Why Putin needs Trump to win
In Ukraine, the fickle fortunes of war have turned in Russia’s favor. The invaders have seized the military initiative, while a Trumpified Republican Party has thrown in doubt both America’s commitment to a free Ukraine and our will to confront a new Russian imperialism.
For the moment, however, GOP House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) has managed to unsnag more than $60 billion in long-stalled U.S. military aid that Ukraine desperately needs to defend itself against a Russian summer offensive.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov recently confirmed Moscow’s plan to seize Kharkiv, Ukraine’s second-largest city. Exploiting their advantages in manpower and missiles, willingness to take casualties and Ukraine’s dire shortage of artillery shells, Russian forces lately have made significant if costly advances near Bakhmut, Avdiivka and Donetsk City.
Although I’m loathe to praise any 2020 election denier, Speaker Johnson acted patriotically, if belatedly, in bringing the aid package to the House floor and passing it with Democratic help.
Last weekend’s rare triumph of strategic clarity over MAGA tribalism in the GOP-controlled House is certainly a setback for Moscow. But Russian ruler Vladimir Putin is still counting on a Trump victory in November to take America off the field, thereby demoralizing our NATO allies and allowing him to grind Ukraine into submission, Chechnya-style.
Conversely, if Trump loses, Putin loses too. So long as America and Europe keep providing arms, money and political backing to Kyiv, the best outcome he can hope for is a bloody stalemate.
In this test of wills between Putin and the West, neither the balance of national resources nor the asymmetry of sacrifices favors the Kremlin warlord.
The NATO partners are sacrificing a small increment of their vastly superior collective wealth, and no lives, to help Ukraine resist being gobbled up piecemeal by Russia. Meanwhile, Moscow’s “meat grinder” tactics already have claimed the lives of 50,000 soldiers.
Putin rules by fear, but such terrible losses likely aren’t sustainable if Russian society sees no path to victory.
In truth, the new infusion of U.S. weapons is more of a reprieve for Kyiv than a game-changer. It will plug gaps in Ukraine’s defenses, but it won’t be enough to uproot the Russian occupation.
Crucially, however, it keeps America in the fight. That will encourage our European partners to ramp up weapons production and deliveries and boost morale in Ukraine, which is struggling to call up enough military-age men to offset Russia’s preponderant troop strength.
U.S. opposition to Russia’s serial aggression shouldn’t be controversial. Embittered by the Soviet Union’s collapse, Putin has invaded no less than three neighboring countries — Chechnya, Georgia and Ukraine, twice — in pursuit of his dream of resurrecting “Greater Russia.”
If he succeeds in Ukraine, few doubt that Putin will turn his acquisitive gaze to Europe. Moldova, outside of the European Union and NATO, and with a sizeable minority of ethnic Russians, already feels the heat.
Although they are NATO members, the Baltic States are also worried about internal agitation by Russian separatists. As my Progressive Policy Institute colleague Tamar Jacoby found on a recent visit there, Poland is spending heavily on defense to deter what President Andrzej Duda recently called “insatiable Russian imperialism.”
Putin bears a deep historical grudge against the United States, which he sees as the chief obstacle to his expansionist vision. He’s flooding our country with disinformation intended to inflame racial and political tensions, stoke fears about an alien invasion across the border, paint Ukraine as hopelessly corrupt and amplify isolationist voices.
"Russian propaganda has made its way into the U.S., unfortunately, and it's infected a good chunk of my party's base," laments Rep. Michael McCaul (R-Texas), chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee.
The House vote revealed a GOP split between Trump’s “America First” camp and conservative internationalists in the Reagan mold. In siding with the latter, Johnson incurred the wrath of Freedom Caucus bomb throwers threatening to force a vote on ousting him as Speaker.
Although Trump uncharacteristically sat this fight out, just over half (112) of House Republicans voted against Ukraine aid.
Many insisted that securing the border is a higher priority. But that objection fizzled after Johnson, at Trump’s behest, refused last February to take up a bipartisan Senate bill that included $20 billion for border security.
Other America Firsters echo Trump in contending that America has no vital interest in Ukraine’s independence, that Putin is entitled to a free hand in Moscow’s “sphere of influence” and that Washington should let Europe worry about Ukraine and focus on the Chinese threat instead.
Sen. J.D. Vance (R-Ohio), who appears to be grooming himself to be Trump’s successor as the top prophet of MAGA populism, contends that Ukraine is simply too weak to defend itself against Russia, even with U.S. help.
