Why the prospects of the 25th Amendment being invoked on Biden is unlikely
![Why the prospects of the 25th Amendment being invoked on Biden is unlikely](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/biden_president-2158937079.jpg?w=900)
Since its ratification in 1967, the 25th Amendment has never received more attention than in recent years.
Beginning in 2018 with a then-“anonymous” op-ed that stated a secret group of Trump administration officials were considering invoking Section Four of the amendment to remove Trump from power, culminating with the events of Jan. 6, 2021, the only section of the amendment never to be invoked has been a popular topic of online searches, op-eds and punditry. (And for those of us who study the 25th Amendment, please know we appreciate your interest!)
The amendment is now back in the news following President Biden’s alarming debate performance last Thursday, which has led to calls for its consideration by House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.), among others. However, as during the Trump administration, this attention ignores the requirements of invoking Section Four.
Since the drafting of the Constitution, the guidelines for removing a president due to a disability have presented a myriad of constitutional challenges. However, following President Dwight Eisenhower’s heart attack in 1955, followed by a 1957 stroke which temporarily robbed him of the ability to speak, the ever-present threat of a Cold War confrontation necessitated a mechanism for removing a president who was either unable or unwilling to admit to his own incapacitation.
Cognizant of this danger, Eisenhower entered into an agreement with Vice President Richard Nixon that would allow Nixon to temporarily assume the presidency if Eisenhower were incapacitated, following “ such consultation as seems to him appropriate under the circumstances.”
Following the assassination of John F. Kennedy in 1963, Congress finally turned its attention to the perils of executive disability and succession. However, the process for removing a democratically elected president from office raised a number of dangers. Specifically, who was best suited to judge a president’s ability while at the same time preventing a power grab by a would-be successor? Subsequently, the decision was made to vest such a power within the Cabinet, while providing Congress with the power to arbitrate any disputes between a president and the Cabinet concerning the president’s ability to discharge the duties of office.
As a result, invoking Section Four requires the vice president and a majority of the Cabinet to declare the president unable to discharge the duties of office. Thus, both Vice President Kamala Harris and a majority of the Biden-appointed Cabinet would have to declare a belief that Biden is mentally unfit to discharge his duties. This is the first and most significant hurdle, as any vice president will be inherently reluctant to level such a claim, due to perceptions of being a usurper to the Oval Office.
Therefore, it would likely fall to a member of the Cabinet to raise such a concern. If that scenario seems plausible, ask yourself which member or members of the Biden Cabinet would dare to raise the prospect of not only removing Biden from power but also ending his reelection chances and casting the Democratic Party into a state of chaos just four months before Election Day.
And while the bedlam of an open convention in August would present a political sideshow the likes of which we have not seen in generations, it would pale in comparison to what would occur if Biden challenged his Cabinet’s decision.
In that scenario, Vice President Harris and a majority of the Cabinet would transmit a letter to Congress declaring their belief that Biden is unable to discharge the duties of his office, thus making Harris acting president. However, Biden could then transmit his own letter stating he is indeed able to discharge his duties, thus restoring himself to the presidency.
At that point, Harris and the Cabinet could overrule Biden with another letter and return Harris to the role of acting president. Were this to unfold, both the House and Senate would then have 21 days to determine whether Biden was capable of serving as president, with both chambers needing two-thirds majorities to remove Biden from power.
While this scenario would make for an excellent arc of episodes on “The West Wing” or “House of Cards,” the prospect of it unfolding in front of the nation is alarming, to say the least.
However, the remarkably high threshold for removing an elected president in the midst of his term was exactly what the drafters of the 25th Amendment had in mind when they created a mechanism that would be utilized in only the most extreme of circumstances. And while the guidelines of the amendment only require a majority of the Cabinet’s support, it is next to impossible to imagine a divided Cabinet seeking to undertake such an arduous task without widespread support both inside and outside of the executive branch.
Therefore, while the calls for invoking Section Four of the 25th Amendment may again be loud, the prospects of these calls emanating from within the Biden administration are virtually nil.
