large."
Date: |
-
NBC News - Politics
Harris targets digital ads spotlighting her words about 'human suffering in Gaza'
Vice President Kamala Harris’ presidential campaign is running new digital spots targeting voters in heavily Arab American neighborhoods in the Detroit area, emphasizing Harris’ saying she “will ...Yesterday -
CBS Sports - Sports
Jalen Hurts vocal leader after Eagles' latest collapse: 'Jalen led everything ... no coach said a word'
'We know what we did was on us,' Reed Blankenship said after the 22-21 lossYesterday -
Inc. - Business
Considering a Big Career Change? Michelle Obama Said 16 Words You Need to Hear
Science shows we are often too reluctant to make big changes. This Michelle Obama quote is the antidote to hesitation.16 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Halle Berry on tackling fear in new film, "Never Let Go"
Academy Award-winner Halle Berry discusses her role in "Never Let Go," where she plays a mother convinced that a mysterious evil force has taken over the world. Berry speaks to "CBS Mornings" in ...Yesterday -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
On Target, Week 3: Go get Darnell Mooney, more fantasy football pass-catcher analysis
Fantasy football analyst Scott Pianowski debuts the 2024 edition of On Target!9 hours ago - Fantasy Football -
CBS Sports - Sports
Why Nick Sirianni feels even more confident about Eagles kicking FG instead of going for it in loss to Falcons
Sirianni said after reviewing the data, he was convinced about kicking6 hours ago - NFL -
The New York Times - Top stories
Arizona’s Mormon Voters Are Divided on Trump
American Mormon voters have traditionally voted Republican. But members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Arizona have become increasingly disillusioned by former President ...16 hours ago - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
North Carolina rafting trip seeks to bridge divides
A group of about 30 Americans with diverse political leanings recently embarked on a rafting trip along a North Carolina river. The goal of the journey wasn't to change minds or persuade anyone to ...Yesterday -
Inc. - Business
Corporate America Cares Less and Less About Inflation
Fewer S&P 500 companies are mentioning inflation during earnings calls ahead of the Fed's first rate cut.Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Republican Arizona county chair endorses Democrat to replace him
The Republican chair of the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors in Arizona has endorsed a Democrat to replace him. "I am endorsing Joel [Navarro] because he is a man of integrity, because he is a ...37 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Newark official wins special election to fill late New Jersey Rep. Payne's seat
Newark City Council President LaMonica McIver (D) has won the special election to fill a vacant House seat representing New Jersey’s 10th Congressional District, according to Decision Desk HQ. ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
RFK Jr. says he's helping Trump pick leaders of FDA, NIH, CDC
Former independent presidential candidate and antivaccine advocate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said that former President Trump wants him to choose leaders for key public health agencies if he wins the ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
EPA retaliated against three scientists, says watchdog
Presented by TerraPower — The Environmental Protection Agency’s internal watchdog has found that the agency retaliated against three staffers for expressing different scientific opinions. {beacon} ...2 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
House GOP torpedoes Speaker Johnson’s funding bill
House Republicans voted down Speaker Mike Johnson's proposal to fund the government, leaving the path to averting a shutdown unclear and putting Johnson in danger of disappointing former President ...2 hours ago - House