With student test scores flailing, DOGE cuts to Nation's Report Card raise red flags
Cuts to the Department of Education are hitting the highly valued Nation’s Report Card even as sirens blare on student test scores.
The 12th grade National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) was recently canceled, and the top official in charge of it was put on leave, leading advocates to doubt a promise from the Department of Education that NAEP would not be affected by the cuts from Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE).
“NAEP provides the only consistent, cross-state picture of student learning; the data is vital for understanding the effectiveness of education policies and ensuring that taxpayer dollars are invested in strategies that lead to improvement in teaching and learning outcomes,” said Auditi Chakravarty, CEO of the Advanced Education Research and Development Fund.
NAEP is the most comprehensive of such U.S. educational assessments, comparing scores across states and among decades of data
While the core NAEP assessment for fourth and eighth graders has yet to be affected, other parts of the national test have already seen changes.
The NAEP exam for 17-year-olds, which only occurs every four years, was canceled for 2025.
“NAEP is a valuable resource for educators, parents, and policymakers. The cancellation of the Long-Term Trend assessment of 17-year-olds is not unprecedented, it has been cancelled several times in the past," said Madi Biedermann, deputy assistant secretary for communications at the Department of Education. "Other NAEP longitudinal assessments are continuing as normal. We will continue to support NAEP access and transparency around student data."
And the exams that have been done have shown dismal results.
Both fourth and eighth graders in the NAEP results this year have seen further declines in reading. For those at the lowest level, scores dipped to the lowest in decades.
In math, fourth graders had a slight improvement, but still behind where they were before the pandemic, while eighth graders saw no change.
In both subjects, the gaps between the lowest-performing and highest-performing students are still growing.
“We know how important of a tool [NAEP] is, particularly as an equity measure, so we're on the lookout for any changes that can happen, and how that's going to affect our ability to assess how well district schools and states are providing services to the students that need them the most,” said Eric Duncan, director of P-12 policy at Ed Trust.
Peggy Carr, appointed by former President Biden to be the NAEP administrator after decades at the Department of Education, has been put on administrative leave, one of scores of agency staffers who may be in DOGE's crosshairs, though the department originally said NAEP would not be affected by the around $1 billion in cuts the agency has faced.
The results from the NAEP are highly anticipated every year as it avoids some of the critiques that state assessments of students' face.
EdTrust sees the NAEP scores as a check on state exams.
“State tests, for example, gauge performance against states’ curriculum standards, so they’re more closely tied to what students learn in the classroom than NAEP’s measures of more generic math and reading skills,” the organization said in an evaluation.
While experts say all assessments of students need to be constantly monitored and improved, what's happening to NAEP under the Trump administration is not transparent.
“We don't think that all the changes just need to be as vast and as big. I think the sort of structural component of having a national assessment that allows us to evaluate is so important,” said Duncan.
Mark Schneider, former director of the Institute for Education Sciences who served under President Trump’s first administration and part way through Biden’s, told education outlet The 74 that cuts to NAEP may come in response to its growth.
“NAEP is going to take a haircut. I don’t think there’s a question about that,” said Schneider about the national exam, which costs more than $170 million. “The question is ‘How do you prioritize what it does in a harsh fiscal environment?’”
“We’ve been doing main NAEP since the 1990s. Why do we need long-term trend tests?” he added. “NAEP has grown and grown and grown, and from my perspective, it’s way too expensive.”
Other experts say that just as important as preserving solid testing is acting effectively on its results.
“I am interested in seeing an appetite for evidence when it comes to education policy decisions. I would like to see continued investment in programs like NAEP. NAEP is a critical tool for providing transparency, informing education policy decisions, and examining long-term trends in student outcomes,” Chakravarty said.
