Why Trump’s biggest ally could be Silicon Valley
For the past four years, the federal government has been at war with Big Tech. The explosive parting shot of President Biden’s Department of Justice is a bewildering lawsuit aiming to break up Google. The lawsuit contains a smorgasbord of proposals, including hiving off Chrome, which almost seem designed to undermine the American economy by dissuading investment, obstructing innovation and creating unnecessary obstacles for consumers accessing technology.
If Donald Trump continues the antitrust action he inherits from Biden, he will unnecessarily undermine economic growth. His political movement cannot survive that.
Trump has staked everything on the economy. He won the presidency thanks to high grocery prices. Although inflation is down, grocery prices will stay high, and his tariffs threaten to send prices of some items soaring again. Swing-state voters will notice if the cost of imported coffee, fruit, sugar and soap skyrockets. Trump therefore needs to bank some economic growth, to prevent the MAGA project dying in 2028.
Silicon Valley is the answer.
Big Tech is arguably America’s most successful export. Walk down the street in practically any country and you will see people using Google on their Android phones. Those who don’t use Android have iPhones. Countless millions use WhatsApp, which is part of Meta. They have Windows computers where they browse American websites using Google Chrome and Mozilla Firefox. Everywhere you look, in the furthest corners of the planet, people buy and use products from American Big Tech companies. Trump should lean into Silicon Valley, not shun it.
The second Trump administration already has something of a “tech bro” image. JD Vance, Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy are all closely associated with a certain type of Silicon Valley entrepreneur. Trump enjoyed endorsements from across the venture capital and crypto worlds, from Marc Andreessen to the Winklevoss twins.
However, it is up for debate whether the Trump brand of tech bro will ultimately benefit Silicon Valley. Earlier this year, Vance praised Lina Khan, Biden’s Federal Trade Commission chief, who has spent her time in office firing off destructive lawsuits of her own, aiming to break up successful American companies like Amazon.
It is in Trump’s interests to seize the narrative early on antitrust, rather than kicking the can down the road. Interventionists like Khan who deplore successful American enterprise and see new regulation as the solution to all society’s problems will not go into hiding over the next four years. If anything, their voices will get louder now they are outside the tent.
The antitrust Overton Window is sliding fast toward yet more state intervention in the market. Jonathan Haidt has become something of a thought leader in tech alarmism in recent years. In a recent Wired op-ed, he likens technology to alcohol, arguing regulators should prevent under-21s accessing much of the internet.
“The idea that parents alone should manage their children’s access to alcohol would have struck most people as absurd,” he writes. “Likewise, it will soon seem absurd that we once allowed children of any age to go everywhere on the internet that adults go.”
Besides the obvious fact that regulations aiming to restrict internet access rarely work — kids know their IPs from their VPNs and can easily circumvent restrictions — this kind of thinking mirrors European-style centrism, where economic growth is secondary to safety concerns. For Trump to align his administration with this anti-tech mentality would be absurd and self-defeating.
To follow through on his promises to the electorate of growth and prosperity, Trump should make a point of safeguarding and boosting America’s most successful industry. That starts with severing the spider’s web, where red tape enthusiasts try to use antitrust as a vehicle to grow the size of the state exponentially. It also means trashing the absurd proposal from the outgoing Biden DOJ to blow up Google.
Beyond saying no to these radical proposals from Silicon Valley’s enemies, making Big Tech’s success work for him requires little effort from Trump. While the rest of the world descends into a bottomless pit of regulation, he can sit back and watch as investment pours into the U.S. economy and a handful of tech companies continue to send the S&P 500 soaring.
That’s the wonder of the free market: it is most successful when the government expends little effort. Breaking up Google would take a huge amount of time and energy. The best thing the 78-year-old president-elect can do, for the economy and for the future of his movement, is nothing.
Jason Reed is a policy analyst and political commentator, who has contributed to more than 100 major media outlets across 15 countries. He is a spokesperson and project manager at Young Voices, a non-profit organization.