“This $60 billion is a fraction of what it would take to turn the tide in Ukraine’s favor. But this is not just a matter of dollars. Fundamentally, we lack the capacity to manufacture the amounts of weapons Ukraine needs us to supply to win the war.”
Vance’s defeatism calls to mind U.S. Ambassador Joseph Kennedy’s dispatches from wartime London aimed at convincing President Roosevelt that Britain could not hold out against the might of Nazi Germany.
Then there’s Trump’s grandiose promise, should he win in November, to negotiate a swift end to the war. His plan reportedly is to force Ukraine to cede Crimea and large chunks of eastern Ukraine to Russia.
Thus does appeasement march under the “America First” banner alongside isolationism and defeatism. If Trump returns to the White House, we’ll hear corks popping in Moscow as well as Mar-a-Lago.
Will Marshall is the founder and president of the Progressive Policy Institute.
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
Filter
-
Secure at Home, Putin Builds on the Alliances He Needs to Prevail in Ukraine
Vladimir Putin was inaugurated as Russia’s president for another six-year term and is now focused squarely on the war in Ukraine—and the alliances he needs to secure a victory.The Wall Street Journal - World - Ukraine -
Stabilizing crime victims' funding is a win America’s kids desperately need
The act calls attention to the threat facing victims of violent crimes and asks for support to save the fund that offers those victims justice and healing.The Hill - Politics -
Trump Knows Dominance Wins. Someone Tell Democrats.
Politics is a competition to dominate. Liberals have their own tradition of it — and they should embrace it.The New York Times - Top stories - Donald Trump -
‘A colonial mindset’: why global aid agencies need to get out of the way
With the world’s humanitarian system in crisis, many NGOs now recognise that local charities can deliver much more at far less cost. Before civil war engulfed her Ethiopian home region of Tigray in 2020, Tsega Girma was a prosperous trader who ...The Guardian - World -
Trump vs Biden: who is winning with six months to go?
Despite the Republican candidate’s criminal charges, the US election is on a knife edgeFinancial Times - Business - Donald Trump -
NY Times editor: Not media's job to prevent Trump from winning
The executive editor of The New York Times is saying it's not up to the news organization he runs, or any other, to stop former President Trump from winning a second term in office this fall. "So there are people out there in the world who may ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Trump voters skeptical that Biden could legitimately win reelection in 2024
Many of former President Donald Trump’s supporters across the country do not believe that President Biden could win the 2024 election without “rigging” the election in his favor, reports NBC News campaign embed Alex Tabet.NBC News - Politics - Joe Biden -
The big idea: why we need human rights now more than ever
In an age of climate crisis and AI, equal treatment is nothing less than essential. In the three decades since I became a lawyer, human rights – once understood as an uncomplicated good, a tool for securing dignity for the vulnerable against ...The Guardian - World -
Sen. Scott refuses to say he will accept 2024 election results, says Trump will win
In an interview with Meet the Press, Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.) avoids giving a direct answer when asked if he would accept the results of the 2024 election.NBC News - Politics - Donald Trump -
Brad Parscale helped Trump win in 2016 using Facebook ads. Now he’s back, and an AI evangelist
The digital campaign operative who helped engineer Donald Trump’s 2016 presidential victory with the heavy use of Facebook ads is back working for Trump and is an evangelist for artificial intelligenceABC News - Tech - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
Most expect Trump to be convicted in hush money trial: Poll
Most registered voters say they expect former President Trump to be convicted on some or all counts in his ongoing hush money criminal trial in New York, according to a poll released Tuesday. The Suffolk University/USA Today survey, conducted from ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Biden will either toughen up on the border or lose reelection
An election that looks, in great part, like a referendum on immigration is one he can’t win — unless he does something about it.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Trump comes face-to-face with porn star Stormy Daniels on the stand: Live updates
Former President Trump has come face-to-face with porn actor Stormy Daniels, who has taken the stand in his hush money case. Daniels is so-far the highest-profile witness in the Manhattan district attorney’s prosecution of Trump over a $130,000 ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Stormy Daniels, porn actor central to Trump’s hush money trial, takes the stand
Stormy Daniels, the porn actor paid hush money to keep an alleged affair with Donald Trump secret ahead of the 2016 election, has taken the stand Tuesday in the former president’s New York criminal trial. Daniels, wearing black with her hair in a ...The Hill - Politics -
Slowing America's migrant and drug crises starts with helping Guatemala
As Central America’s largest nation, a free Guatemala can serve as a beacon of liberty in a region ruled by authoritarian governments.The Hill - Politics