Jim Ronan, P.hD., is an adjunct professor of political science at Villanova University and the author of “Living Dangerously: The Uncertainties of Presidential Disability and Succession.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Joe Biden |
Topics
Filter
-
CBS News - Top stories
Why Trump's "hush money" sentencing is being delayed over immunity ruling
Donald Trump's sentencing for the conviction in his New York "hush money" trial is being postponed until September after his lawyers moved to toss the guilty verdict because of the Supreme Court's presidential immunity ruling. Attorney and CBS ...Donald Trump -
MarketWatch - Business
Betting markets give Harris better chance of being Democratic nominee than Biden
Vice President Kamala Harris on Wednesday moved ahead of President Joe Biden in some betting markets as to who would be the candidate to take on former President Donald Trump in the presidential election.Joe Biden -
The Wall Street Journal - World
The WSJ Dollar Index Falls 0.2% to 100.25
The WSJ Dollar Index was down 0.2% to 100.25 — down for two consecutive trading days. -
ABC News - Entertainment
Why was it a surprise? Biden's debate problems leave some wondering if the press missed the story
Did the media covering President Biden miss a story that was right in front of themJoe Biden -
ESPN - Sports
Sources: NBA prospect Pate, 18, joins Capitanes
Dink Pate, who became the youngest known pro basketball player in U.S. history last year at age 17, is joining the G League's Mexico City Capitanes, sources told ESPN.NBA -
The New York Times - Sports
How Soccer Is Being Used to Influence the U.K. Election
The leaders of the two biggest political parties are tapping into the sport’s reach to target voters ahead of polling day on July 4.United Kingdom -
NBC News - Top stories
Abortion rights amendment is one step closer to appearing on Arizona's ballot
A proposed amendment to enshrine access to abortion in Arizona’s constitution is one step closer to appearing on the November 2024 ballot.Abortion -
CBS News - Top stories
Arizona abortion rights advocates submit signatures to put amendment on ballot
Organizers with Arizona for Abortion Access said they submitted more than 823,000 signatures supporting a ballot initiative that would enshrine abortion rights in the state constitution.Abortion -
ABC News - World
Slovakia's top court approves key parts of a contentious amendment of the penal code
Slovakia’s highest legal authority has ruled that key provisions of a contentious amendment of the penal code drafted by the government of populist Prime Minister Robert Fico are in line with the country's constitution -
ABC News - Top stories
12-year-old missing after being attacked and taken by crocodile: Report
Police in Australia have launched a search for a missing 12-year-old after reports that they were attacked and taken by a crocodile while swimming in a creek.
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
More states on track to have abortion measures on ballot
Click in for more news from The Hill {beacon} Health Care Health Care The Big Story More states on track to have abortion measures on ballot Ballot measures in Arizona and Nebraska ensuring abortion access advanced closer to a vote, with groups ...Abortion -
The Hill - Politics
Fauci says he has 'no doubt' Biden is capable of continuing as president
Former White House chief medical adviser Anthony Fauci said in a new interview he has “no doubt” President Biden is mentally capable of serving as president, amid growing concern among Democrats about the president’s standing as the party’s ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Congress fights nonconsensual deepfakes
Welcome to The Hill's Technology newsletter {beacon} View Online Technology Technology The Big Story Congress to combat nonconsensual AI porn Political momentum is building to regulate the spread of nonconsensual explicit deepfakes as the ... -
The Hill - Politics
White House seeks to stop the bleeding amid new calls for Biden drop-out
The White House and Biden campaign sought to stop the bleeding on Wednesday, forcefully saying the president will not be dropping out of the race after a disastrous debate underscored concerns about his age and ability to serve. Allies and staff ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Federal judge issues narrow pause on FTC noncompete ban
A federal judge on Wednesday granted a preliminary injunction on a nationwide ban on noncompete agreements issued this spring, calling into question its future in the face of opposition by prominent business groups. The Dallas-based tax firm Ryan ...