-
‘Why not us?’: Welsh language trio on their forthcoming double album
Post-punk band Adwaith will release their third album Solas, a Celtic word meaning enlightenment, in February. The idea of releasing a 23-track double album of pop and rock songs written entirely ...The Guardian - 2h -
In Gaza we were the happiest family I could imagine. Then came the worst days of my life | Fadwa al-Masry
I am an academic, a mother, no threat to anyone. Yet those I love have been injured and killed, and I have endured indescribable hardships. I am a Palestinian mother with a bachelor’s degree in ...The Guardian - 4h -
Why is VAT being added to private school fees?
The government says the rule change will raise £460m extra to spend in state schools in 2024/25.BBC News - 8h -
How tariffs could affect health care costs
{beacon} Health Care Health Care The Big Story How tariffs could affect health care costs President-elect Trump’s proposed tariffs on imports could drastically affect the cost of prescription ...The Hill - 10h -
Trump tariffs threaten pharmaceuticals
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Trump tariffs could upend pharma supply chain The hefty tariffs President-elect ...The Hill - 10h -
Evening Report — 2024's biggest moments
Plus: What to watch for in 2025 {beacon} Evening Report © AP Looking back: Biggest political moments of 2024 As 2024 comes to a close and we await the inauguration of the 47th president of the ...The Hill - 11h -
Trump endorses Johnson for speaker
Politico - 1d -
Why Employee Engagement Is a Top Priority for CEOs in the First 90 Days of 2025
Inc. - 1d -
Why Mick Cronin and Other College Basketball Coaches Still Wear Suits
Fashion among basketball coaches has been decidedly casual since the pandemic began, but a handful of college coaches are still dressed for success.The New York Times - 2d -
Why Kwanzaa Is Great
There’s something uniquely American in both its wanton borrowing from existing tradition and its naked admission of artificiality.The New York Times - 5d
More from The Hill
-
Trump says he thinks Johnson has the votes to get confirmed
President-elect Trump firmly believes House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) will get a second term. “No one else can get the votes,” he told reporters on Tuesday. On Monday, Trump offered Johnson his ...The Hill - 5h -
Trump taps creator of viral garbage truck photo op for executive producer position
President-elect Trump announced that Justin Caporale would join him as the executive producer for major events and public appearances while in office. “Justin Caporale has been with me right from ...The Hill - 6h -
Biden speaks to Puerto Rico Gov, Energy Secretary about power outages
President Biden said he spoke with the governor of Puerto Rico and the energy secretary after a blackout hit nearly all of the island early Tuesday morning. During their talk, Biden offered Puerto ...The Hill - 6h -
North Carolina Gov Cooper commutes sentences of 15 death row inmates on final day in office
North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper (D) on Tuesday commuted the death sentences of 15 inmates to life in prison without the possibility of parole, coinciding with New Year’s Eve and his final day in ...The Hill - 9h -
France's Macron acknowledges snap elections backfired
France’s President Emmanuel Macron admitted that his decision to hold parliamentary elections early caused instability in New Year's Eve comments. “Lucidity and humility force [me] to recognize ...The Hill - 10h
More in Politics
-
Trump says he thinks Johnson has the votes to get confirmed
President-elect Trump firmly believes House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) will get a second term. “No one else can get the votes,” he told reporters on Tuesday. On Monday, Trump offered Johnson his ...The Hill - 5h -
Trump taps creator of viral garbage truck photo op for executive producer position
President-elect Trump announced that Justin Caporale would join him as the executive producer for major events and public appearances while in office. “Justin Caporale has been with me right from ...The Hill - 6h -
Biden speaks to Puerto Rico Gov, Energy Secretary about power outages
President Biden said he spoke with the governor of Puerto Rico and the energy secretary after a blackout hit nearly all of the island early Tuesday morning. During their talk, Biden offered Puerto ...The Hill - 6h -
North Carolina Gov Cooper commutes sentences of 15 death row inmates on final day in office
North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper (D) on Tuesday commuted the death sentences of 15 inmates to life in prison without the possibility of parole, coinciding with New Year’s Eve and his final day in ...The Hill - 9h -
France's Macron acknowledges snap elections backfired
France’s President Emmanuel Macron admitted that his decision to hold parliamentary elections early caused instability in New Year's Eve comments. “Lucidity and humility force [me] to recognize ...The Hill - 10h