Topics
-
Upside-down U.S flag hung at Yosemite National Park to protest employee cuts
Nature lovers flock to Yosemite National Park every February to witness the majestic "firefall" event, but this year’s crowds were met a different spectacle: an upside-down American flag hung on a ...NBC News - 6d -
Yosemite National Park workers hang upside-down U.S flag to protest cuts
A group of workers at California's Yosemite National Park positioned the U.S. flag on Saturday near the Horsetail Fall where crowds gather to witness Yosemite's annual firefall.CBS News - 6d -
Barcelona vs. Real Sociedad score, highlights: Early red card benefits first-place Barca in 4-0 win
Real Sociedad went down to 10 when Aritz Elustondo was sent off in the 17th minuteCBS Sports - 14h -
Rejecting Trump’s Call to Annex Their Nation, Canadians Rally Around the Flag
While Canadians are not generally known for flag waving, President Trump’s threats have led to a surge in flag sales and buffed up the national symbol’s image.The New York Times - 4d -
Evening Report —Trump, Musk defend DOGE as federal workforce braces for more cuts
{beacon} Evening Report TRUMP FIRST 100 DAYS © Andrew Harnik, Getty Images Trump, Musk defend DOGE as federal workforce braces for more cuts PRESIDENT TRUMP AND ELON MUSK united to defend the work ...The Hill - 4d -
The Red Card Fighting Trump’s Deportation Agenda
The “red card” lists practical tips and legal rights for immigrants who might find themselves targeted by federal agents. It has received nine million orders since Donald Trump was elected. Miriam ...The New York Times - Feb. 23 -
Antony available vs. Madrid as red card rescinded
Antony will be available to play for Real Betis against Real Madrid on Saturday after the Spanish football federation (RFEF) overturned his red card.ESPN - 4d -
A Trump DOGE Dividend Could Raise Inflation
President Trump floated giving taxpayers a piece of any savings that Elon Musk’s cost-cutting generates, which could reignite inflation.The New York Times - Feb. 20 -
DOGE is now dramatically raising the potential for a government shutdown
Adding Musk's cuts to spending talks could help satisfy hard-liners but alienate Democrats whose votes will be needed to fund the government.Politico - 3d
More from The Hill
-
Hochul seeks to recruit laid off federal workers with ad in Washington's Union Station
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul’s (D) office is running a digital ad in Washington, D.C.’s Union Station to recruit laid-off federal employees to work for New York State amid the Trump administration’s ...The Hill - 2h -
UK prime minister dismisses calls to cancel Trump visit after Zelensky meeting
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer dismissed calls to cancel President Trump’s invitation for a state visit to the United Kingdom, following the explosive Oval Office meeting with Ukrainian ...The Hill - 3h -
Conan O'Brien swipes at Trump with 'Anora' joke at Oscars: Americans 'excited to see somebody finally stand up to a powerful Russian'
Conan O'Brien is seemingly taking a knock at President Trump at the Oscars, saying audiences are happy to see fictional film characters stand up to "a powerful Russian." "You know 'Anora' is having ...The Hill - 3h -
'No Other Land' Oscar winners call for a different path on Israeli-Palestinian conflict
The filmmakers behind ‘No Other Land,’ which won the Oscar for best documentary, called for a different path forward to resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, in their acceptance speech ...The Hill - 3h -
Why Morgan Freeman wore a glove at the 2025 Oscars
Morgan Freeman has been known to wear a single glove at times.The Hill - 4h
More in Politics
-
Hochul seeks to recruit laid off federal workers with ad in Washington's Union Station
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul’s (D) office is running a digital ad in Washington, D.C.’s Union Station to recruit laid-off federal employees to work for New York State amid the Trump administration’s ...The Hill - 2h -
UK prime minister dismisses calls to cancel Trump visit after Zelensky meeting
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer dismissed calls to cancel President Trump’s invitation for a state visit to the United Kingdom, following the explosive Oval Office meeting with Ukrainian ...The Hill - 3h -
Conan O'Brien swipes at Trump with 'Anora' joke at Oscars: Americans 'excited to see somebody finally stand up to a powerful Russian'
Conan O'Brien is seemingly taking a knock at President Trump at the Oscars, saying audiences are happy to see fictional film characters stand up to "a powerful Russian." "You know 'Anora' is having ...The Hill - 3h -
'No Other Land' Oscar winners call for a different path on Israeli-Palestinian conflict
The filmmakers behind ‘No Other Land,’ which won the Oscar for best documentary, called for a different path forward to resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, in their acceptance speech ...The Hill - 3h -
Why Morgan Freeman wore a glove at the 2025 Oscars
Morgan Freeman has been known to wear a single glove at times.The Hill - 4h